Tumbleweed

Tumbleweed

Regina, Canada
Joined : 26th Nov 2010 - 15 years ago
Last Online : 28th Jun 2026 - 1 week ago
Tumbleweed comments on tracks

Tumbleweed has posted 1619 comments on other peoples tracks.

Comments 201 - 225 of 1,619
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 15th Feb 2017 02:18 - 9 years ago

on lost love -the lonely road- by mindhiest
Superb bit of musical art mindhiest....great work on the orchestral mix...it is one of those pieces of music that just draws the listener in and speaks to the inner person that we all are....paints beautiful pictures for the mind and that is not an easy accomplishment...a big well done to you...I enjoyed the listen.....Ed
mindhiest
mindhiest replied 17th Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
thank you. I don't know how much of it is me or the song creating itself. mabe 40/60.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 15th Feb 2017 02:11 - 9 years ago

on the galaxy by ElenaSatine
It sounds fantastic Elena....very nice clean sounding mix with all instruments clear and well balanced....I notice your thoughtful work in the composition and arrangement.....This is your best yet,...and most important it is very pleasant listening....a big Well Done to you....excellent...fav for me......Ed
ElenaSatine
ElenaSatine replied 15th Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
hey Ed
thank you much much for the kind words .
you know that your idea means alot to me .
agree with you about it , it's one of my best
:)
thank you very much again .

Elena
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 8th Feb 2017 03:39 - 9 years ago

on Back 2 tha Roots by kingmadi
Hell yeah...its got something that brings back the great sound of the original R&B and funk masters that I loved...Top class man...this one would not only fit on todays radio it would grab the attention of older souls like myself who get a bit nostalgic for the great artists that brought this kind of sound to us years ago....Don`t change a damn thing...its great...standing ovation from an old guitar dude up North of you....big Well Done.really enjoyed this one...better hit the DL button, I know the good wife would dig it too.......Ed
kingmadi
kingmadi replied 16th Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
Thank you so much! :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 6th Feb 2017 21:30 - 9 years ago

on LONE RIDER by CitizenMofo
Now you`re cooking...the vocal is great but now with the acoustic guitar you and Sunny have kicked it waaaay up there...The real stuff has always appealed most to me and I particularly like the acoustic accompaniment (even though I get lazy & just pick up the old electric a lot more often).....This is top notch guys...keep on.....Ed
CitizenMofo
CitizenMofo replied 6th Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
Thanks, Ed. Sunny's the same way - resists the acoustic a bit, cuz she has to go into the booth and do it to a microphone, as opposed to hanging out with me and the recording engineer on the cushy couch and chairs. She also doesn't do runs and resists doing background vocals but will give in on the latter if I argue for a bit and then say, "Ok, never mind." Then she says, "Ok, I'll do it." In the end, we get it done.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 6th Feb 2017 03:42 - 9 years ago

on MY OWN TWO FEET by CitizenMofo
You can play on my radio any day man........
CitizenMofo
CitizenMofo replied 6th Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
That would be nice...
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 6th Feb 2017 03:40 - 9 years ago

on Dreaming ft Oceanically by Burtsbluesboxes
you made my day man...great little song/video...just luv the real stuff....Ed
Burtsbluesboxes
Burtsbluesboxes replied 6th Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
I love the sound of those guitars!!! Any wonder I've become addicted to building/playing them?! :D I know I have that free album from cigar box nation saved on my music player, can't seem to find the post on there, but I'll upload it to mediafire and share it with you. You tube is loaded with videos of people playing cbgs. Justin Johnson is one amazing player I bet you'd love. Shane Speal is considered the king of them, Samantha Fish (incredibly soulful!) the queen. This tune by Red dog Guitars I love! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wz5wMGovkuQ Nothing like the real raw blues played on handmade instruments. :D Check out the site in the description, 3 string dot com for some history and info, fascinating really. I made a 3 string cookie tin guitar for the elementary school I work at now, just need to string it and some minor tweaks to set it up. Hoping to deliver it to the music teacher this week. :p How about Billy Gibbons of ZZ top on one https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rHzeNW_nJVY Enjoy :D

p.s. If you do build one they're more addicting than crack!!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 5th Feb 2017 22:25 - 9 years ago

on Dreaming ft Oceanically by Burtsbluesboxes
I see you already have the Zep comparisons PK...both vocals are well done...fit nice...Ocean has great vocal character for this kind of mix (and a lot of others too I guess)....This just kind of floats you along for a great ride...I like the guitars of course...Really superb job my friend...big well done to both of you..I`ll be hitting the fav button when it hits the last note....Ed
Burtsbluesboxes
Burtsbluesboxes replied 6th Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
Oh yes the great Zeppelin :p I wasn't even thinking of them when recording this. I LOVE Ocean's voice!! The voice of an angel, just like Joan Baez. I know she's on a break pursuing other artistic excursions. I'm making a video for this, floating along like in a dream, great description. Thanks Ed :D You mean the last snore? hahaha Here's some more CBG Albums (not me) for you to enjoy https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FDRQtBVMmI8 I'm looking for another that's a free download from Cigar box nation(dot)com. My username is the same on there but need to get more current pics up. I gave a way alot of the guitars I've made, kept my favs. I'm getting there, just cleaned up my page here now to get some albums together.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 5th Feb 2017 22:18 - 9 years ago

on Modnex - Over the hills - Dark Limbo by Modnex
Nice slow-building track that kind of floats you along with it like a quiet river...really nice job on this one Modex...enjoyed the listen....Ed
Modnex
Modnex replied 16th Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
Thanks Tumbleweed! I'm happy you enjoyed this one. Sorry for the late reply.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 4th Feb 2017 03:50 - 9 years ago

on WeinerBob-When We Were Young Prod by SANNIBRUH by weinerbob
Neat track weinerbob...music that leaves you with a smile has gotta be good...good job on the vocal & the production is really nice & clean....well done...Ed
weinerbob
weinerbob replied 24th Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
Thank you :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 4th Feb 2017 03:43 - 9 years ago

on Memories are Melodies VOCAL COLLAB by Squennix
always good to listen to some upbeat mixes like this...enjoyed the listen but found the heavy brick wall limiting a bit distracting.....Ed
Squennix
Squennix replied 4th Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
Thanks for the criticism ;) Yes, I know. but as written in the description, It is not mastered yet. At least it's just a raw hardely-mastered version of it just to show what the atmosphere of it is about, and at least it's a trial to get in contact with somebody singing on it. Sadly my friends aren't songwriting.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 4th Feb 2017 03:38 - 9 years ago

on THE THING I FEAR by CitizenMofo
CitizenMofo...man..you are really kicking it through the goal posts with these tracks you are doing with Sunny...I`m usng my old Sony MDV600 cans tonight to listen (they push the highs a bit much but no hell on the lows) but the mix sounds really good in all frequencies these old ears can hear.....agree with Steve..you are going to have a super album..If I had been hearing a couple of your tunes on the radio I would have been looking for who it was done them...For somebody who claims to play nothing you sure have an ear for the composition...my old habits would likely have tried to throw in a little key variation or 2 in this one but at the same time I was enjoying it all the way...Sunny rocks and you are cooking up some good recipes with her....Ed
CitizenMofo
CitizenMofo replied 4th Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
Thanks, Ed. Always, massive thanks. As for the key variations, so the other day at the studio with Sunny I'm like, "OK, there's this guy, Tumbleweed, Ed, on looperman, who's talking about key changes. How do you do that?" And so we talked about it and decided to look for places where we can do some key/chord changes. So - I'm learning, and someday soon you'll hear some changes.

Well, it's true, I can't play an instrument and I sing like a frog. (Nonetheless, I made an album called WWIII in 2015 where I sang all 17 songs - that was a big, dumb mistake, and I killed the album in shame as soon as I finished it.)) I've made music in my head since I was 2 but instead became a writer because words were my other thing. Young marriage, kids, raised 'em to adults, 40 years go by, and then a few years ago I started writing songs to capture the music in my head and began climbing the ladder to BETTER. Hundreds of songs later I'm finally getting somewhere, and Sunny is the magic ingredient that brings it all together. This is most fun I've had in a long, long time. It's just pure joy.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 3rd Feb 2017 22:05 - 9 years ago

on Agonist Moon and Faultline by Spivkurl
Spent several years with various format tape machines Spiv so I have some appreciation for their audio character...Maybe I repeat myself but I have much respect for the way you create..you accomplish things that not many do or could with your dedication to those synths and knowledge that few would posses .Those that describe what you do as creative and unique are on the money as far as I am concerned..hats off to you...keep on..Ed
Spivkurl
Spivkurl replied 12th Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
Hey Ed, thank you as always for the kind hearted comments, and for going out of your way to listen to my stuff. I feel this drive, many times, to convince people to see even a little bit "my way." Usually it feels like pulling teeth... Hopefully I can learn to give that up eventually, except in the music itself. I've spent several weeks designing a new and unusual modular rig, and it will probably be several more before it's finished. Still it is good compared to the decade or so spent on my last one. Thanks again my friend!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 3rd Feb 2017 02:23 - 9 years ago

on Groovy for today by PDMuzak
Just posted Jamaican Funeral here Pat..
https://www.looperman.com/tracks/detail/183084
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 3rd Feb 2017 02:12 - 9 years ago

on Groovy for today by PDMuzak
I think jamid nailed it Pat...brilliant...quite complex and as always I love the way that musical mind of your composes...much enjoyed my friend..I will post Jamaican Funeral shortly...not much time around the Loop lately, but you know where I`m at if you come up with any play-along tunes....
Hope all is well....Cheers...Ed
PDMuzak
PDMuzak replied 3rd Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
Hello my dear friend Ed.. I spent the last 2 weeks recovering my music computer that locked up.. Got it reloaded (fun) and it's ready to go again. I loved your mix of Jamaican Funeral that you mixed, but I lost in during my computer failure. Could you email to me when you get a chance? I may have something for in the future.. Pat
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 3rd Feb 2017 02:08 - 9 years ago

on 100 Years by Sestho
Very nice Sestho...I like this one...the 2 chords repeated for quite a long time but that change at 2:15 was very effective in creating variation...You have room for a more prominent lead instrument if you like but this is good relaxing listening as it now is...I enjoyed it....well done...Ed
Sestho
Sestho replied 3rd Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
you're right, I have to listen to the song several times before uploading, anyway no matter all fine. Indeed, just last night I was thinking the same thing, I mean to cut guitar again a little more. OK then thanks a lot! As for the other instruments let see what I can. appreciate!
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 1st Feb 2017 01:59 - 9 years ago

on The Waves Between Ship And Shore by Evisma
Wow....you got that big arena rock thing...but you have laid some really fine melodic rock in there...This is rock composed with a lot of thought and delivered with a big pile of talent...fabulous track my friend...perhaps your best..sounds.tone totally on the money and the production is top class..so whats left to say...the whole thing is just an excellent piece of rock music that as far as I am concerned would blow away a lot of the so-called pros...you are a pro......
I haven`t mic`d an amp for years Evan...just through my preamp or processor into the mixer...Standing ovation.....Ed
Evisma
Evisma replied 1st Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
Greetings, Ed.

I appreciate the kind words. I spent about a month with it in various forms and with a lot of problems. I'm trying to remove the crutch of effects I've always leaned on and focusing on fundamentals. Everything I don't like about my playing is in the hands. No other factors matter. Gotta keep a guitar in my hands if I want to get better. I'm not a fast player, or really very technical, but I like the feeling of what I write. Executing it is usually my downfall.

I appreciate you stopping by. I hope all is well with you.

Take care.

Evan
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 1st Feb 2017 01:52 - 9 years ago

on Working On It by CitizenMofo
If you and Sunny play a bar gig in my town I`m coming by to sit in on the evening & drink a few brews...come to think of it I feel like a couple of brews right now (its your fault CM....haha)...super track guys...consistently good is hard to accomplish but I think you`re on your way...get that album laid down...Ed
CitizenMofo
CitizenMofo replied 2nd Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
Thanks, Ed. Ditto if you're ever in LA. Swing by and I'll watch you and Sunny jam. We just did guitar on two more songs last night - two more to go and the album's done (one of 'em). Just posted another one called THE THING I FEAR...
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 31st Jan 2017 02:41 - 9 years ago

on Los Visitantes by DanGoldstein
You gotta be about the most..to hell with convention...creative guy on the loop Dan..I`m glad you are not paying much attention to genres..they are totally unhelpful in the creative process unless you are trying to conform to something thats been done before.....I like the freedom of the cinematic genre...good excuse to play to whatever picture is in the mind...very creative..abstract...quite unusual....well done, much respect to you....Ed
DanGoldstein
DanGoldstein replied 2nd Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
Hey Ed. Well I always joke that I was sleeping during theory class so had to invent my own system when I started writing. But yea - I don't try to tie in with genre for most part. Having said that, I am thinking about a few steps back for next track into something more conventional with more emphasis on sweet sounds, blends, and listener's experience. Thanks very much for awesome comment. Regards - Dan
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 31st Jan 2017 02:33 - 9 years ago

on Epic Showtime by beerling1970
fast (with the percussion bits)....upbeat...and yet mellow (the slower main beat) at the same time...it all comes together nicely Steve..a nice mix of genres but genres don`t matter a damn anyway when it comes to letting the creativity flow.....I like the production (after just listening to a couple of over-limited mixes with a ton of highs that hurt the ears this is sounding really good)....always good listening here at your place....nicely done...Ed
beerling1970
beerling1970 replied 2nd Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
Thank you for listening Ed and for the comment :)

Steve
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 31st Jan 2017 02:25 - 9 years ago

on The Beast by CitizenMofo
I don`t think we should even think about genres when we`re trying to create so you can pick any genre you like and I`ll still think its one hell of a fine piece of musical art CitizenMofo..Rock works fine...You`re right...the lady is one big talent..and she takes us for a great musical ride without much in the way of key changes...that takes talent and isn`t often accomplished in loop land..
her guitar and vocal delivery do the trick nicely...fab job by both of you..really enjoyed the listen.big fav & a standing ovation from this old guitar guy..more please...Ed
CitizenMofo
CitizenMofo replied 31st Jan 2017 - 9 years ago
Thanks, Ed. Means a lot coming from you. For an old guitar guy, you sure put out some juicy sounds. I just posted another one called "Working On It", which started with one of your loops as the driving rhythm engine that called forth the song. Please check it out. I'll be posting a lot over the coming weeks. Been busy.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 30th Jan 2017 22:20 - 9 years ago

on Upwelling Ice by Burtsbluesboxes
I think Tekreck described it aptly...awesome....so I just stopped by to tell you that your pages is a mess...I can`t even keep track of what year today is ...haha....man you really nailed the whole vibe in this one (but you have been doing that consistently of late)....absolutely top notch & a big fav....Have you thought about doing an album of your cigar box tunes?...it would def appeal to me....well done mate....cheers...Ed
Burtsbluesboxes
Burtsbluesboxes replied 2nd Feb 2017 - 9 years ago
Yes a very fitting description :p Seems anything I play on that electric 3 string falls into that category ;) My page is an absolute mess!! Any surprise as I'm a cleaner for a living hahahaha. I'm going to delete everything and reupload making it nice and tidy again. I've made and given away a few cds of cigar box guitar music. My co worker played one at work and the guys kept looking at me, this is you? really?? I'm going to set up a band camp account and put up an album for free download as well as on Reverbnation once I figure out how. Joe Cramer put together this one of collabs we've done, not all is cbgs but should hold you over. https://www.reverbnation.com/1096781/album/117064 Always a pleasure Ed, stay tuned for more, new one up today.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 29th Jan 2017 03:30 - 9 years ago

on What it was Like by wikkid
great job bringing these two together wikkid...aside from a couple of the little technical things that have already been mentioned this is one realy good track that has lots of potential...Brado...pump this one up..its damn good listening up my way....well done wikkid....keep on...Ed
wikkid
wikkid replied 29th Jan 2017 - 9 years ago
Thanks for the comment, Ed.
I don't know what else to do to get Brado and Austin to team up to re-make this. Maybe I need to sing them a love song :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 28th Jan 2017 22:31 - 9 years ago

on NEVER STOP DREAMING - Cinematic Soundtrack by Alabafruit
I wouldn`t have guessed you made this one out of loops Albafruit except perhaps for the observation that the key progression gets quite repetitive.That is not necessarily a bad thing in cinematic/soundtrack type of productions as the are intended to provide a theme for a particular scene..you have however, got enough variations in there to keep it interesting listen....really like that flute part...I enjoyed it....a big well done to you and thanks for using that little contribution of mine...that always makes listening fun....cheers....Ed
Alabafruit
Alabafruit replied 28th Jan 2017 - 9 years ago
Thank you for this great Feedback! I hope one day I can do everything alone without any loops and it will be more interesting and just bigger and deeper.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 15th Jan 2017 03:26 - 9 years ago

on Never Forget Your Name by HappyIdiots
nice chord progression & really like the warm backing sounds...its good...and definitely invites a vocal....well done....Ed
HappyIdiots
HappyIdiots replied 15th Jan 2017 - 9 years ago
Thank you so much for listening, I appreciate it! I put it in my favorite key: B minor, which led to a lot of fun experimentation.

I'm looking forward to hearing more of your tracks.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 13th Jan 2017 20:51 - 9 years ago

on Outside by MOONLYTE
I`ve been away slacking for a long time so just catching up with this one now....I did several music mixes for a spoken word artist a few years ago so have some appreciation for the art and the talents it takes to do it well....The backing music caught my attention right from note one..lovin it...nice fat piano...and the cello is great for adding emotional depth to most any kind of music..thoughtful lyrics even if they are dark (thats part of our journey too)....This is honestly one of the very best spoken word performances I have heard Eyedye (and I have heard many)..change nothing.....bravo...standing ovation from an old guy up North.....Ed
MOONLYTE
MOONLYTE replied 14th Jan 2017 - 9 years ago
Ed, another talent I'm honored to receive feedback from. You haven't slacked much, only been up for a couple weeks so you're good haha. Dark is kinda my thing. To be put among your top performers is honestly awesome. To the old guy up North, I thank you for the time :)
Comments 201 - 225 of 1,619