Tumbleweed

Regina, Canada

Joined : 26th Nov 2010 - 15 years ago

Last Online : 28th Jun 2026 - 1 week ago

Loops Out

Tumbleweed comments on tracks

Tumbleweed has posted 1619 comments on other peoples tracks.

Comments 1001 - 1025 of 1,619

Tumbleweed 18th Oct 2013 16:46 - 12 years ago

on The City Never Sleeps With WEKILLTHEBEAR by Darkreine

definitely has that late night in the city vibe Kenny.....This one really puts me in mind of some of Chris Rea`s songs that I have recently spent some time listening to in my search for a bit of inspiration.....and that means its friggin awesome.......Ed

Darkreine replied 20th Oct 2013 - 12 years ago

Hey, Ed, really love Chris Rea ever since he was little boy lol! Thanx for your support as always and I haven't forgotten your Door's track!!

K;)

Tumbleweed 18th Oct 2013 16:39 - 12 years ago

on RufeLess - Dad by teamrufeless

heartfelt indeed....really like this one Lee....Your vocal is the star here...but must say you put together some thoughtful lyrics and delivered them like a pro.....like the interaction between the vocal and the guitar....really well done and I know its not an easy accomplishment.....nice to see a song delivered with all the dynamics intact too.....just a great job Lee....really did enjoy this one.....Ed

teamrufeless replied 18th Oct 2013 - 12 years ago

Hi Ed Thank you so much for your comments really appreciate it, like you i spent the summer doing other things and have returned with a more simple and honest approach, well thats what i was aiming for and your words have made me feel that i am on the right track. as for my comments on your track i completely understand i was just pointing out that your tracks always seem to bring out the lyrics from me, i have since completed the whole thing and should i get the music done ill point you at it . have a great weekend Lee

Tumbleweed 16th Oct 2013 23:28 - 12 years ago

on Dj Octx-Party -Cognac Remix by CognacXE

well done CognacXE......Ed

CognacXE replied 17th Oct 2013 - 12 years ago

Thanks Ed!! I appreciate the listen and the love!

Tumbleweed 16th Oct 2013 23:23 - 12 years ago

on The Valentines Song by MTGMusik

hope you find the vocal you want MTGMusik....its really well done......Ed

MTGMusik replied 16th Oct 2013 - 12 years ago

Thanks Ed. I can't wait till someone puts there spin on it!
Appreciate the listen and comment.

Tumbleweed 13th Oct 2013 23:10 - 12 years ago

on Im Walking Away by ScottFranco

yes...indeed a bit different for you pair of talents (and kudos to the vocalist for such a fine job)...I have tried to vary my own approach several times but I find when I pick up the old guitar my tracks end up sounding like something I did before...I`ll work on it some more....You guys just sound good whatever you decide to do Scott...lots of variation here and I like the way you placed the vocal nicely up front where it is clear/distinct.....keep on Scott & Franco.....your talent is showing again.....Ed

ScottFranco replied 15th Oct 2013 - 12 years ago

Thanks much, Ed. We always enjoy reading your comments on our tracks. I think what really helps us with our array of genres is the fact that we both have our roots in several different styles of music, not to mention there are two minds at work. We have also compared notes on artists we like, and we have similar musical idols and styles.

Again, your words are very encouraging and we appreciate them.

Ciao,
Franco & Scott

Tumbleweed 13th Oct 2013 22:47 - 12 years ago

on I Feel FT Tara Toxic by brillbilly

Oh...how did I miss this little gem...best stop over & check out Tara`s stuff soon ...although I`m no good at composing around acapellas for some reason...this one has a nice airy quality about it the way you placed the vocal & music mix....good one Chris...very enjoyable Sunday listening..well done to both of you...Ed

brillbilly replied 8th Nov 2013 - 12 years ago

Arrrggggg im so late to reply to this!

sorry ED!

Im my defence my goverment are screwing up my country lol

big thanks for your kind comments!

Yeah tara's got a lovely tone.!

***bb***

Tumbleweed 13th Oct 2013 17:32 - 12 years ago

on Super Saiyan by Felix

that changeup around 0:45 is really effective...its not a genre I would be a good source of feedback on but you obviously do it very well....nice job on the production...notice you brick walled it but still were able to leave the main dynamics intact....well done....Ed

Felix replied 13th Oct 2013 - 12 years ago

First of all, thank you for the feedback. I spent a little while on the change up, so I'm glad you noticed it. While mixing this track down, it didn't sound like it would be brick walled, but it was. I do need to work on that. Overall, I am glad you liked it. Thanks again for the feedback.

-Felix

Tumbleweed 13th Oct 2013 05:12 - 12 years ago

on Sik Style Ft Kayla Evans - Mindless by SikStyle1

you know its not my usual listening SikStyle....but I know when its well done...your gf deserves a reward for this one too...she`s good.........Ed

SikStyle1 replied 13th Oct 2013 - 12 years ago

Lol thanks man, That put a smile on her face now she wants to make more music.

Tumbleweed 13th Oct 2013 05:03 - 12 years ago

on hereforyou by domr30

you had my attention right at the intro domr30....excellent vocal...and I like the way you mixed it so that it is nicely up front and clear...beautiful orchestral backing music and acoustic guitar..it really is exceptionally well done....superb......Ed

Tumbleweed 13th Oct 2013 04:54 - 12 years ago

on Rocket Plane-featuring Samantha Nova by dansjoy4

oh yes the lady does indeed have a wonderful natural style about her vocal delivery..and you have it wrapped up in a nice warm blanket with the music...great listening over my way Dan......kudos to you on the mix too...really like the way you kept the vocal nicely up front..clear & distinct...great job & great listening...I could use lots more like this.....Ed

dansjoy4 replied 15th Oct 2013 - 12 years ago

Hey thanks Ed. Glad you enjoyed listening to this.

Tumbleweed 12th Oct 2013 19:22 - 12 years ago

on The Hypnotist - Black Sun by Indozizz

that drop bass to the break at 2:17 and 4:38 is great....good job on the main lead...sets it apart from the more usual arpeggio approach.....very nicely done Gerwin.....Ed

Tumbleweed 10th Oct 2013 02:44 - 12 years ago

on Sik Style - No More Sorrow by SikStyle1

A good listening song starts with the lyrics & the way they are delivered....and you do it well SikStyle...like the piano too...well done....You can stop over for another beer any time...Ed

SikStyle1 replied 10th Oct 2013 - 12 years ago

Lol thanks man im still drinking

Tumbleweed 10th Oct 2013 02:40 - 12 years ago

on Wondered Why w ImproveWithError on Vocals by MWRatridge

Hey Mark & Kyle....you guys could convert me to country....the way you do it is so close to Folk the difference doesnt matter...great work on the harmonies...but like all good songs of the genre it starts with the lyrics & the way they are delivered...and you do it well boys...I would maybe run a little bass in the mix but I can sure do without it....Bravo guys....more....Ed

Tumbleweed 7th Oct 2013 18:35 - 12 years ago

on Long Lonely Nights by beerling1970

one of your best beerling...carries the title theme really well...I have been absorbing a few lessons on the Loop today and I really like the quite minimal appraoch you have going here where every instrument plays a distinct part in the overall vibe....this is thoughtful stuff..creativity at its best (which is one of the reasons I love hanging out here wher I get a chance)......Ed

beerling1970 replied 16th Oct 2013 - 12 years ago

Thank you so much Ed so glad you like it :)

Tumbleweed 7th Oct 2013 03:00 - 12 years ago

on Platform 1b ft Behnam Zandi DeciBel by srbrown7

Hey Steve...just a note of thanks for the comments on Cloud Dancer...I went over to my music PC...muted the bass track (I used a simple synth bass on the version posted) and plugged in my old JazzBass which I am much more comfortable with...but tend to walk around a lot on....and did some different bass licks...big difference....I`ll leave the one I did posted ...but I`m slapping myself on the forehead for not letting myself do my old bass player things....thanks again...Ed

srbrown7 replied 7th Oct 2013 - 12 years ago

Hi Ed, thanks for the nice comments on Platform. Yes Behnam has really shined on this one and to be perfectly honest probably didn't give it his best shot which is scary! Behnam just played his part alongside my orignal posting of this song and sent the guitar work via email! No worries with the bass feedback. As I work alone its easy to forget all that I have at my disposal, or alternative approaches, or I find I get bored with a piece and go for a quick finish.
Kind regards
Steve

Tumbleweed 7th Oct 2013 02:33 - 12 years ago

on Unrequited love -Original Song- Soleil Lune by SoraSolitudine

Hi SoleilxLune....you know enough about music to convey some very pleasant Sunday evening listening over my way...it does have a touch of the meloncholy...but the lighter sounds & high strings keep it floating just above becoming sad (if you had added a cello it would have really come across much sadder)...I like it the way it is...not too meloncholy...but certainly thoughtful....You did very well...keep on doing it....Ed

SoraSolitudine replied 9th Dec 2013 - 12 years ago

Aww! Thank you very much for your words.
Well, I think that this one is very (extremely simple ._. )
I've not been able to compose these last weeks.
University takes all my time.
Anyway, maybe I'll upload another song of mine soon.
Thanks for listening and comment :D

Tumbleweed 7th Oct 2013 02:25 - 12 years ago

on TWO STEP TO YOUR HEART by abnerbesares

I hear a hint of good time Latin in that intro abnerbesares..hits a bit more of a traditional country beat stride around 1:35...Its good listening party music & you can put it in any genre you want...but why do I feel like I should go pop the top on a nice cool beer right now...haha....good work my freind...enjoyed it all the way...Ed

abnerbesares replied 8th Oct 2013 - 12 years ago

well i'm a fan of your work so thank you once again my friend for saying something,till next one.

Tumbleweed 7th Oct 2013 02:16 - 12 years ago

on Platform 1b ft Behnam Zandi DeciBel by srbrown7

oh man...love that bite-yer-arse-off guitar played with a ton of feeeling it...its like a whole bottle of blue...and I mean this is just totally great listening to my old ears guys...I knew Behnam was a very talented guy...didn`t realize he could nail the guitar like this....and I must say you have it wrapped up in a big warm blanket of goodness sr....I`d offer suggestions if I could...but this is honestly just the way it should be...best thing I`ve heard today...congrats guys..exceptionally well done...Ed

Tumbleweed 7th Oct 2013 00:03 - 12 years ago

on 100 seconds pianO for thinking to deaf people by deciBel

Hi Behnam....it is quite a unique piano sound...very bell like...but I know and you know...it is the feeling that the music conveys that speaks to the mind....you are special Behnam...and I am happy to have met you and your music here....Ed

deciBel replied 7th Oct 2013 - 12 years ago

Ed , master ,how are U ? lastnight I was thinking should write an email & ask '' How are U '' ?,cause there was no news from U for a couple of the days , and now I'm glad to see U fine .
and ...regardng your kind comment,first I rally wish U know this is not a compliment by an eastern guy if I say no doubT , I'm honoured to know U ( & some others too) here ..in fact I was so lucky Ed ..that day when I joined to looperman peradventure and U may don'T feel by yourself , U may don'T think so by yourself such about yourself if I honesty say beyond music & your lovely guitar playing style which I adore , I've learned ( & am still learning) so much from your personalitY( as a true manner of a master behaviour & talking )your insight & even talking ...
things which no doubT ar so more important & more worthy than the way we play instruments,and things which won't be teached in no college...
& has made me learn abouT personality & actually life for my future ..the days will pass and I may never can be honoured to see many of my unseen friends here who are dear for me ..like U , Danke , Steve Brown ,Chris ( brillbilly),Mike Stokes,Wayne , Domenico, even little Corina or even VickyDan & Patrick(spivkurl) althought we have never sent email to eachother and also many of others whom I don't make my reply longer by writing their names now ,humans who I knew them all here & We may never meet eachother , buT they are alive and will remain in my mind beyond the time ...... looperman worked as a college ,or some how a new university for me ,and more than music I've learned about personalitY & mastership behaiviour and insight in this site ,which is so worthy for me.
appology for long reply and my gratest appreciations to your attention for listening to this trial of mine & in he end as usual my best wishes . Sincerely.__Behnam

Tumbleweed 30th Sep 2013 23:46 - 12 years ago

on Child Of The Matrix by brillbilly

Oh I like that bit that kicks in around 1:50....a bit dark...but there is also a kind of majestic quality about the whole thing...really some very rich sounding pads evolving in the background..this was great listening right now as I am in one of those funks where my ideas aren`t enough to motivate me to sit down and play....superbly done Chris...floats itself all the way across the water to these old prairies...Ed

brillbilly replied 1st Oct 2013 - 12 years ago

Then what more can i add but thank you,for feeling my music!

I love the fact that music can be so universal!

Sending you kind warm vibes man!

Fire up that guitar man,you know she's worth it! Em Bm D A ish? bending notes,that easy chilled stuff that makes me go girly lol!

Peace my man!

***bb***

Tumbleweed 30th Sep 2013 03:09 - 12 years ago

on The PachelS Heart - Soleil Lune by SoraSolitudine

really pleasant Sunday evening listening over at my place...well done...and much enjoyed...Ed

SoraSolitudine replied 30th Sep 2013 - 12 years ago

Thank you very much for listening! :D

Tumbleweed 28th Sep 2013 21:19 - 12 years ago

on Shifted Progressions by DouglasS

oh yeah...that big transition around 1:50 is a work of art....(as are all of them)...great example of cinematic composing (3rd section..3:20 is a really effective switch)....Definitely music of the picture painting variety Doug...the great thing about the genre is the scope of license it provides for creativity...this is just a superb bit of work and the thought you put into the composition realy shows....a well done to you.....Ed

DouglasS replied 7th Oct 2013 - 12 years ago

Ed,

Thank you for your insight, I was faced with working with many parts that I couldn't in good conscience let go or remove, so I spent a good bit of time working on the transitions and had some fun doing so. As always, I appreciate your input, especially from someone as talented as yourself.

Doug

Tumbleweed 28th Sep 2013 00:03 - 12 years ago

on Speechless by Mahloo13

Mahloo...what you consider unfinished most of us would be happy to consider an achievement....The song, accompaniment and production are really well done...even if I have to confess that my ears are considerably less than they used to be...besides I eally like the laid-back styling so really enjoyed the listen...a well done to both of you....Ed

Mahloo13 replied 28th Sep 2013 - 12 years ago

Thank you Ed! I really appreciate it! We did have a lot of plans with this track but we never go around to re-record the vocals so the project kinda started collecting dust.

There is nothing wrong with your ears and your music speaks for that.

Thanks again!

Tumbleweed 27th Sep 2013 02:19 - 12 years ago

on THE ANSWER IS MAYBE by SERGEJ77 by SERGEJ77

Hi Serge...well..I dont do any of the social sites...just a couple of the smaller music communities where fellow musicians hang out....besides pictures of this old guy would just scare off any potential listeners....I do have a couple of little videos (including one with Carole (janis71) on my YouTube page here :
https://www.youtube.com/user/WestTracksMusic?feature=mhee
I just signed in to google plus but I havent a clue how it works yet....guess Im a bit old fashioned serge...I just like hanging out with you guys here on the loop....Ed

SERGEJ77 replied 21st Oct 2013 - 12 years ago

nice video you have there, goes well with your music...
SeE you around Ed...come to www.facebook.com/sergej.jovic.5

it's more interesting...
RGDS
SERGEJ

Tumbleweed 26th Sep 2013 23:14 - 12 years ago

on While You Were Sleeping by BrandonMichelle

With that smooth & expressive vocal delivery style I wouldn`t think you would be lacking in collab opportunities BM...really well done, and being just an instrumentalist myself I must say you have some very talented accompaniment in this one...and Daniel obviously has some extra big talent on that guitar....A big well done to both of you...I often have more than a few backing music compositions (usually done with the intention of adding some guitar melody) in my folders if you should need a mix or two for a rainy day just let me know.....Most of my tunes of late have been of the mellow variety but likely have 1 or 2 R&B type tunes unfinished right now if that style appeals to you....Anyway...enjoyed this one....keep on.....Ed

BrandonMichelle replied 9th Nov 2013 - 12 years ago

Thank you for all your kind words.

Respectfully,
Brandon Michelle

Comments 1001 - 1025 of 1,619