Tumbleweed

Tumbleweed

Regina, Canada
Joined : 26th Nov 2010 - 15 years ago
Last Online : 28th Jun 2026 - 1 week ago
Tumbleweed comments on tracks

Tumbleweed has posted 1619 comments on other peoples tracks.

Comments 951 - 975 of 1,619
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 13th Dec 2013 03:04 - 12 years ago

on Dont Stop ft Mariah Dawn by RoyaleMuzik
Love that big fat bass ChokiStarz and the way it contrasts with the higher/lighter sounds.....nice slow grooving, head-nodding kind of sound with just the right key prog & variations to keep it rolling & the ears perked...good job on this one..enjoyed the listen...Ed
RoyaleMuzik
RoyaleMuzik replied 13th Dec 2013 - 12 years ago
Thanks much for the comments Ed, greatly appreciated that!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 13th Dec 2013 01:11 - 12 years ago

on Quel Dommage ft Morpheusd by Darkreine
this one must have been hiding away somewhere on the Loop...(since May)....so...whioe not being a conniseur of the genre (as you know)...I just gotta leave a few words on this one Kenny...some great sounds...some creative stuff in the composition and the way you bring it all together & keep an ol guitar guys ears perked..dm, love those big fat pads you got in there this is a good one....Ed
Darkreine
Darkreine replied 13th Dec 2013 - 12 years ago
Hey ED, thanx for wandering over into the Darkside lol!! Always appreciate your support man.
K;)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 12th Dec 2013 21:41 - 12 years ago

on You Are The One by beerling1970
I really like the fact that you havent loaded the mix up with a ton of elements Steve...just the ones that carry it along perfectly and wrap around the vocal...It seems to be something I find in common with mixes that I really like...super job on this one...Ed
beerling1970
beerling1970 replied 13th Dec 2013 - 12 years ago
Less is More I was once told and I will say in this case it obviously worked well lol Thanks for listening Ed :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 12th Dec 2013 21:37 - 12 years ago

on Caught Between A Rock by Spivkurl
Hey Spiv,...if you say its dubstep I`ll take your word for it as I know squat about the electronic sub genres (and many other things)...Have to tell you I have a big smile on my face while I`m listening...sounds like that fella was cutting some bad gas but yet had the good sense to tune them nicely...what fun would music been if you couldn`t have some fun with it...good on ya...keep them creative juices flowing...no excuses needed...I`ll tune in....Ed
Spivkurl
Spivkurl replied 12th Dec 2013 - 12 years ago
I'm glad I could enhance your smiling, as your songs always cheer me up too! I've gotten the impression that you know more about electronic genres than a lot of people out there for real. Thanks so much for stopping by to listen!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 12th Dec 2013 21:11 - 12 years ago

on Ritual by Sevenola
your phone????...well it sure works out just fine...really interesting mix..lots of electronic elements but it carries a theme that would almost fit the bill for one of those medeival scenes...well done Sevenola....I see you`ve been busy with music lately...will have to catch up with your others soon....Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 11th Dec 2013 03:21 - 12 years ago

on Ode to my mom by musiclover38
This is special...and believe it or not I know the feelings you express so well in the music.....I came home from my younger brother`s funeral some years ago and had to sit down and play my feelings...I have never posted the result anywhere..likely never will...the felings are in the notes..in the beauty and simplicity of it all and the unspoken knowledge that our end here is not the end...This is music that speaks emotion that can`t be expressed in other ways.....thanks for posting...sympathies from me and God bless........Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 8th Dec 2013 02:06 - 12 years ago

on Man On Mars by Sevenola
I can hear why this is your fav Sevenola.....has a nice rolling along vibe & the kind of uplifting feel that leaves a smile on your face..The string stabs are a nice contrast with the beat & synth pad & the breaks/variations keep it interesting listening....enjoyed this one....Well done....Ed
Sevenola
Sevenola replied 8th Dec 2013 - 12 years ago
Thanks, I am so glad you liked it Ed :)
Comment much appreciated !
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 8th Dec 2013 02:00 - 12 years ago

on Do Da Toot by Sevenola
Musicians of my generation (older guys) have a hard time getting into some of the more recent sub genres Sevenola...but I`ve been finding it real interesting to do some checking around the Loop and particularly fellow artists who leave a few comments on my own noises...No lack of creativity..thats for sure...This one is kind of neat and I hear the creative thought you put into it...To my tastes (that I know are kind of old fashioned) I think a couple of little key changes in there somewhere would bump it up a notch...in any case..i gotta say...good for you...keep doing your own thing.....Ed
Sevenola
Sevenola replied 8th Dec 2013 - 12 years ago
Thanks Ed, coming from a musician from a great generation of musicianship that means a lot. Key change is a thought to put into Electronic Dance Music... I'll have to keep it in mind for sure, thanks for the feedback ! :D
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 7th Dec 2013 04:00 - 12 years ago

on Remix Pieces Ft Devyn Rose by SeriouslyJoking
Well SJ....now you`re getting serious...way to go..some neat production ideas (like those breaks & stops)....standing ovation..Ed
SeriouslyJoking
SeriouslyJoking replied 7th Dec 2013 - 12 years ago
Hi Ed - standing ovations from you!! Well, I have to say, that is the best comment ever and makes me very proud. I've been struggeling with this one for some time now...something always clashing with something else, but maybe I'm finally getting there.

Hope all is well with you!
/SJ =)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 7th Dec 2013 03:55 - 12 years ago

on Keep it simple by Lithman
Really like this one Lithman...beautiful piano and cool chord prog....you`ve got a good one going here...would maybe benefit from a little key change or 2 somewhere along the line just for a changeup...but its good listening....well done to you....Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 6th Dec 2013 02:07 - 12 years ago

on Beyond those ugly days by ALXSIX
very different intro...almost sounds like water in the stream running over rocks...then you hit all that sound fx stuff....I have to admit ALXIX that that the genre is not of my frequent listening list...but I also must say that my habit of checking out the music of fellow artists who leave any comments on my own noises seldom fails to produce some really interesting/creative listening...and no doubt that this is some creative thinking...and it helps me stretch the imagination a bit on different possibilities....well done....all the best to you.....Ed
ALXSIX
ALXSIX replied 6th Dec 2013 - 12 years ago
Thank you Ed for your listen and comments, really appreciated esp. from someone not into that kind of music!
It was really fun experimenting with all those fx, I wanted to know how far I could go that way.
Glad it helped you broaden the imagination on creativity!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 5th Dec 2013 21:12 - 12 years ago

on Just Tonight by theHumps
sounds dm good to me Wayne....def western vibe but with that blues feel....there is something to be said about keeping the mixes basic/a bit sparce (something I forget to do often)...it sure does let each instrument play its part effectively in the mix....and you have a nice clean mix going here....great job....Ed
theHumps
theHumps replied 6th Dec 2013 - 12 years ago
Hey Ed, thanks for swinging by!

I did this before I knew anything about interfaces, sequencers and controllers. It would probably sound different and more cluttered if I did it today having all they toys to play with. I like open mixes that can feature each instrument so I try to keep things simple.

I believe this was the second song I posted on the loop when I joined. Cool Edit Pro 2 has nothing on Ableton, hehe!

Take care Ed!

Wayne
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 1st Dec 2013 21:53 - 12 years ago

on you know im no good by domr30
Really well done domr30....very professional....enjoyed the listen....Ed
domr30
domr30 replied 3rd Dec 2013 - 12 years ago
merci pour ce commentaire musicalement domr
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 26th Nov 2013 23:20 - 12 years ago

on OLD BITCHES by zappo
Was doing some before supper listening & just had to log in to leave you a big well done on this one zappo...super bit of musical work here with a lot of creativity & extra large helping of talent....PJB is always the best of musical company...kudos to you both...and the production counts for big bonus marks....Ed
zappo
zappo replied 28th Nov 2013 - 12 years ago
hi ED
super bit of musical work here with a lot of creativity...lol

THANK S SO LOT
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 26th Nov 2013 20:34 - 12 years ago

on Voice of Violin by AIQIAmusic
I know I have heard a good dance mix...when it is also good listening music....great job on this one GalaXProject...enjoyed the listen...Ed
AIQIAmusic
AIQIAmusic replied 6th Dec 2013 - 12 years ago
thank you for ya nixe words!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 26th Nov 2013 15:35 - 12 years ago

on Your No Good For me by midiman007
Super bit of funky listening over my way midiman...It really is well done and kudos to you of the playing and the nice even production....much enjoyed...Ed
midiman007
midiman007 replied 27th Nov 2013 - 12 years ago
Tumbleweed it is so great to hear nice compliments from you. I do appropriate everything since I know when it comes from someone who plays an instrument or instruments it really is from the heart. Peace..
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 22nd Nov 2013 23:10 - 12 years ago

on High Ft Carrol by SeriouslyJoking
Dont put it in the bin SJ...I can hear a lot of good work (and talent) that went into this one..Good for you on that bassline..that drop at 2:45 really works well and the drums are subtle enough to let the bass do its thing...the big reverb on Carrol`s vocal works well in this one too...The whole mix has a nice big rich sound...Its really well done...the only thing that I could think of as I was listening was that a couple of little key changes somewhere along the way might kick it up another notch....enjoyed this one...keep on.....Ed
SeriouslyJoking
SeriouslyJoking replied 22nd Nov 2013 - 12 years ago
Hi again, Ed!
About that bass - I didn't even consciously notice the bass in songs before and didn't understand what all the fuss was about...you guys here talking about great basslines etc. etc.
And then I suddenly started to hear it too. (It's OK to laugh, it's both hilarious and embarrassing... =D)
So this is kind of a big musical revelation for me: The bass is what brings the music alive somehow...well, I haven't quite figured it out yet but I'm getting there.

In this case however, it's a very simple and amatourish bassline of course, I'm aware of that. Just celebrating my new knowledge by building a song around that bass which just happened to popp out in an other song where it didn't belong, that's all.

Key changes are a good idea, it's very flat and veeeeeery long, this song.
So some key changes and also just half a song could be my next move here.
Thanks for listening and for the advice!

Take care! /SJ
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 22nd Nov 2013 16:25 - 12 years ago

on if i aint got you baby section 1 by Candelaria
You`ve got a good one going here Candelaria...exceptionally well done...cool vocal delivery....well done....If you are looking for flamenco check our ferryterry here on LM.....Ed
Candelaria
Candelaria replied 1st Jan 2014 - 12 years ago
Tumbleweed i got thrilled to read your comment .
just appology for late reply .
i appreciate your listening and ear and comment .
and i am still waiting to recceive your mail since previous comment of yours !
i like your music .
but i need your email first .
thank you very much .
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 22nd Nov 2013 16:21 - 12 years ago

on exception by domr30
Great job domr30....this is really well done...congrats to both of you...much enjoyed.....Ed
Tumbleweed
Outstanding brotbackautomat....great vocal of course...and you did a super job on the accompaniment and production.....Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 15th Nov 2013 03:18 - 12 years ago

on 100 Seconds spanish guitar dueT of Me ft Mysef by deciBel
Behnam.....if you are going to do playing like this we are all goping to be calling you the genius....I listened to the copy you sent several times as well as this one...I know you structure it carefully...yet it comes across as free-form......Domenico makes some good points in his review....Your playiong is just excellent my friend...I will never be able to play the strings that fast in my lifetime....and also important...you have made some obvious variations to keep it interesting...The introduction was unexpected but definitely commands the listeners attention....Now...if you are going to do a CD for download...listeners (and me also) will want you to play longer songs....and I know you can do that....perhaps a little bridge in the middle..and then a new variation of your theme.....You deserve the many compliments our friends on The Loop are giving you Behnam.....(Told you so..HaHa).....Bravo Behnam.....standing ovation......Ed
deciBel
deciBel replied 16th Nov 2013 - 12 years ago
Master generous words & great adices of yours makes me remember how was forgotten frame of smile on my face ,& thnx alot fr al mastershp encouragements & supports. Ed I've learned never people judge us true . neither when friends call U genius or when a unknown id of a countrymates for unknown reasons calls U such generous words like ##### and nsyas U should get a muzzle like his horse as U saw they did here with me to appreciate me for showing U foreigners that my country has talents . as I've seen even our parents , our childs , or oure wives to judge us false as We do this mistake about them too , so as I told U another time in mail too never mind to what people call me Ed ..cause I know I don't deserve to be called genius and ##### neither . and master particulary i really don't think playing fast is greatest point of a guitarist .. I should confess tha I played this trial fast cause because of some private matters I was worry for someone who i love her more than my being and i'm sure if i was not worry tempo won't go more than 100 bmp cause personaly I enjoy when I hold my guitar and play his hair smooth and sow and gentle and kind ,and this complicated harmony of this 2 lines is what I enjoy about mathematiX & what depends on my crowded mind .about timing particulary i think 100 seconds is enough cause I think listeners find no way but repeat my traX again and again buT
if Ed,Master is supposed to listen , I'll send him main version of trial which has been about 3 minutes todaY cause he is a special audiance for me whose idea has exclusive value. thnx Ed,master for all your attentions and advices and instructive points & taken time of yours in mails & here too,accept my greatest appreciations,please take care and in the end my best wishes for U .___Behnam
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 12th Nov 2013 22:09 - 12 years ago

on The Fool by theHumps
Its been a lucky music day for me Wayne...had a little while to spend catching up a bit on the Loops and what a treat ...finding new posts from my fav artists..I love acoustic instruments so this one is a big treat...Has a bit of a Western, folky vibe and no matter what genre it is I really enjoyed it....Good decision to upload...another fav...Ed
theHumps
theHumps replied 13th Nov 2013 - 12 years ago
I did the same thing. folk? acoustic? chillout? country? lol!

Acoustic music has always been my favorite, whether it's Pete Seeger or Aerosmith unplugged, I just love the acoustic guitar!! The story behind writing it and it's name is a good personal humorous story.

Thanks for stopping by Ed and appreciate the nice words!

Wayne
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 12th Nov 2013 21:54 - 12 years ago

on Falling From The Sky Broken Branch Mix by visionarysoundsystem
You`ve got my speakers pumping Vis....and now my ears are loving it too...I wondered how it would sound when I looked at the Wav picture...and now I know....that pumping comp really works on this one...very effective in fact...If anyone is movable this one will get them moving...great work again.....Ed
visionarysoundsystem
visionarysoundsystem replied 12th Nov 2013 - 12 years ago
Hey Ed thanx for stopping by my good friend. Really appreciate your kind comments mate. Much appreciated as always.
Peace, Love, Justice & respect.
Vis . . . .
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 12th Nov 2013 21:46 - 12 years ago

on Land of jade by janis71
What a nice surprise...yet another piece of musical art from our favourite vocalist....and as a bonus there is some excellent accompaniment music...but as always...the vocal is the star...Excellent...............Ed
janis71
janis71 replied 18th Nov 2013 - 12 years ago
I'm in the mood for r'n'b too this moment so I guess you'll soon hear from me, Ed ... :D
Isn't it wonderful to read such warm and encouraging words from one of the best musicians here ?! I'm so lucky and happy !
But don't be too good to me, Ed, I might take your words for granted and really think I can win "France's got talent", hehehe ( see my answer to Chris ) .
Thanks a lot my dear friend and do take care,
kisses
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 11th Nov 2013 17:32 - 12 years ago

on New hiphop beat or rap beat by johnnyproducing
Nice Job on this one Johnny....I like that you have brought quite a few different elements into the mix...I dont mind the sparcer hiphop mixes but find that many of them get very repetative if you listen close to the backing music...Hope you find the vocal you want....well done...Ed
johnnyproducing
johnnyproducing replied 14th Nov 2013 - 12 years ago
I have the same feeling about other hiphop mixes that's why I decided to make something different, I mean it's indeed ok to have the sort of repetitive hiphop beats but when I listen to them I get annoyed after a while because they stay the same from start to end
Comments 951 - 975 of 1,619