Tumbleweed

Tumbleweed

Regina, Canada
Joined : 26th Nov 2010 - 15 years ago
Last Online : 2nd Oct 2026 - 4 days ago
Tumbleweed comments on tracks

Tumbleweed has posted 1544 comments on other peoples tracks.

Comments 276 - 300 of 1,544
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 3rd Aug 2016 04:08 - 10 years ago

on Have A Good Time by Musicante
always good music at your place...this one is different for you guys but as usual the fine musicianship is always evident...I`ve been paying more attention to Dan`s sax work lately....tell him I`m definitely a fan...very talented player....but, guess that goes for the whole group....time to take it on tour guys....This one really moves...enjoyed the trip....Ed
Musicante
Musicante replied 7th Sep 2016 - 10 years ago
Hi Ed,

Sorry for the delay in reply. We've had a bunch of things happening lately. Again, your kind words are very inspiring to us all and we thank you.

Ciao,
M.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 14th Jul 2016 02:50 - 10 years ago

on The Land Of Ill Gotten Gains by Evisma
Great intro...and then into a kind of lilting quality...I like the way the crystal melody lines fly above that big rich paddy background...very tasty guitar bits really work a treat Evan...There is something of a Celtic vibe to my ears...from the melody lines I think...that picked up change around 3:30 is great..it changes the whole vibe of the track yet maintains the theme...The mix is perfect...This is just a really well done piece of music...and I enjoyed it....big fav....Ed
Evisma
Evisma replied 14th Jul 2016 - 10 years ago
Greetings, Mr. Ed.

Glad you liked the track. bought a small lamp for the music room to use instead of the bright overhead fixture. The lamp gives the room a softer, more intimate feel, and brought out the guitar lines. Strange, I know, but it was a big change to my feelings while writing. Not sure if that makes sense, but yeah. Softly lit studio brought on a softer song. What would a strobe, blacklight and discoball do?!

I hope all is well with you.

Evan
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 12th Jul 2016 22:15 - 10 years ago

on Marys Black Lamb by Tinka0
Hey Met...I`m diggin this one...Mary actually did have a little lamb..If I can`t come up with a melody in my head when I`m playing I just recite one of those little old nursery rhymes to myself while I play so I don`t hit more notes than necessary..man...this is creative stuff (not the usual canned stuff we hear a lot of on radios)...I really respect artists who create their own sounds rather than try to emulate ones we heard already...great job....Ed
Tinka0
Tinka0 replied 13th Jul 2016 - 10 years ago
That's not a bad idea! I usually just go with the flow and my imagination does the rest.

Thanks man! I want to cut this down, deepen & lengthen particular sections...

My trick is having no idea what I'm doing!

Field recording is a sure fire way to add a little uniqueness.

Last year I worked on the rails for my City's Metrolink system and when the trams were stabled they would produce this noise that sounded like the coming of the four horsemen! The problem was it sounded off at random times so I could never catch it!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 12th Jul 2016 04:57 - 10 years ago

on Love and Peace by silverman
silverman...you`ve gone gold in this one...fab chilled listening..lots of layers...the rich pads really float it along and the intertwining melody & aside bits add just the right scenery..its quite different...and in the best of ways...fab track made...good evening listening over my side of the water this rainy night....big fav....Ed
silverman
silverman replied 12th Jul 2016 - 10 years ago
Wow thanks Ed. I have had great feedback on this one from so many of you.
Enjoyed making this as it actually chilled me no end whilst working on it. We are what we eat as they say.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 12th Jul 2016 04:51 - 10 years ago

on Billion - When Im Gone by BillionaireExclusive
Good to hear some positive vibes Billion...I`m not really a rap fan so you will get more useful input from other listeners, but this is well done and I like the musical accompaniment...keep it going....Ed
BillionaireExclusive
BillionaireExclusive replied 12th Jul 2016 - 10 years ago
Thanks Man. Appreciate The Comment Even Though It's Outside Your Comfort Zone. Spread The Live

- Billion
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 10th Jul 2016 21:30 - 10 years ago

on A Long Way To Go - TevySound2 - SJ Remix by SeriouslyJoking
Hey S.J...this is better by far that the stuff my car radio has been playing....and the mix sounds fine to me (although that is coming from an old guy with fading ears haha)...enjoyed the listen...and I agree with Orlando..we could use more of your music...but please get yourself a real comfortable chair.....cheers....Ed
SeriouslyJoking
SeriouslyJoking replied 10th Jul 2016 - 10 years ago
Hi Ed!
Ha ha the chair...yes, have to get an other one.
Thanks for the listen, I believe your ears are just fine, probably hearing more than mine. But this one really has some timing issues and a lot of other flaws to be fixed some rainy day.

I wish you a happy and delightful summer!
Cheers//
SJ =)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 10th Jul 2016 20:56 - 10 years ago

on midnight hindsight by doudei
I can`t believe this one has been around since May last year & I haven`t found it till now...(shame on me...slacker..ha)...This is one of those uplifting pieces of music that leave you feeling good & with a smile...your talent is on display doudei...always a pleasure to hear how you use it...great job...enjoyed the listen...Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 10th Jul 2016 20:46 - 10 years ago

on Jeden Tag - Power Version 2016 by joecramer
and you even got a little quiet string squeak in the intro guitar strings...cool...Joe...you have the perfect vocal character for this kind of music...synth..but not quite...as you say it does indeed sound like it was played by a band...fits the 80s but hell it fits most anywhere else too...reminds me a bit of the music my wife used to crank up the car radio too...great job...good listening over my side of the water...Ed
joecramer
joecramer replied 14th Jul 2016 - 10 years ago
What a friendly comment Ed.
Always nice to read something friendly about my voice.
Nice to read that you like in a way what i have done.
:) your wife must have a good taste for music

stay tuned
joe
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 7th Jul 2016 05:10 - 10 years ago

on Reuse Refix by Tinka0
You would likely know I`m not a good source of knowledgeable commentary on the genre Met...Guess the kind of limiting you hit this one with is part of the genre ...I`m listening with a pair of old Sony (MDR-V600) cans that don`t reproduce the low end well but they are great on the highs...and this one has a lot of higher & high-mid frequency content...I would be inclined to do a bit of selective cutting in that area (maybe around 1.2 khz and above 5) & lay some big fat bass in there pushing some 80 hz & lower stuff...you got lot of power going on so you`re well on your way....keep on....Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 7th Jul 2016 04:50 - 10 years ago

on Here we come by beerling1970
If you hadn`t mentioned this was Trap, I wouldn`t know better Steve..guess my age is showing as I`m just not up on the current electronic genres...I just listen to whats happening without wondering where it fits...but I do like music that is done well like this...don`t understand why this one doesn`t have a lot of comments...its great evening listening over my side of the water...leaves you with a smile, plus as a bonus a I got a bit of education on Trap...nice job putting it together & top notch bit of work on the production...sounding damn good mate.....Ed
beerling1970
beerling1970 replied 22nd Aug 2016 - 10 years ago
Cheers Ed much appreciated :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 30th Jun 2016 04:04 - 10 years ago

on Cassendra by danydory
Welcome to the Loop Daniel...Listening to this, I think you are probably a well experienced musician/producer..thoughtful composition..rich sounds..top class production....most importantly it is very enjoyable listening...You should mark this one as "Featured" Daniel...more people should hear it..A big "Well done" to you..a fine addition to L.M...more please...Ed
danydory
danydory replied 30th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
thank you Ed for the encouraging comment, it make me happy.
I am only a modest amateur musical composition and I do not have your musical talent because I do not play any instrument, I am only the composition MAO
sorry my english is not perfect
Daniel H
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 30th Jun 2016 03:56 - 10 years ago

on Windrunner by mudhoen
This is top notch mudhoen...really extra cool dancing/club mix with all the best elements...I hear a lot of thoughtful work you put into the composition & production...but most importantly..its damn good listening ...absolutely no suggestions from me...big well done to you...Ed
mudhoen
mudhoen replied 30th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Thanks a lot Ed. Most important is how people experiece it. I am very glad you like it!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 30th Jun 2016 03:48 - 10 years ago

on Africapolis by Bindanox
upbeat tune Nelson...definitely a bit different and that is a good thing when you are getting creative...some nice fat synth sounds behind the lead..I just listening with my old Sony cans this evening & they don`t produce the lows real well but sounds like maybe it could be kicked up a bit with some nice low bass...well done...always good to hear some happy music...Ed
Bindanox
Bindanox replied 30th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Thanks Ed
I write depending of how iam feeling at that particular moment.
This one came out quite naturally.
Cheers for the tips.

Thank you for taking the time

Nelson
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 27th Jun 2016 04:07 - 10 years ago

on The Mythical Gates by StaticNomad
The first 1:40 or so is really influenced strongly by that darker pad sound I think..the guitar at 1:50 moves it into a bit brighter place ...really like the bass lines...I am a fan of the minimal in spite of the clutter I sometimes get into my own mixes...I like the guitar work a lot Static...nice bell-like tone and the you have played the spaces (rather than just the notes) well...4:31...now we`re cooking the kind of blues I dig...really a bit closer to free form around those chords, rather than anything rigidly structured...the outro section kind of floats you to the end with that combination of darkness and then light I was getting at the intro...I like the length, but I do agree with silverman...in spite of my oft short attention span I would still be listening if it was still playing...so its gotta be damn good....Ed
StaticNomad
StaticNomad replied 28th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Hello Mr Tweed.

"first 1:40 or so is really influenced strongly by that darker pad sound I think"

Yes and no. The darker sound is the synth bass. There is a pad there (right from after the drum fill intro) but it's quite a light sound.

"guitar at 1:50 moves it into a bit brighter place"

I agree - a more beautiful place before it gets darker as the guitar goes Eastern (around 3:53). Arabic, maybe.

"you have played the spaces (rather than just the notes)"

Yes - I could play blues guitar all day over this sort of groove but I was trying to come up with something distinctive and different that wasn't exactly soloing, more something between hitting different arpeggiated chords and other fills and stuff. Better guitarists than me would no doubt come up with something better but, after lots of editing of the guitar parts, I'm fairly happy with what I've got.

"4:31...now we`re cooking the kind of blues I dig"

Yes - that's fun, bright, stomping stuff. But I played none of the guitar there over that groove. It's leftover playing from before, over the laidback shuffle groove. It just sounds quite different because of the change in drum groove. The bassline is pretty much the same so it just goes to show what a massive difference a (double time) drum groove can make.

I could have gone mad with that stomping blues section, adding loads of slide playing and funky, pumping bass guitar parts. Yet I resisted.

"the outro section kind of floats you to the end"

Yes, gently floating stuff and a chord change from the bass on 6:55. Out of the previous darkness and into the triumphant light. Uplifting guitar follows the filtered strings.

Oh sure - it could be way, way longer as I'd planned to bring the stomping blues section back and add all the slide playing and stuff. Maybe sometimes I should ignore my aim of making tracks under 10 mins and just go over if it feels right.

Thanks again.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 25th Jun 2016 22:58 - 10 years ago

on Talk To Me by Denyjanuary ft Mildperil by T0mmyy
Where have you been hiding that fab voice of yours mildperil...probably I just hadn`t caught up with enough of your tracks in the past...man, you have just the right amount of subtle gravel in the vox...and I particularly like the expressiveness you get in the delivery...it really sets you apart from the more usual canned stuff our radios play...Super job...enjoyed listening...big well done to you....Ed
T0mmyy
T0mmyy replied 26th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Really pleased you enjoyed listening, as I love your music. I've never been a big fan of the usual canned radio stuff, so that is an extra compliment for me.

But I can't give enough credit to Denyjanuary who wrote the music in the first place, as without him, there would be no song.

Thanks for stopping by and leaving such a kind comment, much appreciated :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 24th Jun 2016 04:41 - 10 years ago

on NextStep 13 by Spivkurl
You amaze me Spiv...I definitely get the chiptune 8 bit association in the sounds...but for some reason the way you put this together lifts it into any post synth decade you want...I think even kids who have never heard the original machines would bend an ear to this one..its got a cool uplifting kind of vibe that leaves you with a smile...and I`m sure thats a good thing...right on......Ed
Spivkurl
Spivkurl replied 21st Jul 2016 - 10 years ago
Thank you Ed for listening at communicating here! Don't let the uplifting musical efforts fool you, this song has a very specific political agenda. Sometimes it is worth putting on a costume in order to slip in undetected. I do really appreciate your comments on the arrangement side of things! It was a pretty enjoyable one to work on. Thanks so much!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 24th Jun 2016 04:35 - 10 years ago

on MYXD - Echo by PortraitOfABlackHole
glad to hear someone trying to mix guitar and electronic instruments...I have tried it quite a few times...big fun....nice upbeat mix MYXD...good tune for a Summer evening listen...Ed
PortraitOfABlackHole
PortraitOfABlackHole replied 24th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Thanks Ed! I'm working hard to perfect my sound!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 24th Jun 2016 04:29 - 10 years ago

on Black lambs of Deling city by traz75
Nice clear production traz..everythig sits nice and cleanly in the mix so you must have spent a lot of time getting everything just right...notice some comments on the one guitar volume...sounds fine to me (I`m using headphones)...when I play with volume variation I often just insert a compressor...set it to comp down to -15dB...fast attack.. 15ms....slow release 1000ms, so it works continually all the way through and helps even the volumes out...Nice uplifting tune you have going...sounds like Summer....well done my friend...Ed
traz75
traz75 replied 27th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Thank you Ed!
Yeah, some timing takes a while because in this one i use a few loops in different speeds and heavily cut. It gives great satisfaction as you hear them ok with headphones too, were not really reliant on it before...

Regards, traz
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 23rd Jun 2016 04:26 - 10 years ago

on Voltage feat Maddie by mudhoen
Maddie is one really talented vocalist and I gotta say you really did a great job on making the backing mix & vocal work together mudhoen...really nice upbeat summer-sounding mix...well done....Ed
mudhoen
mudhoen replied 23rd Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Thanks Ed. It was a delight working together with her.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 14th Jun 2016 02:59 - 10 years ago

on The Denim Clad Monk by silverman
I`m not sure that monk is as peaceful as he is supposed to be...maybe he used some of the wrong kind of mountain weed in making his incense..now, that part starting around 2:20 sees him with a new peaceful vision of his role...before temptation comes his way again at 3:42 for a while....very cool trip silverman...certainly different...and most definitely an enjoyable listen...great job...Ed
silverman
silverman replied 15th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Thanks Ed. Always encouraging when you comment.
Not as peaceful you say. Well that's why he's in denim.
A hippy in the mountains looking for enlightenment as opposed to a monk who already possesses it.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 13th Jun 2016 05:09 - 10 years ago

on Everything Where It Should Be by StaticNomad
This comment is hidden.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 10th Jun 2016 17:55 - 10 years ago

on Terrorist by Tinka0
This comment is hidden.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 10th Jun 2016 17:03 - 10 years ago

on Something You Said by Planetjazzbass
I was just gliding along...appreciating the bass playing and vocal over that subtle backing pad...then the first of the diversions into that kind of country blues-rock whacked me with a big smile...love the way you just glide out of that section around 3:05...and on into the smooth next one (like the way you walked the bass around there too)...I was thinking you were using your fretless in that first section till I read your later comments..never did try an acoustic one but I did try a set of those black nylon wound jazz strings on my first JBass (around 65)...Your posts are always a treat for the ears and inspiration for the mind Dave...the production is fantastic, but having such a great arrangement...the composing imagination...and playing talent really sets a standard that few will meet....superb work all round...really enjoyed this one...Ed
Planetjazzbass
Planetjazzbass replied 11th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Hey Ed thanks man. I'm really getting into the acoustic tone of my bass at the moment, it's got heaps of sustain and fills out the bottom register nicely, pretty sure I'm going to build another one, a four stringer this time with an additional magnetic pickup for those crossover tones (and a slimmer neck for speeder playing! lol)...thanks for your kind words mate very much appreciated!....cheers Dave :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 10th Jun 2016 03:09 - 10 years ago

on one 4 the road by bbedford48
best tune I have listened to today Bob...its got the composition, arrangement The big talent in the band and nice clean production....gotta be all good..a bit of a throwback to times when artists used to have to play their instruemnts and be good at it...most importantly I`m just really enjoying this evening listen....well done to you..fav....Ed
bbedford48
bbedford48 replied 10th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Hi Ed,
good to hear from you. Yes it's a bit 40s. I remember when I was a kid of about 5, my mother would have the radio on, and it had this kind of warm harmonic sound.
Thanks for your great comment.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 10th Jun 2016 03:04 - 10 years ago

on How We Dream by BigPete
cool intro...really like the mix of the higher & fatter orchestral bits...and the smoother than usual beats easily make this one a crossover type track Pete...new or old school, its just good listening over my way...can`t honestly claim to be a rap fan, but your vocal is really well done...great job...I think this is the first time I hit the fav button on a hip hop mix....cheers....Ed
BigPete
BigPete replied 10th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Thank I really appreciate espacially not being a fan of hip hop it means a lot to me, thanks again for taking the time to comment, peace.
Comments 276 - 300 of 1,544