Tumbleweed

Tumbleweed

Regina, Canada
Joined : 26th Nov 2010 - 15 years ago
Last Online : 28th Jun 2026 - 1 week ago
Tumbleweed comments on tracks

Tumbleweed has posted 1619 comments on other peoples tracks.

Comments 301 - 325 of 1,619
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 23rd Jun 2016 04:26 - 10 years ago

on Voltage feat Maddie by mudhoen
Maddie is one really talented vocalist and I gotta say you really did a great job on making the backing mix & vocal work together mudhoen...really nice upbeat summer-sounding mix...well done....Ed
mudhoen
mudhoen replied 23rd Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Thanks Ed. It was a delight working together with her.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 14th Jun 2016 02:59 - 10 years ago

on The Denim Clad Monk by silverman
I`m not sure that monk is as peaceful as he is supposed to be...maybe he used some of the wrong kind of mountain weed in making his incense..now, that part starting around 2:20 sees him with a new peaceful vision of his role...before temptation comes his way again at 3:42 for a while....very cool trip silverman...certainly different...and most definitely an enjoyable listen...great job...Ed
silverman
silverman replied 15th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Thanks Ed. Always encouraging when you comment.
Not as peaceful you say. Well that's why he's in denim.
A hippy in the mountains looking for enlightenment as opposed to a monk who already possesses it.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 13th Jun 2016 05:09 - 10 years ago

on Everything Where It Should Be by StaticNomad
Hail ye master of technique...that thing you did with the pumpin piano and sax at the beginning is freekin awesome (interesting to note how you did it in your reply to Neomorpheus)...the creative stuff you have been doing with that cello is bloody musical art Static...This one is just one great groove...and aside from how you may more accurately describe it...its just good listening, particularly like the fat/low piano - sax combo parts...honestly enjoyed this one till the last note (which was not the more usual lazy fade most of us do)...big ovation from an old fart across the water.....Cheers...Ed
StaticNomad
StaticNomad replied 14th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Hail me, master of...poor cello technique.

And hail you, master old fart across the water.

Yes, that early pumping piano part I hear as being very hip hop. That main first note was a kick drum part (hence the insistent precision) and then the note it changes to was the snare. I have some interesting ideas that I'll have to explore some time regarding taking drum fills and copying the MIDI data to a synth so that drums and synth are playing exactly the same thing. Could be very interesting, especially when I start to slowly vary things so that they're not quite playing the same thing.

Yes, I have been doing lots of creative stuff with the cello. That's partly because I'm still rubbish at bowing and can't consistently do the kind of things on it that I can do on my other stringed instruments. But I don't just sit there practising it as I try to learn it. I record and then edit my parts very carefully to get rid of all the many errors. I do that a hell of a lot anyway with my other instruments but that's more for creativity whereas this is initially just to get rid of the crap bowing tones that I often hit. Scrapey, whingey sounds.

"enjoyed this one till the last note (which was not the more usual lazy fade most of us do)"

My endings have not been too great in the last year and I've done too many abrupt sort of endings and only a few skilful ones. I think I'm almost getting worse at endings. Must make more effort as they're important. That's how you leave the listener so it has to be a good goodbye, so to speak.

Good to hear you enjoyed all of this.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 10th Jun 2016 17:55 - 10 years ago

on Terrorist by Tinka0
wicked intro hits...nailed my old Sony headphones right to my ears...I use these cans to check high (they do a nice job on that...but ##### on lows)...you`re right...its a wicked heavy industrial mix...best headphones (for accuracy) I have are ATH M50s....cheers....Ed
Tinka0
Tinka0 replied 18th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Hey Ed, thanks for listening man. I like the way you describe the intro, it's to be modified but kept the same. :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 10th Jun 2016 17:03 - 10 years ago

on Something You Said by Planetjazzbass
I was just gliding along...appreciating the bass playing and vocal over that subtle backing pad...then the first of the diversions into that kind of country blues-rock whacked me with a big smile...love the way you just glide out of that section around 3:05...and on into the smooth next one (like the way you walked the bass around there too)...I was thinking you were using your fretless in that first section till I read your later comments..never did try an acoustic one but I did try a set of those black nylon wound jazz strings on my first JBass (around 65)...Your posts are always a treat for the ears and inspiration for the mind Dave...the production is fantastic, but having such a great arrangement...the composing imagination...and playing talent really sets a standard that few will meet....superb work all round...really enjoyed this one...Ed
Planetjazzbass
Planetjazzbass replied 11th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Hey Ed thanks man. I'm really getting into the acoustic tone of my bass at the moment, it's got heaps of sustain and fills out the bottom register nicely, pretty sure I'm going to build another one, a four stringer this time with an additional magnetic pickup for those crossover tones (and a slimmer neck for speeder playing! lol)...thanks for your kind words mate very much appreciated!....cheers Dave :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 10th Jun 2016 03:09 - 10 years ago

on one 4 the road by bbedford48
best tune I have listened to today Bob...its got the composition, arrangement The big talent in the band and nice clean production....gotta be all good..a bit of a throwback to times when artists used to have to play their instruemnts and be good at it...most importantly I`m just really enjoying this evening listen....well done to you..fav....Ed
bbedford48
bbedford48 replied 10th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Hi Ed,
good to hear from you. Yes it's a bit 40s. I remember when I was a kid of about 5, my mother would have the radio on, and it had this kind of warm harmonic sound.
Thanks for your great comment.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 10th Jun 2016 03:04 - 10 years ago

on How We Dream by BigPete
cool intro...really like the mix of the higher & fatter orchestral bits...and the smoother than usual beats easily make this one a crossover type track Pete...new or old school, its just good listening over my way...can`t honestly claim to be a rap fan, but your vocal is really well done...great job...I think this is the first time I hit the fav button on a hip hop mix....cheers....Ed
BigPete
BigPete replied 10th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Thank I really appreciate espacially not being a fan of hip hop it means a lot to me, thanks again for taking the time to comment, peace.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 8th Jun 2016 00:01 - 10 years ago

on Four Leaf Lover by Spivkurl
You have a way with the words Spiv..and the way you deliver them is right on with the musical vibe...I think I catch little glimpses of some of my early recollections of synth tunes (my wife used to play it really loud in the car)...as always it is really well done..it is unique (and I`m sure I have said that several times before) and that in itself is an unusual achievement today...perhaps you are the only one-of-a-kind on a planet that the species went extinct on...Cheers...Ed
Spivkurl
Spivkurl replied 18th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Ed, you are far too kind! It was an important song for me to complete, and as is often the case, songs like that are difficult for me to share with anyone. Sometimes I wonder about being one of a kind, and all I need to do is think of my wife... we share too many feelings and ideas for that to be true. In reading about clovers, white clovers specifically, I learned that the world record for most leaflets on a clover is 86. I think that my upbringing regarding the rarity of a simple four leaf clover was simply overstated. Hopefully this is true, otherwise something odd is going on in our backyard the last few years! Thank you for your listen, and the discussion! Have a great day!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 3rd Jun 2016 23:58 - 10 years ago

on Tumulus by Denyjanuary ft mildperil by T0mmyy
This is one extra cool track mildperil..perhaps the lack of editing gives it a more real feel that we are used to hearing..really like the guitar (nice clear production) but the vocal is the star...delivered with feeling...enjoyed this one mate....keep on....Ed
T0mmyy
T0mmyy replied 5th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Thanks for listening and for the feedback, much appreciated :)
Tumbleweed
Different.....and that is a good thing..quite a minimal mix but it works well and keeps to the quiet theme...interesting track Tayalijeffery....Ed
TayaliJeffrey
TayaliJeffrey replied 31st Aug 2016 - 9 years ago
thanks a millie been working at it
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 27th May 2016 17:05 - 10 years ago

on Red Shoes by silverman
I like this one silverman..nice smooth vibe..a bit of R&B - Jazz feel...You have the mix in a nice space too...feel like I should be sitting at a back table sipping on something cool....great job...Cheers...Ed
silverman
silverman replied 28th May 2016 - 10 years ago
Thank you Tumble. I might take it down and try for a little more depth and a little more stuff in there irt sounds a little long winded in places now but you know what it's like creating these things having to listen to the same bit over and over and over until your happy with it and then it gets tempting to repeat thaty bit a few to many times ... that's me at the moment.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 27th May 2016 17:01 - 10 years ago

on ANDWY Instrumental by bitronix
Nicely played & sounds good to me 2D2R...Ed
bitronix
bitronix replied 28th May 2016 - 10 years ago
Hey Ed! Thanks a lot man!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 26th May 2016 21:36 - 10 years ago

on I Fall Down v2 by Spivkurl
I cant honestly remember enough about the earlier mixes to offer much Spiv...and you know I`m not a good source of informed observation on the genre...Its just good..and when you combine the lyrics with the music its damn fine entertainment with yet another listen...and the mix sounds good to me...Ed
Spivkurl
Spivkurl replied 4th Jun 2016 - 10 years ago
Hello again Ed! Thanks for taking to the new version, as it's definitely better... hence the earlier one doesn't matter much. I'm really looking forward to hearing more remixes of this as they roll in! "Damn find entertainment" is quite the compliment, I appreciate it!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 26th May 2016 17:40 - 10 years ago

on Cried A Million Tears by Mosaic
PS: If you are still using Sony Creative products you might be interested to know that they were just acquired by Magix....maybe there is hope Acid Pro will have a better future...it hasnt been updated since 2012...
Mosaic
Mosaic replied 27th May 2016 - 10 years ago
Hi my friend

Yep still use Sony, so that is good news re magix...Things okies here my friend, waiting to get into a Hospital then hoping things will settle down health wise...Peace...Mosaic...
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 26th May 2016 17:35 - 10 years ago

on Cried A Million Tears by Mosaic
I`m liking this big time right off the bat...If it was on the radio I would be looking for who the artist was so I could get more....great combination of sounds with the fat synth backing...right-on drums & bass..The vocal works great and you mixed it in nicely....a brilliant return mate...hope you and yours are well.....Ed
Mosaic
Mosaic replied 27th May 2016 - 10 years ago
Hey Ed

Thank you mate for stopping by, and more so your kind words on the track, just listen to this again and fairly happy with it, glad you enjoyed the piece...Peace Ed...mosaic...
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 26th May 2016 17:17 - 10 years ago

on Alive by ImproveWithError
This is top notch Kyle...a bigger mix this time with the electric gtr...nice job on the recording by the way...We tend to be our own worse critics at times but you really do have the vocal chops Kyle..I don`t know how to explain it but its a voice character thing ...this would fit very nicely in today`s country radio....a big well done to you...fav from this ol boy...Ed
ImproveWithError
ImproveWithError replied 27th May 2016 - 10 years ago
Thanks Ed, I always respect your view on things so I take your compliment on my vocals to heart, I appreciate it. It's tough to for me to like my own voice I guess, but I do like singing so I guess I just need to except it and just make music because its fun. As always I appreciate you taking the time to listen and comment. Thanks!!!

Kyle
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 25th May 2016 00:12 - 10 years ago

on Foreign Glory by TinyFinger
I think my hair started growing again while I was listening to this TF..HaHa......good rock without the frills....sounds good guys....well done...Ed
TinyFinger
TinyFinger replied 25th May 2016 - 10 years ago
Hi. Thx mat. I'm glad that your heart enjoy.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 25th May 2016 00:05 - 10 years ago

on Luke The Biker by Musicante
man....with a voice like that you can do any kind of song you want Scott...can`t be bought...either got it or you dont...certainly hear Franko`s signature in there too...I dont have 5.1..just listening with phones but it sounds really good..stay behind the windshield if you are riding our prairies later in the year...them grasshoppers are damn hard..haha....well done guys...another winner for sure...Ed
Musicante
Musicante replied 26th May 2016 - 10 years ago
Hi Ed,

I thought I'd chime in and thank you personally for your kind words. I'm not exactly sure what I've 'got' except a decent speaking voice, but I can't really sing, but thanks anyway.

You don't really need a surround system, but it's nice when you can hear different instruments coming from different parts of the room. I mix on a stereo, though.

Cheers,
Scott
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 23rd May 2016 23:21 - 10 years ago

on Like this - ft Grotesk the subhuman by TeeGee1965
You got a good live band sound going in this one TG (I find that hard to do sometimes)..the band sounds tight and the vocal is nicely placed...sounds good just the way you did it....well done to everyone...Ed
TeeGee1965
TeeGee1965 replied 24th May 2016 - 10 years ago
Thanks Ed :) Yes it is amazing considering I have never met or played with these guys in the same room...but we got a good system going for our recording process, and we are learning all the time. And to tell you the truth, I am basically flying in the dark with the mixing process, I pull on some levers and push some buttons, ask the guys what they think, do some adjustments and that's it. TG :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 23rd May 2016 04:19 - 10 years ago

on To Keep You by Cestevens1783
Voice and acoustic guitar are just the perfect combination for me Cestevens....well done...Ed
Cestevens1783
Cestevens1783 replied 2nd Nov 2016 - 9 years ago
sorry for the uber late response, thank you!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 23rd May 2016 04:15 - 10 years ago

on On Edge by silverman
I`m good with electro..or whatever else people say...but I will say you seem to have a good way of just disregarding the genre boxes & doing damn good listening music Silverman...Top notch track going on here and I really enjoyed the listen...and ain`t that what counts....Cheers...Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 23rd May 2016 04:05 - 10 years ago

on the heartbeat by Prelude
I think DesignedImpression has a good idea Cindy...he does some really good string sounds...this is quite different...and thats a good thing...It has quite a bit of tension with appropriate breaks...always good to hear your creativity...keep this one going...Ed
Prelude
Prelude replied 23rd May 2016 - 10 years ago
hey how are you Ed ?
:)
yes I'm glad about his offer .

nice to see you here and thank you very much for the kind words .

Cindy
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 23rd May 2016 04:00 - 10 years ago

on Legendary by EazyBeatz
Nice easy listening up my way this evening Ernest...like the piano bit...nice panning & rich sound contrast with the backing...very cool track...I don`t know much about trap...its just good music that leaves the listener feeling good....Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 19th May 2016 00:10 - 10 years ago

on Alles was ich will - MDMA Mix by joecramer
It has a really nice flow Joe...perhaps a little dark, but to me its more of a calm mood...I like the minimalist approach, and you have the perfect voice for this...I like the music but I think your voice is the star...really well done...I like it...Ed
joecramer
joecramer replied 19th May 2016 - 10 years ago
That is a really nice comment Ed
Always good to read some positive stuff about my vocal work, cause deep inside i am more a singer than a musician.
Good to hear that you could enjoy the song.

stay tuned
joe
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 14th May 2016 22:46 - 10 years ago

on I Wanna Love You by DanielLondon
Hey Daniel...this is top notch man...did you do the vocal?...its really well done & mixed...definitely finish it...good laid back R&B just the way it should be....cheers...Ed
DanielLondon
DanielLondon replied 15th May 2016 - 10 years ago
Thanks man, yeah I did the vocals, I´ll upload the finished song when it´s done
Comments 301 - 325 of 1,619