Tumbleweed

Tumbleweed

Regina, Canada
Joined : 26th Nov 2010 - 15 years ago
Last Online : 3rd Dec 2025 - 2 days ago
Tumbleweed comments on tracks

Tumbleweed has posted 1626 comments on other peoples tracks.

Comments 476 - 500 of 1,626
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 16th Sep 2015 20:08 - 10 years ago

on Thug Beat by Gnasty
good job with the panning on the hats..like that real subby bass hitting on the lows...I think the kind of minimal backing music leaves a lot of room for anybody who might add the vocal..has a little R&B kind of vibe that I like...keep on Gnasty.....Ed
Gnasty
Gnasty replied 17th Sep 2015 - 10 years ago
Its definitely minimal, I'm not sure whether I like it or not. Do you think I should add a pad or ambient noise or keep it as is?
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 15th Sep 2015 22:58 - 10 years ago

on undergroundsound dance by joecramer
You are a creative guy Joe...always something a bit different and always interesting to hear what you come up with...nice groove to this one as it moves right along...your voice goes well with the music (reminds me just a little of Da Da Da by Trio)but you have a better beat happening...it is a little dark but I think that comes mainly from the choice of sounds and some of the effects, plus the perpetual groove of the drums...well done to you...keep on....Ed
joecramer
joecramer replied 16th Sep 2015 - 10 years ago
What a gentle comment Ed :)

In a way the most things i make sounds a bit dark.
This one is realy very repetive and so it is in fact close to this Da DA DA one from Trio. Cool to know that i got a better beat :)
I never tryed to do something "normal" or maybe i tryed but never end with something close to normal. So you can be sure i will keep on doing music in that way.

Thanks for the friendly words. Realy nice to hear things like that from a real musican like you.

stay tuned joe
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 15th Sep 2015 22:43 - 10 years ago

on White Lights by NitramBeatS
you can sign me up for this kind of hip hop NitramBeatS...(the more usual hip hop tracks aren`t on my frequent listening menu)...you take it to another level...really like the rich textured pads and the smooth R&B type flow you have going on here...great job...keep raising the bar....Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 15th Sep 2015 21:48 - 10 years ago

on bicycles in love by DanGoldstein
Its experimenters like you that take musical ideas to new places Dan..Zappa did music that wasn`t always preferred listening for many of us...but it sure was interesting and a source of creative ideas....not sure about how those bicycles are going to get along (but since more than a few humans find that difficult too they just as well give it a shot HaHa)...Always a pleasure to stop by your place and hear what you have been up to....well done....keep on...Ed
DanGoldstein
DanGoldstein replied 15th Sep 2015 - 10 years ago
Hey, Ed. I was always falling asleep in harmony class or otherwise distracted so I have had no choice but to come up with my own musical language. It's fun trying to create connections between the visual and the sonic. It is my muse. Glad you had a chance to hear. hopefully this one has some more to come. Best regards - Dan
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 15th Sep 2015 04:09 - 10 years ago

on Almost and Never by Cestevens1783
I think danke`s comments are right on...good use of the loops..you integrate them really nicely Cestenens...really nice little uplifting kind of mix...and I wish we hade more of those...well done to you.....now do the vocal...Ed
Cestevens1783
Cestevens1783 replied 25th Nov 2015 - 10 years ago
Thank you very much :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 8th Sep 2015 03:35 - 10 years ago

on Shes Nachos by vigwig
Good for you vigwig...I have never been brave enough to try doing a vocal myself (for which the listening public should be grateful)...some nice traditional elements in there (guitars)...has a wee touch of that old & a bit of the new...keep doing it man...we could use a bit more country around here....its an honest genre thats great for those story songs...Ed
vigwig
vigwig replied 8th Sep 2015 - 10 years ago
Thanks for the listen and kind words. Do you have a breathy, raspy voice or can you massage it into one? With a moniker like Tumbleweed, I'd listen. Maybe no Crystal Gayle but at least a Don Williams or Tom T Hall. I got a stylized country-ishsong "My Baby's Got No Juice" which is pretty good. Not much on lyrics but loaded with signature country elements.
Vic
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 8th Sep 2015 03:30 - 10 years ago

on Prison by the Sea by toastedavalanche
I like this one toasted av and your voice sounds really good...fits the music backing perfectly...very nice chord prog (and that always grabs my attention)...instruments are nicely placed...just seems everything about it fits well...great job..Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 7th Sep 2015 22:03 - 10 years ago

on Im a stone ft MrFunktastic with Shamoozey by promenade2239
You have the best of musical company for this one Alex and I understand the kind of compositional thinking and work that goes into make it all come together so well...You did a super job on it..I worked on a mix a couple of weeks ago that I wanted to get some of Joe`s piano loops into but I didn`t like what I was adding so its still on a back burner somewhere...nice idea getting Shamoozey`s vocal in there..it sets it apart nicely....well done...good listening too..Ed
promenade2239
promenade2239 replied 7th Sep 2015 - 10 years ago
Thank you!

I am really happy that you liked the arrangement and my vision on this song! I did it very quickly on headphones so there are probably still many anomalies in the actual mix. Now I can hear them so do not worry haha. There is no processing on the acapella. I must say I was playing this version on internal laptop speakers earlier today and it sounded harmonically painful to me. There is still no real bassline on this track.
I am still too much into a real life at the moment. I whish I could contribute more as a real player and music creator sometime.
Thank you for listening and the kind words. It is much appreciated!
Best to you, Alex
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 21st Aug 2015 02:36 - 10 years ago

on I like the way you look at me ft Oceanically by promenade2239
laid back way late in the night sexy listening...the shuffly beat & minimal accompaniment really works with Ocean`s perfectly placed up front vocal...very effective....well done to both of you....feels like I`m right at the lounge.....think I`ll have a cool drink...Ed
promenade2239
promenade2239 replied 23rd Aug 2015 - 10 years ago
Hello Ed

I am sorry for a little delay in replying.

Gled you liked this older production of mine. It was made the moment I joined the site but I think there's still something nice about this song...

Thank you for your nice words - as always I much appreciate that.

Alex
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 21st Aug 2015 02:28 - 10 years ago

on Stormy Monday Blues by PDMuzak
You are a talent to be reckoned with Pat...they should be playing you on my radio instead of the stuff thats there....so get yourself booked into a venue around here & I`ll buy a ticket (& tell everyone I know) and come listen to you all night....its classically good my friend with your own special spices added to bounce it up a few more notches...I like the way you seem to be able to walk through the additional keys in those transitions....o.k.... standing ovation from this ol boy out on the prairies....keep em coming.....Ed
PDMuzak
PDMuzak replied 21st Aug 2015 - 10 years ago
Thanks Ed. This is actually an old track on drive that I dusted off did some punch in/out.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 21st Aug 2015 02:07 - 10 years ago

on Disco Money by ScottB55
I`m sitting here smiling Scott...reminds me of days on the road back then...used to slip down to whatever club was in the hotel for a listen & a nightcap...it was goodtime music no matter what some may now think of it & set up a lot of what was to come thereafter...you do it well (as always)...has the whole vibe...good listening over my way...just a great job ..as I have come to expect...Ed
ScottB55
ScottB55 replied 27th Aug 2015 - 10 years ago
Hey Ed,

Glad I could put a smile on your face! Our situations on the road must be similar, since I use to do the same thing. Yeah, disco got a bad rap back then, but I do look back fondly in my days with a big disco horn band.

Anyway, thanks for giving it a listen and leaving your kind words.

Cheers,
Scott
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 18th Aug 2015 16:58 - 10 years ago

on To War by silverman
your versatility is showing again silverman...yes..def has a cinematic vibe to my ear..& fits the marching off to war picture nicely...the distorted guitar(?) bit around 3:oo does it a bit of the retro rock vibe...great job mate....Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 11th Aug 2015 22:38 - 10 years ago

on Fairy Roads Updated by MGproduct
Good for you MG...welcome to Looperman....I think you have all the parts of a good song here...the music is good and your singing is fine...the technical things about mixing the final product will improve as you do it more often...I like your words.....well done...keep on doing your music...Ed
MGproduct
MGproduct replied 12th Aug 2015 - 10 years ago
Thanks Tumbleweed
Im Happy In Looperman
I Wanna Find Professional Friends To Improve My Skills

MG
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 11th Aug 2015 15:36 - 10 years ago

on Orrie in the city of vice updated Drums by DijamMusic
HaHa....hey jamid...cant say I have pictured our talented friend Orlando drunk...but you do set a cool scene here..it has that bit of old-time detective movie vibe that would fit Orlando`s appearance....you have nice width on the mix...I think the drums work really well...I always have a hell of a time finding drums I like so I know it can be lots of trying & searching for what fits the music just right (make a big difference too...as you know)...the ride cymbal addition is spot on...you just keep getting better...well done....keep on....Ed
DijamMusic
DijamMusic replied 12th Aug 2015 - 10 years ago
Ed,
Hello mate,
Thank you very much for your kind feedback.
I think our friend he is not too worried about the drink so much as long as we keeping him with those lovely vice girls haha.
Mate, you too kind to me with your feedbacks and as they are coming from a world class master like you it means a lot.
Thanks again.
Jamid
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 9th Aug 2015 04:53 - 10 years ago

on IMAGES OF THE PAST by Planetjazzbass
...and you top the whole production off by managing to get that elusive live sound...not much to say Dave...just total funky goodness (with a wee sprinkle of jazz) that sounds great..appreciate the intricacy of the mix...the funky rhythm guitar...the bass that is always something special in your compositions...the extra tasty chords backing the event..the hammond style organ with a bit of key attack...hell..its all just good...I have been royally entertained this evening....bravo...Ed
Planetjazzbass
Planetjazzbass replied 15th Aug 2015 - 10 years ago
Hey Ed thanks man!...everyone that's ever picked up a guitar will gladly get on the funk train,the question is can you ever get off,there doesn't seem to be any station stops! lol...thanks again for your great review mate! cheers Dave and Detlef :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 5th Aug 2015 03:56 - 10 years ago

on Farewell my lovely by DijamMusic
jamid....this is one hell of a fine listening and very emotional track...you outdid yourself (again) this time...I do agree with T.G`s comments about bass..a nice soft sub bass would go great,,,I even think this one could sail along nicely on its own without the drums & just let the instruments carry their own rhythm or maybe a little subtle percussion...not to detract from what you have done here, but after listening I keep thinking...lordy..some nice quiet rich sounding strings would take this over the moon....You`ve got a good one going here mate...music and emotion love each other....a big well done to you....keep on...Ed
DijamMusic
DijamMusic replied 5th Aug 2015 - 10 years ago
Ed
Hello mate,
Thank you ever so much for your kind and generous feedback and input.
I am really glad you liked it.
I have made a few changes with what I had, I hope I have been successful to do that poor man a justice.
Thanks again
Jamid
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 3rd Aug 2015 20:55 - 10 years ago

on I Know The Way by ScottB55
Did you do the vocal Scott??....its one hell of a fine job....really good expression & delivery & totally on key...quite an intricate accompaniment mix but everything gets along well together...yes, I think power ballad nails it...and it rocks...well done.....Ed
ScottB55
ScottB55 replied 5th Aug 2015 - 10 years ago
Thanks allot, Ed. Unfortunately, it's not my vocals...I wish. I found this pella on the net over a year ago and knew one day I would do something with it, and finally did.

Cheers,
Scott
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 1st Aug 2015 17:37 - 10 years ago

on Sensational Sford Remix by sford
Hi sford....I think asidRn has some interesting comments and he is definitely a lot more up on the genre than I am...I`m o.k. with the piano volume but the hard limiting is quite obvious (especially on the drums)...I know this is typical of some of the club genres where its designed to get people moving, but on listening music it does indeed knock out a lot of the instrument dynamics...you are doing a lot of things well..so its just a matter of keeping on doing it, getting a bit of feedback, reading everything you can from professional sources, & finding your own mixing habits...give some thought to getting some key changes into the track as well as the drops and other techniques that go with some of the current sub-genres...it tends to bring them up a notch or two....anyway...you`re off to a damn good start...just keep on...Ed
sford
sford replied 3rd Aug 2015 - 10 years ago
Thanks dude. I'm finding it incredibly difficult to top my first track.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 31st Jul 2015 04:31 - 10 years ago

on so this is your love by lostjoe333
Hey Joe....this is about as live sounding as we are likely to hear anywhere...feel like I`m down at a local spot listening to some classically good rock band....O.K. good stuff man...now I`ll grab another brew & sit a bit for a listen...Ed
lostjoe333
lostjoe333 replied 3rd Aug 2015 - 10 years ago
thanks so much ed....i used to play this out down at the bars, but i only had me on bass and a drummer....lol
thanks for the kind words....
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 28th Jul 2015 22:28 - 10 years ago

on Internet by Rhodesy
put in any genre you like and I`ll still like it...I suppose genres are useful when we are looking for a particular type of listening...but I`ve never considered them a useful reference for composing....like the way you have the kick & toms placed in the mix (aint technology great)..and as others have said...its a fine mix indeed...and its good funky listening on a stormy afternoon over here on the Canadian prairies.....Ed
Rhodesy
Rhodesy replied 29th Jul 2015 - 10 years ago
Thankyou,you are a gentlemen Sir.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 28th Jul 2015 22:15 - 10 years ago

on Holes by visualword
o.k. that intro may be just drums & stand up bass...but I was getting a nice Motown vibe from it...I`m guessing you spent more than a little time on this one...quite intricate the way you use the instruments...and if you do this with samples and a midi keyboard I think you have some really good chops on the keys too...talent seems to have a way of showing up in the results...and you`re blessed with a big helping of it vis...another good listening one this afternoon...well done to you...Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 28th Jul 2015 22:08 - 10 years ago

on Weather by visualword
right off the bat I like that drum kit...and the touch of funk that comes along with the horns...is that a tuba you are using for the low end vis ...nice helping of the jazz vibe as the mix moves along...find the horn & string instrumentation really interesting...enjoy both but its been a while since I have heard them carry the whole composition...a little reminder of the Big Band days strikes me....Good to hear something different on the Loop...especially something done this well....right on...Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 27th Jul 2015 16:08 - 10 years ago

on Legacy of the dark mind by DijamMusic
Finally caught up with this one...you have been a prolific producer lately jamid...love that fat clean guitar at the intro...very smooth flowing track and I`m a sucker for those nice chord progressions you have going here. The clean sound seems to make a guitar`s true voice sound so much better/richer....has a wee touch of midevil minstrel in a few spots...beat/drums go nicely with the backing mix...really like this one jamid...great job..I could handle lots more like this...Ed
DijamMusic
DijamMusic replied 28th Jul 2015 - 10 years ago
Ed,
Hello mate,
Thank you for your kind feedback.
I am glad you liked it I do have a couple more similar that are in my maybe folder I am hopping to finish them soon.
Thanks again and really well done on your new track with Orlando.
Jamid
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 25th Jul 2015 21:05 - 10 years ago

on Love Is A Verb by Twanna1
You can sing on my radio any day Twanna...this is really well done...meaningful lyrics...great job in the vocal delivery (there is a little sibilance in the lead vocal...notable most at the intro...easy fix)...right on accompaniment & nicely produced..guess that makes it all good.....This is the way R&B should be done...superb...a tip of the hat to you and a definite fav....bravo.....Ed
Twanna1
Twanna1 replied 19th Aug 2015 - 10 years ago
Thank you Ed for your kind words. It would be an honor to sing on your radio anyday. This style of "spoken word" is new for me, but I love trying something different, getting away from the typical.

Much love to you.

Twanna
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 24th Jul 2015 17:51 - 10 years ago

on Tripwire Valley by Evisma
Definite Celtic vibe Evan...and since thats a genre I like a lot (when its updated to include more modern instrumentation with the traditional melody stuff) I enjoying the listen...nice clean production by the way...everything is really clear & distinct in the mix.....a big well done...Ed
Evisma
Evisma replied 29th Jul 2015 - 10 years ago
Mr. Ed.

I appreciate the kind words, especially about the mix. I've been trying to get better in every aspect as I go, so it's nice to hear I'm doing something right!

Take care.

Evan
Comments 476 - 500 of 1,626