Tumbleweed

Regina, Canada

Joined : 26th Nov 2010 - 15 years ago

Last Online : 28th Jun 2026 - 1 week ago

Loops Out

Tumbleweed comments on tracks

Tumbleweed has posted 1619 comments on other peoples tracks.

Comments 776 - 800 of 1,619

Tumbleweed 29th Apr 2014 18:08 - 12 years ago

on lets forget about my inconvincible father by ElenaSatine

I am way late in catching up with this one Elena...but glad I finally did...this is good rocking stuff...reminds me just a little of a group I used to listen to a long time ago (Steppenwolf) who did many of my fav rock songs...good straignt forward arrangement..those little drops/breaks work well...You should finish this one...some banging drums would be great and maybe a couple of short screaming lead parts...well done ladyinred......Ed

ElenaSatine replied 6th May 2014 - 12 years ago

:) Ed I'm proud of your kind words .
about drum i wish someone can help me ...
i'm not really good abiut beats ...
and regarding screaming lead i wished someone like Behnam or you was kind enough to do that !
cause i can't play lead guitar.
Ed thank you much much for the words.
i appreciate your time and comment .
:) Elena

Tumbleweed 29th Apr 2014 17:51 - 12 years ago

on MAKE THAT NEEDLE BOUNCE by beerling1970

This one could easily cross over to the pop charts too Steve..its got all the elements...the beat..the sounds...the hook...the catchy vocals...nicely produced too by the way..levels are up there but the dynamics havent been limited to death...missed this one while I was away, so good to catch up with some of my favs (still working on that)....great job...hope the Spring sun is shining on you over there...Ed

beerling1970 replied 1st May 2014 - 12 years ago

Thanks Ed :) glad your back mate

Steve

Tumbleweed 29th Apr 2014 03:43 - 12 years ago

on Hypnotic Larry Wiggles aka Mark Jeffries by larrywiggles1

Like many of us...you are likely your own harshest critic Mark...this is good stuff mate...I know...I listened through to the last note & enjoyed every funky hopping pop minute,,...an eclectic mix of instruments and nicely produced....keep them coming...you obviously had a lot of gems you were keeping to yourself....well done...Ed

larrywiggles1 replied 29th Apr 2014 - 12 years ago

Hi Ed,

A big thank you as always for your kind, positive but always honest comments. I am really pleased you liked and yes I have a store of earlier work, but feedback at the time was negative so I mothballed them and saved most as mp3's but have lost a lot of the original wav files. I decided to give them an airing on looperman so I could have some constructive feedback!!

Great to hear from you again Ed and take care.

Very best wishes,

Mark/Larry!

Tumbleweed 29th Apr 2014 03:27 - 12 years ago

on Shamanic Voyage The After Dark Glow by brillbilly

hot damn (its a prairie saying borrowed from some old Americal western I think...) you`ve got some extra cool sounds going on here...you gotta be having a good day my friend...this is uplifting crazy good stuff..I`m just checking to see if its downloadable...yep...so thanks for that as well as the good listening....that is one grooving shaman....and he ends on a nice peaceful note...so good night......great track...fav....Ed

brillbilly replied 29th Apr 2014 - 12 years ago

Awwwww bless ya!

i have a great love for all our Ancient Ancesters.!

Shame so many people care not,and only seek War.!

Thank you for taking this vouyage Ed.!

On we push my friend,another day another dollar lol

***chris***

Tumbleweed 28th Apr 2014 18:29 - 12 years ago

on Bad Boy Sound by FreeRadical

I just had to go and read your profile page (again) FR...and its been well worth the read every time so far..haha...and about the music.....I know squat about DnB so I`m just listening...(my body would hurt too much if I tried dancing to it on a Monday morning)...its got big fat production values and I note that you hit it hard with the limiting that seems to be a common part of the genre...I can tell you were having fun doing this one....it was a fun listen too (woke me right up)......Ed

FreeRadical replied 28th Apr 2014 - 12 years ago

Yeah, it's probably about time i updated that profile page as those jokes are pretty darn old now.
As for the track i'm glad you listened to it but i have a better version that i've been trying to upload for about an hour and a half. It's really winding me up now!
Anyway, thank you for playing my row of a tune, i know it's not really your thing so that makes it that little bit more special.
FR

Tumbleweed 28th Apr 2014 18:07 - 12 years ago

on Silent Spotlight by AviatOfficial

Hi Advait07...I am not a good source of advice on the genre...but I think you are off to a good start and I notice that you have already received some useful comments & suggestions...I am always in agreement with those who suggest variation and structure in compositions as it tends to make the mix more interesting as listening music as well...good for you...keep it going...Ed

Tumbleweed 28th Apr 2014 17:58 - 12 years ago

on domrorchestra by domr30

a really good combination of the dramatic and quieter moments...superbly done domr...and I particularly like the piano - strings combination...excellent production....Ed

domr30 replied 29th Apr 2014 - 12 years ago

merci pour l ecoute et le commentaire domr

Tumbleweed 28th Apr 2014 03:32 - 12 years ago

on Night rain by Anubis

an interesting combination of the big rich sounds (a little dark) with the airy sounds and lighter contrasting arp...well done Anubis...I enjoyed this one....Ed

Anubis replied 28th Apr 2014 - 12 years ago

I'm really glad you enjoyed it.

This ambience is not very complex, just consider the feeling.
are interesting elements to mix.
your words are very welcome my friend.
Thank you for taking the time to listen to this composition.

Tumbleweed 28th Apr 2014 03:28 - 12 years ago

on Distant Footsteps Nocturne by Orlando51

ah yes...this is the kind of musical trip that makes you set aside less important things and remember that you are on a short journey on this little beautiful planet filled with many wonderful things that are there to be found by those who can let the noise and darkness of the self-interested minority and political power players fall aside...I listened to this a while back Orlando, but didn`t have the chance to leave a few comments...superbly done...Ed

Orlando51 replied 28th Apr 2014 - 12 years ago

Thx alot Ed...I didn't know you've already checked it out, otherwise I wouldn't be bothering you. This piece of music will leave some memories for me in the sense how it has been done. I did the whole thing in one or two hours. It was an incredible experience. I did the complete lenght basic track in one single take, which is incredible. I just did some overdubs later on. In fact it was like uninterupted live session. It just happened that magical night when my emotions and my fingers on the keyboard were in perfect harmony. This just can't be repeated! It was one off experience.
Thanks again for your kindness...

All the best____Orlando

Tumbleweed 26th Apr 2014 04:18 - 12 years ago

on Deep waters by Anubis

Orlando is always good musiscal company Anubis...but must say you did a really nice job on this one...ambient music is for the restful mind..(not for people with cluttered minds looking for an adventure) and this one does it just fine...well done......Ed

Anubis replied 26th Apr 2014 - 12 years ago

many thanks to you my friend, I'm very glad you like it.
On this site we met people with incredible talent, who bring inspiration, good stuff, among other things.
not always the most upbeat songs has the same enthusiasm that an ambient music, feelings may be different in musical genres.
depends on the composition. ,D
thank you for leave a comment here,for all support

Sorry my english.

All the best.

Tumbleweed 6th Apr 2014 20:30 - 12 years ago

on Spivkurl vs DeciBel - Hidden Locked Tight by Spivkurl

Really interesting track Spiv...I knew it would be when I read that you and Behnam were mixing it up...definite industrial backing and a bit dark/ominous..The vocal is quite a contrast..not so much the lyrics...but it has a lighter vibe and your vocal character puts a more upbeat vibe to it in spite of the darkness of the words...I guess it just continues to prove that music can paint some very complex pictures for the mind of the listener...Music for thinking people...that is a very creative kind of accomplishment....a well done to you and Behnam...Ed

Spivkurl replied 13th Apr 2014 - 12 years ago

Your comment made my day friend! I hadn't really thought about the feelings you got from the vibe of the vocals and stuff. I think the lyrics are pretty basic averall, but I tried to inject the light and dark of life into them. I appreciate you listening to some unusual styles. Thanks very much!

Tumbleweed 5th Apr 2014 02:54 - 12 years ago

on Fannie Maes Funky Lil Dance Number by ScottB55

Time Of The Seasons has been a long time fav of mine Scott (watched them play it live a while back) so your wee doggie & I might get along well...a bit of a similar vibe here obviously even though its a much different track...great stuff...and kudos on the production on this one...you obviously put a lot of talent into that as well as the music....Ed

ScottB55 replied 6th Apr 2014 - 12 years ago

Thank you, Ed...You're so kind with your comment. Much appreciated.

Cheers,
Scott

Tumbleweed 4th Apr 2014 03:47 - 12 years ago

on Lies 3rd by MisterCH

its got a kind of comfortable classic rock vibe too CH...and a lot of the things I enjoy listening to in it...well done (again)....Ed

MisterCH replied 4th Apr 2014 - 12 years ago

Thanks! I'm glad you liked it

Tumbleweed 4th Apr 2014 03:43 - 12 years ago

on Still Running by locatednowhere

heavy stuff locatednowhere....that little break at 1:55 works well....you should be getting more plays, but I guess LM doesn`t have a lot of metal fans...its always good for those times when you need a heavy rock fix...keep on...Ed

locatednowhere replied 4th Apr 2014 - 12 years ago

Thank you for listening the track =] i appreciate it

Tumbleweed 3rd Apr 2014 04:05 - 12 years ago

on Angels by BearAustin

I see I`m late catching up with this one but really glad I finally did...just a fantastic bit of musical work BearAustin...very pro sounding all around...much enjoyed...definite fav.......well done....Ed

Tumbleweed 2nd Apr 2014 19:57 - 12 years ago

on Funky Stuff - Added Vocals by Tatiacha

hell yeh....nice funky uplifting little tune that sails right along with nary a care in the world....good for you Tatiavha...keep on doing your thing...neat ending with the digeridoo sound & laughs...party time......Ed

Tumbleweed 1st Apr 2014 17:29 - 12 years ago

on I Know You by MisterCH

you had me hooked right at the intro with that acoustic guitar MisterCH...you have a unique vocal character (and its not something that can be learned or bought) that catches attention...very vice job on this one...I dont mind reverb, but a little less on this one would be better...and thats just a personal taste thing....well done...Ed

MisterCH replied 1st Apr 2014 - 12 years ago

Thanks for listening!
And yes, I actually agree with you. When I put the reverb effect, I found it pretty cool, probably because I'd never really done it before, but now I think the song would be better off without it or, at least, with more subtlety to it.

Tumbleweed 31st Mar 2014 23:35 - 12 years ago

on Wont Get Old Anymore by MWRatridge

It sounds good ...it feels good...and it is good...really like this one Mark...I`m into acoustic these days (although I just sold my Martin to a guy who loved it more than me) so this one fills the bill really well...Ed

MWRatridge replied 1st Apr 2014 - 12 years ago

Ed,
Great to hear from you. TY sir.
Mark.

Tumbleweed 31st Mar 2014 04:01 - 12 years ago

on Sleep by topvega

you`re reminding me of that old rock feeling Topvega....if it aint rock it aint music...my tastes may have mellowed a lot but the straight up rock & roll done guitar band style always rings the bell for good times...good stuff..not intended as a criticism (I enjoyed the listen big time) but if you backed off the hard limiting a bit (or used a softer knee) I think the lead guitar dynamics might pop a little more....keep on man....Ed

topvega replied 2nd Apr 2014 - 12 years ago

Thanks for the tip Ed, I will give that a try. Kind of you to give it a listen and for leaving a comment. Every time I think my tastes are mellowing a bit I seem to find a new band that reignited that hard rock vibe in me. Latest has been WolfMother. Thanks again for the kind words.

tv

Tumbleweed 31st Mar 2014 03:45 - 12 years ago

on Couldnt Care Less Featuring Improve With Error by Merchaholic

hip hop bounced up above the bar...and you`ve got some really good company on this one Merchaholic...well done...Ed

Merchaholic replied 31st Mar 2014 - 12 years ago

Thank you good sir!

Tumbleweed 31st Mar 2014 03:39 - 12 years ago

on Gentle Persuasion by Tatiacha

Your musical imagination is working well Tatiacha...well done...enjoyed this one...Ed

Tatiacha replied 31st Mar 2014 - 12 years ago

thanks, working on one right now with one of your guitar parts. :-)

Tumbleweed 30th Mar 2014 19:45 - 12 years ago

on Ups And Downs by Lithman

that little section at 1:07 with the pizz strings works a treat..the piano & strings really are a nice combination for this one...thoughtfully composed and really well done...enjoyed this one Rick.....Keep on....Ed

Tumbleweed 30th Mar 2014 19:33 - 12 years ago

on Minus - Ohgr Cover by Spivkurl

Hey Spiv....you better move up here....I think we`re the only area in North America that never changes time...haha...gotta say I enjoyed this one...I think its likely got a little more of the rock in it that most of the industrial I`ve listened to...and its well done...has a touch of the rough edge that lets it come off very naturally...you could have told me you spent ages on it & I would have accepted that too....good stuff Spiv....Ed

Spivkurl replied 5th Apr 2014 - 12 years ago

Thanks my friend for your kind thoughts! I just today realized that the falacy of time has been on my mind for far longer than when I was DJ'ing to other time zones. I'm happy to have a common vein of thought in recent works, even though this is a cover. I just haven't adjusted to modern changes in reality I guess, glad I'm not the only one! See you in a moment!

Tumbleweed 30th Mar 2014 02:23 - 12 years ago

on Relax by DESTERO

hell yeah....you can play this on my radio all day Destro...just dm good laid back listening with a touch of slow funk and a dash of rock & maybe a dab of R&B all throw in...really lie the vocal bit too...great job...keep em coming....Ed

DESTERO replied 31st Mar 2014 - 12 years ago

Thanks so much,
awesome (for me) Feedback!!

Tumbleweed 30th Mar 2014 02:16 - 12 years ago

on On the Road by MisterAllea

Like the minor chords..I think I start about 90% of my tunes in a minor...the piano and strings accompaniment is a wonderful combination for emotional/expressive music and seems to generate a little meloncholy...very nicely done MisterAllea...enjoyed this one......Ed

Comments 776 - 800 of 1,619