Tumbleweed

Tumbleweed

Regina, Canada
Joined : 26th Nov 2010 - 15 years ago
Last Online : 28th Jun 2026 - 1 week ago
Tumbleweed comments on tracks

Tumbleweed has posted 1619 comments on other peoples tracks.

Comments 451 - 475 of 1,619
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 22nd Oct 2015 22:29 - 10 years ago

on Janis71 Disco snippet by Rasputin
you cant go wrong with janis71 in a mix rasputin....keep it going...sounds good so far...and dont worry a lot about the technical perfection (This sounds fine by the way)...Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 19th Oct 2015 03:00 - 10 years ago

on Fever - Peggy Lee cover by ScottB55
absolutely remember the Peggy Lee version...classic in every way...gotta have that standup bass for sure....I think Easy Evil would be my all time Peggy Lee fav (had in on vinyl)...but I actually liked the version of it John Kay did in the 80 even better...great job Scott...I appreciate that you kept the mix quite minimal with just the synth strings adding a bit of air in the background...Iguess there wouldn`t be many singers that could do that soulful style that Peggy did but it sounds good as an instrumental....enjoyed this one man....Ed
ScottB55
ScottB55 replied 7th Nov 2015 - 10 years ago
Thanks allot, Ed. Glad you like it. This and 'Pass me by' are my two favorites, but don't really listen to her much. It was one my mom liked, so thought I'd give it a go. Will have to check out 'Easy Evil,' though.

Cheers,
Scott
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 17th Oct 2015 03:59 - 10 years ago

on Beatnik Dream by PDMuzak
That little section around .25 in reminded mw a wee bit of swinging shepherd blues (even though its entirely different)...just the chiffy flute lead I guess (my age is showing)...I have known of your playing talent for a long time Pat....but your composing talent is certainly on display in this one...I suppose its not something (or a genre) that a majority of LM folks may recognize,...but man...you are one rare talent...and one for whom I have the utmost admiration and respect...I really did enjoy the listen to this one...definitely a fav....a tip of the hat to you my friend...I`ll mail you on an idea I have....Ed
PDMuzak
PDMuzak replied 17th Oct 2015 - 10 years ago
thanks Ed. Lately I have been working a lot of overtime in rotating shift work. Which leaves me no time. The obscure thing about it is when I am short on time my creative process is actually enhanced. When I sit down for 4 hours of uninterrupted time , my mind goes blank. Go figure. Pat
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 16th Oct 2015 03:25 - 10 years ago

on HipHop-Thingy by soundhound
Guess I was away from the loop longer than I realized...so just catching up with this one now...Hip Hop eh?....well, you can out it under any genre you want and it still sounds good...very creative stuff...with the guitar, processed vocals & hip hoppy beat (I think hip hop drums layer with damn near anything ...I`ve been doing it a lot to add some extra kicks etc)...you gotta know I like the guitar...right on....Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 16th Oct 2015 03:19 - 10 years ago

on In Violet Dreams by cellardoor
wow....this should be getting a lot more listens (and comments)...did you do the vocals?...they are just superb...and the accompaniment is top notch....noting to offer...I`ll just listen & join the applause......great track....Ed
cellardoor
cellardoor replied 16th Oct 2015 - 10 years ago
Thank you for the wonderful compliments! Yes, the vocals are mine. =) Yay, I'm so happy that you like this.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 16th Oct 2015 03:07 - 10 years ago

on Allure by 7venth12
I like it 7venth....it has a nice uplifting kind of vibe...and couldn`t we all use more of that...intro is very cool...that little break that starts around 2:18 & repeats around 3:25 is great with the nice clean guitar strums (vst guitars sound good when they are used right...& you have it nailed here)...I dont know (or care) much about some genres...but I know what I like to hear & must say I enjoyed this one...keep on..you do it well and you will keep getting better at it....Ed
7venth12
7venth12 replied 16th Oct 2015 - 10 years ago
Thank you so much! Comments like these are what keeps me producing, glad you liked it!!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 15th Oct 2015 21:08 - 10 years ago

on frederick by joecramer
Well Joe...when you look at the state of humanity on our planet its hard not to get depressed...but fortunately we can express the darkness in music & art rather than action...you certainly accomplish it well...really like the choirs and the way they combine so well with your main vocal...and that cool little beat keeps it all evolving along nicely....well done to you...Ed
joecramer
joecramer replied 16th Oct 2015 - 10 years ago
Thanks a lot Ed

Nice to know that you think that the vocals and the choirs work well together and that the beat fits to, cause it wasn't realy easy to make the choirs and this beat.

A well done from your side is always something i enjoy

stay tuned
joe
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 15th Oct 2015 20:46 - 10 years ago

on As Life Goes On by OmarMuk
Nice mix of the classical and modern (synth) sounds...I think the great thing about the Cinematic genre is it just lets you play to any picture or feeling you want without worrying about what genre box it fits...you do it well..and this one allows the listener to add their own mind picture...nice emotional flow and good listening...well done Omar....enjoyed...Ed
OmarMuk
OmarMuk replied 18th Oct 2015 - 10 years ago
Thanks Ed.
My forte is hip hop and when I venture outside of that I still have a little bit of that influence so I get stuck on the genre thing. But I guess its like you said, cinematic has such a wide range.

Thanks again
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 14th Oct 2015 20:44 - 10 years ago

on Jahjah And Rainso - After The Fact by zacvoos
the piano makes for a nice intro...great bassy synth groove works a treat...a bit different than my usual listening genre zac, but its really well done and the hard limiting seems to work best on these synth based dance/club mixes....keep on...Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 14th Oct 2015 03:41 - 10 years ago

on Changes None by toastedavalanche
I lived with Tascam 8 track decks for years & wore out the outside heads I used them so much...it makes an honest musician of the user...nowhere to hide...just the music...I noticed the acoustic was nicely recorded but your vocal is the star T.A...good for you....a big well done to you...enjoyed this one...Ed
toastedavalanche
toastedavalanche replied 15th Oct 2015 - 10 years ago
Thank you TW. It was difficult to get the takes right at first, but as soon as I relaxed and learned to love the soft hiss of the tape deck, I really enjoyed the experience. Also, I'm relieved that you liked the vocals, I always feel nervous about showcasing my voice. Though I'm starting to use it more and more lately.

Cheers,

TA
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 14th Oct 2015 03:37 - 10 years ago

on Give Me A Chance - Opinions Needed by BradoSanz
You nailed the Pop vibe E.R...its better than most of what my radio plays...like many, I have come to dislike autotune when its noticeable...but there are obviously ways of using it that just work...and you did it here..I agree with the Kick comments, although thats a bit of a personal taste thing rather than anything that detracts from the mix...You would be in the top echelon of the charts if I was rating it...great job...Ed
BradoSanz
BradoSanz replied 30th Oct 2015 - 10 years ago
My apologies, my dearest Tumbleweed! I just saw this comment. I do appreciate your kind words. And yes, it seems the biggest problem here is my kick tightness. But alas, when your computer is horrible, then everything else suffers :c Maybe I'll be able to upgrade soon! That'd be quite nice lol
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 1st Oct 2015 23:00 - 10 years ago

on Hold You Closer - Acoustic Instrumental VOX Rdy by BradoSanz
If I wasn`t already a fan I sure would be after listening to this one E.R...you`ve outdone yourself again man...this is the real kind of stuff that I just love to listen to...go to the head of the class....hope you get the vocal you want..the track definitely invites one.....bravo....Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 1st Oct 2015 22:55 - 10 years ago

on Eve - Vocals and Orchestration by Cellar Door by cellardoor
I haven`t had much music time lately...but I just had to log in to leave you a big WELL DONE on this one cellar door...your vocal reminds me a bit of Karen Carpenter...a good song, well delivered and accompanied outshines any of those little technical/production issues that may concern you..and there is absolutely nothing wrong with this production..you have a nice warmth to the vocal & those mic limitations don`t seem to matter...this is in fact better that a majority of the vocals I hear posted...I would much rather hear the natural dynamics & expression than a squashed/limited to death version...great job...this one is a keeper (write it down somewhere)....Fav,,....Ed
cellardoor
cellardoor replied 3rd Oct 2015 - 10 years ago
Thanks Ed. That review was a real confidence booster. I'm glowing!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 29th Sep 2015 23:04 - 10 years ago

on Love You Down and Party by ScottB55
great composition & arrangement Scott...fits the description to a T...really like that hammond organ..very tasty guitar lines around 3:40...was it a vst gtr?....Always good listening over here at your place...great track...Ed
ScottB55
ScottB55 replied 30th Sep 2015 - 10 years ago
Hi Ed,

Thanks allot for your kind words. Yeah, a lot of people like the Hammond, but unfortunately, it's not used much in today's music. I still love listening to all those organ based rock bands of the 60s and 70s. Damian is basically a piano player, but I think his organ and synth playing is as good as his piano.

Cheers,
Scott
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 24th Sep 2015 22:20 - 10 years ago

on whatsGoing by Spivkurl and promenade by promenade2239
I find it a treat to hit the play button when 2 talented and yet different artists put their musical ideas together in a collab...and especially 2 as creative as you 2..It is indeed different (I would have guessed that part before I hit play)..Hope you don`t mind the comparison (of reaction...not the music)..but it puts me in mind of the first time I listened to David Byrne & The Talking Heads...It was totally different..completely off to the side from what was mainstream at the time..Yet It just made a big splash in my mind as fantastically wild, fun,spontaneous, addictingly good music...So obviously I enjoyed this one..unique combination of the vocals & instrumentation...great job Alex & Spiv....Ed
promenade2239
promenade2239 replied 6th Oct 2015 - 10 years ago
Thank you Ed! I truly appreciate your nice comments. I just have listened to David Byrne&Talking Heads' 'Once in a Lifetime' and 'Girlfriend is Better' (that one with big suit). Interesting. I tried to get the idea of the band's general artistic message so I watched some of interviews with David Byrne as well and now I understand the comparision. Thanks for pointing this! I must say I wasn't going intentionally any specific direction like that though and there wasn't actually any 'scenario' of how music should sound at the fist place - I simply wrote this track directly on daw juggling Spivkurls vocals, drums and bassline. There are 2 other songs we are still working on, maybe I will post one soon.
Thank you again for listening!
Best to you, Alex
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 22nd Sep 2015 03:38 - 10 years ago

on Icarus by bbedford48
You can play this kind of music on my radio all day Bob...funny, the way you developed this one is the way I end up starting a lot of my own efforts..sit around playing chord progs on the acoustic...coming up with chord variations..trying do do something I haven`t done before with lots of changes & then seeing if my head finds the melody ( I have better luck when I put the original away for a while HaHa)...this one comes out a treat my friend..I`m likely biased as I played rhythm guitar for quite a few years in band days & later developed the habit of composing around progressions I liked....keep on doing it...I`ll keep tuning in...this is the real stuff....definite fav...Ed
bbedford48
bbedford48 replied 22nd Sep 2015 - 10 years ago
Hi Ed,
Great to hear from you. I'm always a bit in awe of your mighty guitar playing, but I can hit the right notes often ( although not always in the right order :) ). Many thanks for your kind words. I'm trying to build my latest thing from a bass line. see how that works out !
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 17th Sep 2015 16:31 - 10 years ago

on Music On - Feat Hilomowo-Tanaka-Samukange-KASSPROD by 8Kass8
Really nice clean mix..like the way you mixed the vocals too...good job 8Kass8......Ed
8Kass8
8Kass8 replied 18th Sep 2015 - 10 years ago
thanks Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 17th Sep 2015 03:57 - 10 years ago

on Shes Nachos by vigwig
Hey Vic...unfortunately no vocals coming from this old guy...I would smoke a ton of cigars & drink a ##### load of whiskey if I thought it would help me sing like one of those ol blues guys...but I would just end up in the morgue....Best country folk vocalist I know of on the site goes by the handle ImproveWithError...did a collab with him a year or 2 ago...but doing your own thing sounds fine to me...Ed
vigwig
vigwig replied 20th Sep 2015 - 10 years ago
It is our loss not hearing you vocalize. You should try it at home and find your comfort zone. Record yourself and listen to the replay. You can just throw awauy the bad stuff and try again. Vic
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 17th Sep 2015 03:27 - 10 years ago

on Thug Beat by Gnasty
not sure about adding an ambient noise Gnasty...but the whole track is in the same key (C) so it might be worth taking a shot at an additional sound..or pad ...or even a bit of quiet synth sweep in a section or 2 ...something that evolves through a few complimentary keys or adds a bit of variety...could maybe kick it up a notch.....keep on doing your thing...Ed
Gnasty
Gnasty replied 17th Sep 2015 - 10 years ago
Thanks for the suggestions man! Ill experiment with a few things and see what works better. The quiet synth sounds is a good suggestions
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 16th Sep 2015 20:08 - 10 years ago

on Thug Beat by Gnasty
good job with the panning on the hats..like that real subby bass hitting on the lows...I think the kind of minimal backing music leaves a lot of room for anybody who might add the vocal..has a little R&B kind of vibe that I like...keep on Gnasty.....Ed
Gnasty
Gnasty replied 17th Sep 2015 - 10 years ago
Its definitely minimal, I'm not sure whether I like it or not. Do you think I should add a pad or ambient noise or keep it as is?
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 15th Sep 2015 22:58 - 10 years ago

on undergroundsound dance by joecramer
You are a creative guy Joe...always something a bit different and always interesting to hear what you come up with...nice groove to this one as it moves right along...your voice goes well with the music (reminds me just a little of Da Da Da by Trio)but you have a better beat happening...it is a little dark but I think that comes mainly from the choice of sounds and some of the effects, plus the perpetual groove of the drums...well done to you...keep on....Ed
joecramer
joecramer replied 16th Sep 2015 - 10 years ago
What a gentle comment Ed :)

In a way the most things i make sounds a bit dark.
This one is realy very repetive and so it is in fact close to this Da DA DA one from Trio. Cool to know that i got a better beat :)
I never tryed to do something "normal" or maybe i tryed but never end with something close to normal. So you can be sure i will keep on doing music in that way.

Thanks for the friendly words. Realy nice to hear things like that from a real musican like you.

stay tuned joe
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 15th Sep 2015 22:43 - 10 years ago

on White Lights by NitramBeatS
you can sign me up for this kind of hip hop NitramBeatS...(the more usual hip hop tracks aren`t on my frequent listening menu)...you take it to another level...really like the rich textured pads and the smooth R&B type flow you have going on here...great job...keep raising the bar....Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 15th Sep 2015 21:48 - 10 years ago

on bicycles in love by DanGoldstein
Its experimenters like you that take musical ideas to new places Dan..Zappa did music that wasn`t always preferred listening for many of us...but it sure was interesting and a source of creative ideas....not sure about how those bicycles are going to get along (but since more than a few humans find that difficult too they just as well give it a shot HaHa)...Always a pleasure to stop by your place and hear what you have been up to....well done....keep on...Ed
DanGoldstein
DanGoldstein replied 15th Sep 2015 - 10 years ago
Hey, Ed. I was always falling asleep in harmony class or otherwise distracted so I have had no choice but to come up with my own musical language. It's fun trying to create connections between the visual and the sonic. It is my muse. Glad you had a chance to hear. hopefully this one has some more to come. Best regards - Dan
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 15th Sep 2015 04:09 - 10 years ago

on Almost and Never by Cestevens1783
I think danke`s comments are right on...good use of the loops..you integrate them really nicely Cestenens...really nice little uplifting kind of mix...and I wish we hade more of those...well done to you.....now do the vocal...Ed
Cestevens1783
Cestevens1783 replied 25th Nov 2015 - 10 years ago
Thank you very much :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 8th Sep 2015 03:35 - 10 years ago

on Shes Nachos by vigwig
Good for you vigwig...I have never been brave enough to try doing a vocal myself (for which the listening public should be grateful)...some nice traditional elements in there (guitars)...has a wee touch of that old & a bit of the new...keep doing it man...we could use a bit more country around here....its an honest genre thats great for those story songs...Ed
vigwig
vigwig replied 8th Sep 2015 - 10 years ago
Thanks for the listen and kind words. Do you have a breathy, raspy voice or can you massage it into one? With a moniker like Tumbleweed, I'd listen. Maybe no Crystal Gayle but at least a Don Williams or Tom T Hall. I got a stylized country-ishsong "My Baby's Got No Juice" which is pretty good. Not much on lyrics but loaded with signature country elements.
Vic
Comments 451 - 475 of 1,619