Tumbleweed

Tumbleweed

Regina, Canada
Joined : 26th Nov 2010 - 15 years ago
Last Online : 3rd Dec 2025 - 1 day ago
Tumbleweed comments on tracks

Tumbleweed has posted 1626 comments on other peoples tracks.

Comments 226 - 250 of 1,626
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 30th Jan 2017 22:20 - 8 years ago

on Upwelling Ice by Burtsbluesboxes
I think Tekreck described it aptly...awesome....so I just stopped by to tell you that your pages is a mess...I can`t even keep track of what year today is ...haha....man you really nailed the whole vibe in this one (but you have been doing that consistently of late)....absolutely top notch & a big fav....Have you thought about doing an album of your cigar box tunes?...it would def appeal to me....well done mate....cheers...Ed
Burtsbluesboxes
Burtsbluesboxes replied 2nd Feb 2017 - 8 years ago
Yes a very fitting description :p Seems anything I play on that electric 3 string falls into that category ;) My page is an absolute mess!! Any surprise as I'm a cleaner for a living hahahaha. I'm going to delete everything and reupload making it nice and tidy again. I've made and given away a few cds of cigar box guitar music. My co worker played one at work and the guys kept looking at me, this is you? really?? I'm going to set up a band camp account and put up an album for free download as well as on Reverbnation once I figure out how. Joe Cramer put together this one of collabs we've done, not all is cbgs but should hold you over. https://www.reverbnation.com/1096781/album/117064 Always a pleasure Ed, stay tuned for more, new one up today.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 29th Jan 2017 03:30 - 8 years ago

on What it was Like by wikkid
great job bringing these two together wikkid...aside from a couple of the little technical things that have already been mentioned this is one realy good track that has lots of potential...Brado...pump this one up..its damn good listening up my way....well done wikkid....keep on...Ed
wikkid
wikkid replied 29th Jan 2017 - 8 years ago
Thanks for the comment, Ed.
I don't know what else to do to get Brado and Austin to team up to re-make this. Maybe I need to sing them a love song :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 28th Jan 2017 22:31 - 8 years ago

on NEVER STOP DREAMING - Cinematic Soundtrack by Alabafruit
I wouldn`t have guessed you made this one out of loops Albafruit except perhaps for the observation that the key progression gets quite repetitive.That is not necessarily a bad thing in cinematic/soundtrack type of productions as the are intended to provide a theme for a particular scene..you have however, got enough variations in there to keep it interesting listen....really like that flute part...I enjoyed it....a big well done to you and thanks for using that little contribution of mine...that always makes listening fun....cheers....Ed
Alabafruit
Alabafruit replied 28th Jan 2017 - 8 years ago
Thank you for this great Feedback! I hope one day I can do everything alone without any loops and it will be more interesting and just bigger and deeper.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 15th Jan 2017 03:26 - 8 years ago

on Never Forget Your Name by HappyIdiots
nice chord progression & really like the warm backing sounds...its good...and definitely invites a vocal....well done....Ed
HappyIdiots
HappyIdiots replied 15th Jan 2017 - 8 years ago
Thank you so much for listening, I appreciate it! I put it in my favorite key: B minor, which led to a lot of fun experimentation.

I'm looking forward to hearing more of your tracks.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 13th Jan 2017 20:51 - 8 years ago

on Outside by MOONLYTE
I`ve been away slacking for a long time so just catching up with this one now....I did several music mixes for a spoken word artist a few years ago so have some appreciation for the art and the talents it takes to do it well....The backing music caught my attention right from note one..lovin it...nice fat piano...and the cello is great for adding emotional depth to most any kind of music..thoughtful lyrics even if they are dark (thats part of our journey too)....This is honestly one of the very best spoken word performances I have heard Eyedye (and I have heard many)..change nothing.....bravo...standing ovation from an old guy up North.....Ed
MOONLYTE
MOONLYTE replied 14th Jan 2017 - 8 years ago
Ed, another talent I'm honored to receive feedback from. You haven't slacked much, only been up for a couple weeks so you're good haha. Dark is kinda my thing. To be put among your top performers is honestly awesome. To the old guy up North, I thank you for the time :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 13th Jan 2017 20:40 - 8 years ago

on New World ft RomyHarmony by Unkn0wnPr0g
Like your creativity ..and the nice kind of bouncy uplifting sounds...found the clap/snare panned hard left a bit unusual but its one of those tunes and leaves you with a smile...the vocal is good...agree with the comments that bringing it up in the mix a little would be a good idea...well done......Ed
Unkn0wnPr0g
Unkn0wnPr0g replied 14th Jan 2017 - 8 years ago
Thanks you! Yeah idk why the clap/snare sounds like that, will fix that.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 13th Jan 2017 03:06 - 8 years ago

on hello i hate u - THC mashup - adele x gnash by TrippyHippyCrew
creative stuff guys....the vocal bits may be familiar but you have some very cool accompaniment ideas going on....Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 12th Jan 2017 03:09 - 8 years ago

on Seasons by toastedavalanche
Dig that acoustic intro a lot...( a bit of a Southern blues vibe to start with)....the vocal fits to a T....I wanted to stand up and cheer at that little neat key change around 1:22...subtle but most effective...unsure how to describe this one but I gotta say I am absolutely impressed my friend...its got a kind of a folky vibe and is one of those little songs that just seems to wrap itself around your mind and carry you along...something we would all wish to accomplish.....Bravo....big fav from across the water....Ed
toastedavalanche
toastedavalanche replied 15th Jan 2017 - 8 years ago
Thanks man. I wanted to do something a little different. Glad that you enjoyed it :)

TA
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 11th Jan 2017 23:05 - 8 years ago

on Night Dream by DijamMusic
You`ve got some dream picture painting music going on here Jamid mate...really well done and with nice production values..and most importantly,,,I enjoyed listening....been away a while so lots of catching up to do (maybe next month)...but this one was a good place to start...keep on doing it.....Ed
DijamMusic
DijamMusic replied 12th Jan 2017 - 8 years ago
Hello Dear legend Ed,
How you doing, I hope You had a great holiday mate.
Thank you very much for your kind and wonderful feedback mate.
Yes, unfortunately I do know how it is not having the time to do what we want.
I am looking forward for your new track.
Thanks again.
Jamid
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 11th Dec 2016 01:56 - 8 years ago

on Titan - Preview by kingmadi
Nice clean mix Kingmadi...sounds nice and crisp and the vocal is on the money...The accompaniment is very minimal (which I like) so I would agree with the comments you have already about giving the bass quite a bit more prominence to bring up that lower end.There aren`t really any sounds eating up the low mids and lower frequencies so there is lots of room..well done...keep it going...Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 11th Dec 2016 01:49 - 8 years ago

on Eyes Run Aground by Evisma
Yeah...I like it.....and I see I`m way late even catching up with this one (like everything else lately)...love the acoustic intro....drums are very natural sounding (like the acoustic kit you are using) many very tasty little bits with the ping-pong delay etc to add the interest/variety...Man, you really got everything working together great in this one Evan.....thoughtful composing too....best damn piece of music I have listened to all day (and then some)...big fav from this ol boy....Cheers...Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 8th Dec 2016 03:36 - 8 years ago

on all ive done instrumental by larrybarrow31
songs built around a nice chord progression with rich instrumentation always seem to sound good to me...it is a bit repetitive but as you say the vocal styling can take it in different directions...nice clean mix...you do R&B well Larry..nice work on this one..good evening listening....Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 8th Dec 2016 03:30 - 8 years ago

on With Sarah And Wine by Orlando51
I`m more than a little slow these days Orlando, but I eventually catch up with you...I note the little enhancements you have made in the mix, and I`m enjoying another listen...I think Steve`s comments pretty much nailed my own feelings on a first listen..it does bring with it a feeling of warm memories, a wee touch of nostalgia, beauty and lightness all at the same time....My thanks to you again and always for the privilege of sharing that talent of yours again this year..look forward to another year of making music with you that I enjoy.....Ed
Orlando51
Orlando51 replied 8th Dec 2016 - 8 years ago
Hola my friend...I can only imagine what you're going through lately, so the most important at the moment is that you fix your health problems and everything else can wait.
Therefore going slow is the way to go at the moment...the acceleration comes when you get better..:)
I'm glad you noticed little changes on the mix which I think are for the better. I'm also very close to what Steve says and what you also find to be your feeling about the song. I know it's a bit old fashioned in style, but hey, what's wrong with being old fashioned sometimes or even all of the time? To me it has some nice moments and that's what counts. Afteral it's December, and aren't we all more or less old fashioned in our habits during that time of the year...haha...wine in the title is there with a reason..:)
Thank you again so much for great musical company and friendship during this year and I'm sure there is more to come in 2017...looking forward with excitement!:)

With much appreciation and gratitude_____Orlando
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 6th Dec 2016 03:03 - 9 years ago

on Globule by raleighbull
Nice clean sounding production raleighbull...moving mix...maybe could use a bit of low bass to fill that bottom end but it sounds good otherwise...Ed
raleighbull
raleighbull replied 6th Dec 2016 - 9 years ago
Thanks Tumbleweed for the helpful feedback! For some reason I find it hard to tell if the bass is too loud or not but I'm working on it.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 1st Dec 2016 22:53 - 9 years ago

on LITTLE DREAD by Planetjazzbass
hey mon...welcome to d` island dis late evening.....is there anything you can`t do musically...reggae of a somewhat different class to my ears as I keep getting a wee sip of something jazzy...like the moon rising on the horizon....superb musicianship by all members of the band (named Dave)..lovely clean production with perfect levels & natural placement...To say this is damn good would be a big understatement....standing ovation from up North....Ed
Planetjazzbass
Planetjazzbass replied 2nd Dec 2016 - 9 years ago
Hey Ed thanks buddy!...went along to a Marley concert only because a friend of my sister's offered me free tickets..they were second row dead centre, a totally awesome experience for me...while I had always liked calypso and early Jamaican styles I'd never been exposed to full blown live reggae before, became an instant convert (along with most of western youth at that time) and still am, though Dubstep doesn't appeal to me..I wonder why. haha....thanks for your kind review mate much appreciated! cheers Dave :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 1st Dec 2016 22:27 - 9 years ago

on Butterfly Effect - An Ultra Violet Apology by Mahloo13
Well, being a bit of a guitar addict for life you gotta know I`m loving this one...great tone and the kind of playing style that wraps itself around the vocal perfectly...nothing overstated...just the eloquent bits...I`m admiring the tones, levels & placement...and not to understate the vocal...some voices just fit the music like it was meant to be....like this one. I think the production really evidences some of the comments/advice you have made in the past Malu...particularly the concept of compression steps, with each designed to be in a particular place for a specific purpose rather than nailing the entire mix to manage levels....superb bit of work...and its a great song...the kind of melodic slow rock I could listen to for a very long time......Cheers...Ed
Mahloo13
Mahloo13 replied 2nd Dec 2016 - 9 years ago
Thank you Ed!

I also love guitar and guitar tone and I could probably spend days just recreating diferent amp tones. An amazing instrument!

There are definitely some cool tricks one can do with compressors especially if each is used for a specific purpose. Compressors are really hated on cause a lot of people missunderstood the concept behind the loudness wars and have since thought of compressors as something that's a no no when it comes to mixing. Compressing even overcompressing can yield interesting results and sonic characters. It comes down to experimentation really.

Thank you once again for the great review!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 27th Nov 2016 02:42 - 9 years ago

on Show Me by Jeffiedillard
and a lovey-dovey mix it is indeed....I`ll just sit here at the back table with my glass off the good stuff and enjoy that sexy lady sing along with the cool music...like the way you kept it minimal jeffiernee and let it just wrap up the songstress in the basics......well done...Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 16th Nov 2016 22:33 - 9 years ago

on Bowie Cover Everyone Says Hi by Mykael
I was a kind of sometimes and sometimes not Bowie fan Mykael so I don`t really recall this one ...You`ve got a nice smooth vocal delivery going so I hope you get the kind of accompaniment you want....If you get someone to do the keys & drums bit to set out the keys & beat I might be able to do the acoustic guitar for you...so long as you are not in a rush...Just have short spurts of music time these days & having to eat pain pills that slow the creative urge down....All the best with it...its really well done...nice and clean and should work into a mix real easy...Ed
Mykael
Mykael replied 15th Dec 2016 - 8 years ago
Hiya Ed!

Thanks so much for your comments and offer! If needed I will definitely reach out when the the time comes. Thanks again!

LovePeace&Light,

Mykael
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 3rd Nov 2016 02:04 - 9 years ago

on Primordial by Neomorpheus
Your versatility is showing again Neo...and I have a smile of satisfaction of my face when I hear an guitarist/artist use the instrument to create the atmosphere with the restrained kind of melody lines that convey the feeling/mind picture rather than demo speed on scales etc (as many do)...love that big fat kind of dark pad that introduces the track...nice patient build (a la Pink Floyd)...very cool smooth singy tone on the guitar...its a fairly minimal mix..where the instrumentation carries the rhythm with the need for anything else....This is really well and thoughtfully done man...fab job...fav from this ol guy....Ed
Neomorpheus
Neomorpheus replied 5th Nov 2016 - 9 years ago
Ambient music is great in how it allows us to create that mind picture as you put it Ed. Yeah as a guitarist its always fascinating as to what can be done with the instrument, and in particular just with notes. Used drop C tuning here and just 3 chords - D flat minor, Sus 2 on the A string and an A caged major, and just basically picked on the roots. The last section was done by coil tapping the rear pickup with one hand while one finger sliding out the notes on the fret board. All the keys were done in FL Studio using the Sytrus VST. Synth bass track also created with FL Studios' GMS (Groove Machine Synth) with some heavy boosted frequency modulation FX.

Its always great to hear your views Ed, thanks for listen and comments my friend.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 31st Oct 2016 20:56 - 9 years ago

on Highland Homecoming by Orlando51
The more times I listen to this one the more I love that piano of yours Leon....and I`ve been listening every moring on my MP3 player (when I walk & try to compensate for my bad habits).....Thank you again my friend...this one would never have survived without your talented additions...Ed
Orlando51
Orlando51 replied 31st Oct 2016 - 9 years ago
Thank you so much my friend for stopping by and for your very generous words of support and encouragment....and if it's true that this track survived only because of my involvement then I'm happy as one can be, and can one get a bigger compliment than this? Or if I say it more on a joke side...should I become a founder of "Trash Bin Recovery Agency"? I would certainly be very much in favour of that idea, especially when a very particular trash bin over there in Canada is in question..:)

With much gratitude & looking forward for the next one..

Orlando
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 31st Oct 2016 20:53 - 9 years ago

on Shadowless by crucethus
I would be diggin this one no matter what genre you said it was my friend...I`m a fan of a bit of panning (I more often use m-s processing) on some of the percussion parts...like those funky guitar bits back there and the horns...Having played the ol bass for a few years my ear always catches effective bass lines like this...thoughtful composing and arranging going on with the breaks, changeups...Oh I just his that piano bit...freeking awesome...lots going on but doesn`t really feel that way as the whole trip just weaves its way through your hear from beginning to end...Great track...and I`m use to that being the case when I stop by your place....Fav...Ed
crucethus
crucethus replied 17th Nov 2016 - 9 years ago
Thanks Ed, Iḿ glad this one caught your ear in a good way. I think bass is such an anchor to a tune and can create the mood for the listener. This one is a moody one and I love making tunes like this .
Thanks
Steve
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 28th Oct 2016 16:20 - 9 years ago

on Help Halloween 2016 by Mosaic
Very effective/cool build into the beat...nice breaks where the ghouls do whatever evil they are doing...and they are enjoying it immensely..although the victims sound less light-hearted about the whole thing...HaHa...just a great Halloween trip Mos..and as a bonus it comes with your talent for the big dance groove....fab track mate.....Ed
Mosaic
Mosaic replied 26th Aug 2017 - 8 years ago
Hey Ed

Firstly sorry for taking so long to get back to you with response, suppose better late then never. wrapped you enjoyed this one was a bit of fun doing it, glad it turned out okies...Peace n much respect my friend...mosaic...
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 27th Oct 2016 23:23 - 9 years ago

on turning time by mindhiest
The vocal works just fine mindheist...in fact I thought it was really good...fair bit of darkness in the intro section that eases into a more dramatic mode as the beat comes it....This is really well done man...nicely structured & arranged (really liked that little heavy section towards the end)......kudos to you on the production too....enjoyed the listen...Ed
mindhiest
mindhiest replied 27th Nov 2016 - 9 years ago
thank you, sorry took so long to respond. actually think it is my top 3 piece, funny becuase not my style. may do more like this. thank you so much.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 27th Oct 2016 03:42 - 9 years ago

on Falcon Trance 8 by EricMilligan
Hi Eric...not being much of a keyboard player I`m not familiar with the synth plugins you mention (been thinking of investing in a new outboard synth one of these days when I dispose of some of the current toys)....I like this little chord prog I`m hearing...one of those just good to hear & a bit addicting things..and being one who tends to compose around progressions much of the time I`m enjoying this one a lot...kudos on the production too...everything sits nice & clear in the mix...I could listen to lots of music like this...a big well done to you...Ed
EricMilligan
EricMilligan replied 27th Oct 2016 - 9 years ago
Thanks, Ed. I am embarrassed to admit that I've let my guitar chops, which were never that great frankly, totally evaporate. I've got two acoustics hanging on the wall in my home studio/office and I basically never pick them up. I really should get back on that trail. I use an Access Virus outboard synth as my controller keyboard and it does sound great, but other than that, all of my instruments are virtual. I guess I compose around progressions too, but I need to learn more of them so I can get greater variety and interest in my stuff. I'm keeping a list of progressions to try out. The mix on that track was difficult and I'm still not sure if I got it right. The synth chords have a pretty good bass floor to them if you listen to them on headphones or a decent set of studio monitors, so I originally did the track without a separate bass track. Didn't sound like it needed it. Then I bounced it to MP3 and played it in my car. Sounded awful. No bass and really annoying high frequencies dominating. There's a lot of noise in the synth chord part. That's programmed into the patch on purpose I think so that it cuts through. I added 3 bass tracks and it sounded better, but I still find the high frequency content a bit much and I have tinnitus, so have some measure of hearing loss for high frequencies. So, I always worry that, for others, my mixes actually don't sound like I hear them.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 24th Oct 2016 18:23 - 9 years ago

on Frying Pan Man by MWRatridge
No matter the subject...when you play it with feeling it always sounds good to me....something classically good about this one Mark....as always the lyrics & vocal delivery come with your signature...and thats a very good thing....With the current state of our planet its good to listen to some humour...maybe I`ll go hide all the heavier type frying pans in the house...a big well done to you...Cheers...Ed
MWRatridge
MWRatridge replied 17th Jan 2018 - 7 years ago
tyvvm much Ed. much respect.
Comments 226 - 250 of 1,626