ValveDriver

ValveDriver

Not every song requires vocals
Portland, United States
Joined : 25th Sep 2012 - 13 years ago
Last Online : 1st Jan 2026 - 1 day ago
ValveDriver comments on tracks

ValveDriver has posted 520 comments on other peoples tracks.

Comments 201 - 225 of 520
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 15th Jun 2022 17:15 - 3 years ago

on This Game by crucethus
This right here is what Rammstein would have been if they came out in the early stages of Industrial back in the late 70s- early 80s. Imagine a Rammstein without Til Lindemann and this is what it would be.

I think the only thing I would have done differently would have been to add a sub bass line as a bottom end platform. It's a good and interesting mix,(both in concept and levels, etc.) and I think that sub would be Lebowski's rug. Ya know?

I hope it doesn't get as hot up there in the GWN as it is here in the US Midwest. Today is the coolest day of the week with something like 80f. By the end of the week it's supposed to be up to 100f. And the in-laws want to do a Father's Day BBQ. I think they forget I'm from the Northwest where it averages 75 in the summers. I'm a panzy when it comes that heat, man! But, good food should make it easier, right?

Anyhow, Take care, Mister C.
Aaron.
crucethus
crucethus replied 24th Jun 2022 - 3 years ago
Thanks, mate, sorry for the late reply, I'm in the process of starting a new career. Ironically I have been listening to quite a bit of the new Rammstein lately. Also to your sub-bass comment, there actually is a sub-bass line but I just need to bring it up in the mix. Today is Ste Jean-Baptiste day in Quebec with a sunny but warmer day 28c(82f). I plan on BBQing a nice steak with mushroom caps and herbed potatoes. We are pairing it with a 2020 Snoop Dogs, 19 crimes cali red wine, which I have never tried.
Take Care
Steven
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 14th Jun 2022 15:56 - 3 years ago

on jesus has a mighty sword by Zootman
This is like Stereo MCs got ahold of a Tom Waits tune, turned it into a funkcicle and had Ray Manzarek lick it.

Cool, man. I dig it.

Take care.
V.
Zootman
Zootman replied 15th Jun 2022 - 3 years ago
Great comment! I've been a big Tom waits fan for decades, and who hasn't got into the doors at some point in their lives?! Thanks for listening.
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 16th Jan 2022 01:10 - 3 years ago

on KlOWN by Spivkurl
Wow! Spivkurl. It's been a long time, man. I was wondering how you were doing. I was generally concerned. It's good to see you're presence again. Hopefully you're doing better these days?

To me this track sounds like the relentless pounding of coffee and any other insomnia inducing stimulant for the sake of avoiding the silent moments before sleep, when the mind tends to do it's dirtiest deeds. There's a certain air of urgency and looking over ones shoulder at all times.

The aggression appeals to me. It's almost hypnotic.

Truly, Pat, It's good to see you again.

Take care, friend.
Aaron.
Spivkurl
Spivkurl replied 24th Jan 2022 - 3 years ago
Aaron, thank you for the kind words! It's good to be back interacting on the Loop.

I think you hit the nail on the head while investigating this song. Those dirtiest deeds while avoiding sleep definitely come through. And I was looking over my shoulder at all times... you nailed it.

Very appreciative of your kind words!
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 29th Sep 2021 19:59 - 4 years ago

on Mama when i grow up i will be like Charlie Sheen by BananaLu
If you really want to get a taste of Mike Doughty's vocal abilities, check out the band Soul Coughing. That's where he really came to be known. They are a band from the 90s. Very unusual style. Even for the 90s. They come across as kind of a funky-groovy type thing, but there's a certain darkness that lurks under the surface. I love that. The darker the better if you ask me.
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 28th Sep 2021 23:05 - 4 years ago

on Untitles by Cessangelmusicbaby
Honestly, I really like it. Overall, I mean. It's got a great 90's sound to it. Which, I'm partial to.

As far as the technical side goes, it does need some work.
The first thing I noticed was the vocals are off beat. If that's you singing, try rerecording them with a little more attention to that. I understand that you're trying to convey raw emotion, but with out proper timing, it sounds...off.
ZkyNate suggestion compression on the vocals. I agree. If you aren't sure how to do that, there are a lot of good videos that explain in depth not only how to do it, but why to do it. I suggest looking into those.
He also mentioned the background vocals interfering with the main vocals. I think if you were to tighten the harmonies it would help as well.
The music itself. Personally, I really like it. I'd love to hear you put some more time into this and make it a good full track. This is something I would listen to in my regular rotation.

That's just my two cents. Take it for what it's worth.
Take care.
V.
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 28th Sep 2021 21:58 - 4 years ago

on Mama when i grow up i will be like Charlie Sheen by BananaLu
BLu, how ya doin, man?

Another good one from you. The mixing does need a little work, but it's all pretty easy fixes. Mainly just bring the sub-bass down a little in the mix. It's loud enough that it kind of makes everything a little muddy. Other than that, it's really not bad.

Your voice in this one is very reminiscent of Mike Doughty. Especially at the 2:00 mark to the end. That's pretty impressive.

You definitely have a stand out-style here at Looperman. Keep it up, man.

Take care.
V.
BananaLu
BananaLu replied 29th Sep 2021 - 4 years ago
Hey V, I´m a lot better now :)

i have huge difficulties with mixing, never owned monitor boxes. I do everything with headphones. I´m now saving up for really good ones. I hope with time and better equip i get better results. I love that the community will help me with next project. This is all just demo to show people that i can do some stuff . I love the fact that you name dropping artist to compare my voice. i had to google Mike Doughty :) I explore more and more music with your help. Thaks V
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 9th Sep 2021 20:04 - 4 years ago

on Blood Moon by Zootman
The D-n-B part is good. I like that. It's got a good classic beat, It's not overloaded with growly synths, (which is something I'm guilty of doing.)

The ambient beginning. I really dug that. The bass line in it is groovy as fuck. It's got a real Roger Waters appeal circa Saucer Full Of Secrets. I love the evolving synths, and the heavily reverbed background SFX. Honestly, I think you should go back and make a full track out just that.

Alternatively, it would be cool if you strung some of the Ambient half through the D-n-B half to kind of tie them together a little more. Maybe bring the evolving synths into it, or work in that bass line.

But, that's just my own opinion. Take it for what it's worth.

Overall man, great track.

Take care.
V.
Zootman
Zootman replied 9th Sep 2021 - 4 years ago
Hi Valvedriver, thanks for those insightful comments, there's some good ideas there. I wish I had more time to indulge this passion. By the way, the mysterious womens voice in the ambient section is someone praying in tongues (backwards). Have you ever read Snow Crash by Neal Stephenson? Pretty cool book and has a theme running through it of glossolalia so that was the inspiration. And thanks for listening to a bunch of other tracks, much appreciated. I checked out your website too, pretty cool man.
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 5th Sep 2021 17:39 - 4 years ago

on Disappointing Crucethus by Jynxz
Ha! Sorry. We started in 2012. Not twelve years ago.
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 5th Sep 2021 16:50 - 4 years ago

on Disappointing Crucethus by Jynxz
I like it. It's got a good funky-ass groove to it. The guitar is pretty cool, but the bass line takes it for me. Between the music and the description in the Lyrics section, I'm willing to go out on a limb here and say that you're a fan of the P-funk. But, really, how could anyone NOT be, right?

In regards to Mr. Crucethus, I think he and I started here at the Loop just weeks apart, 12 years ago. It's been a hell of a journey watching him grow and evolve as an artist. I've always been able to count on him for some interesting-as-fuck insights, comments, and criticisms. His complete lack of regard for in-the-box rules of music is inspiring at the very least.
There are very few artists here that participate like we all did back in the hey-day, but you new batch of regulars...I like you guys. You keep the feeling of community alive. The place has a pulse again. Good on ya for that!

Take care, man.
V.
Jynxz
Jynxz replied 6th Sep 2021 - 4 years ago
Hello V.,

I don't know if you realize how intimidating it is when
you first get on LM and hear guys like you Cru and many of the other great sounding music producers that were here on LM when I first came on board in 2019. I have received nothing less than a warm welcome and tons of helpful advice from the LM community. I plan to pay it forward as best I can with whoever I come in contact with
new or old.

Thank you for your listen and encouragement
it goes further than you think.

PEACE...
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 5th Sep 2021 14:59 - 4 years ago

on St James Infirmary ft Jack Teagarden by Zootman
This is a pretty cool mixup.

I was especially digging 2:50 to 3:50. In my opinion, that whole section could have been doubled in length. It's got such a nice ethereal groove to it, that it was over before it started. So to speak. But, then again, I'm a fan of really long instrumentals. That's why I listen to Doom Metal. HA!

Anyhow. I really dig the genre mixing. You made it sound good.

Keep up the good work, and take care.
V.
Zootman
Zootman replied 5th Sep 2021 - 4 years ago
Hi there, thanks a lot. Yep there's something soothing about a sine wave!
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 4th Sep 2021 12:55 - 4 years ago

on Restore the power by Djsquezze
Yeah, it's got some of that old hardcore style. The vocal samples need a few effects on them, though. With them being so dry, they don't really seem to fit in the mix. They're chopped and placed well, just a little to bold and dry.

other than that, good track over all.

Take care.
V.
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 3rd Sep 2021 23:05 - 4 years ago

on Where the fck is the Moonman by BananaLu
Yeah. I think I really dig your work, man. Of the three tracks that I've heard from you, I think the style on this one really compliments your voice the most. It's got a bit of a Rev. Horton Heat/The Clash/Tom Waits thing happening.

I look forward to hearing more from you.

Take care.
V.
BananaLu
BananaLu replied 6th Sep 2021 - 4 years ago
Thank you very much ValveDriver that you take the time in listen to my older tracks. I´m a huge fan of your works too. I can feel your energy in your tracks, specially your last.
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 3rd Sep 2021 22:56 - 4 years ago

on This has nothing to do with Nancy Sinatra by BananaLu
Ok. So, at first, I wasn't sure about it. But after a couple seconds, I was totally on board.

First, let me say it's good exactly how it is. But in my head, while listening to it, I kept wanting to hear the vocals as if they were being sung through a Megaphone. As in, the low and high frequencies dropped, and a layer of distortion over them.

Like I said, though, it's perfectly fine the way it is. Maybe you can take this as an idea for a different track. Who knows?

Good job, man.
Take care.
V.
BananaLu
BananaLu replied 4th Sep 2021 - 4 years ago
thank you very much. I really like your comment and the community. I like your Idea for the Voice im totally down with it i wrote soemthing on your track Red On White. i would love to work with you. I need fresh smoothie ideas like yours. honest banana, love from germany
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 28th Aug 2021 15:59 - 4 years ago

on March Of The Machines by Orlando51
Oh, Leon...what have you done?

This comment is probably going to take at a minimum, 4 listen-throughs.

I've listened to many of your songs. All of which I absolutely love. They all have so much depth and feeling. They always capture the beauty of life. Even in the more melancholic ones. But this one, my friend, in this one you go to a place that I haven't heard from you, but I always knew was there. However, you do it with absolute authority.

The piano in the opening is by far the most important moment of this song. They tell the entire story, in just those 7 chords. Everything before, and after that is just an explanation.

This is a very introspective piece, but it's also a perfect social commentary on the world today. Especially from the perspective of those of us who were here before the massive influx of technology. The beginning being a distorted memory of a peaceful, natural world. Those pivotal piano chords being the moment when you realize that all of that is gone. Overshadowed by what's to come. It could be health, age, or what I'm guessing it to be, the technological machine that has brought a darkness over us all.
But you know, even in the midst of the darkness, and the aggression of the lower guitars, and the chugs, (which I absolutely love!) There's still a level of determination and refusal to be consumed.

Dystopian.

That's how I would describe this track. I know you said that you used "Industrial" more out of necessity than reality, but I would certainly go with Dystopian.

Up until the drums come in, it's like standing in one point just taking in the surroundings. Looking at everything and how it's become a charred shadow of it's former self. Whether that's literal, or symbolic. But when the drums start, it brings a new level of determination and an acceptance of the fact that you need to just carry on regardless. The clean guitars, and the piano that's sprinkled in throughout this part accompanied by the guitars harmonics deliver a feeling of peacefulness that says you will still find the beauty even in an ugly world, and you will not be broken.

Leon, this one is by far my favorite of yours, and not just because it's a darker theme. I mean, that helps, but this one seems to tell a much more poignant story. It has a level of vulnerability that your other work doesn't have. I would even go as far to bet that you felt you were in a moment of weakness when you wrote this one. But let me assure you, this is your strongest piece yet, and it reflects your own personal strength and drive.
As an artist and a person, I have tremendous respect for you, so hopefully, I didn't cross any lines in my assumptions on a personal level.

Oh, it was a grand total of 8 listen-throughs.
Leon, as always, take care my friend.
Aaron.
Orlando51
Orlando51 replied 1st Sep 2021 - 4 years ago
Wow wow wow Aaron...I really don't remember if I ever received such a comprehensive feedback !I had kind of a sixth sense that you might be interested in checking this one, so I shared the link, but frankly I didn't expect so overwhelmingly positive and enthusiastic response.This really means alot to me so I can only say big thank you my friend for this generous review !:)

With maximum appreciation_____Leon
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 27th Aug 2021 23:25 - 4 years ago

on passing time on sunday by pseudoble
Hello.

I really enjoyed this. It was very calming and peaceful. Even though there was a lot going on. I think it was Cru that mentioned the sax, I may be wrong. Either way, I agree. It is a great touch. It really smooths out the entire track. Just curious though, with it being so mellow and chill, how many times did you fall asleep in the middle of playbacks during it's production? (something that happens to me ALL the time! lol).
Overall, nice piece. Good work on the mix, too. Everything seemed to be right where it should.

Take care.
V.
pseudoble
pseudoble replied 28th Aug 2021 - 4 years ago
Ha - thank V - it depends how late I sit up if I fall asleep or not - worked on this during the day and kept interested by layering the sound and finding the right settings for some of the effects on the multiple tracks of guitar - but yeah it sure aint dance or party music! Thanks for listening and the warm feedback
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 27th Aug 2021 22:42 - 4 years ago

on The Birdlands Edge by Orlando51
Leon! Hello my friend! Damn. I knew I dropped by The Loop today for a reason. It's been quite awhile. I hope all is well with you and yours.

The intro in this has no specific realm. Meaning, it leaves it open to go in any direction. My imagination was already starting to go one way, and then you came in from a completely different direction with the beautiful guitar arpeggios, accompanied by the spacious piano.
When the strings come in they sound as if they're Celtic strings that have been kissed by the middle east.
A nice simple drum beat. But that's what it needs to be. Any more and they would overstep their boundaries. The other percussive elements fill in the spaces perfectly.
Leon, I have always been a fan of your layering and overlapping transitions. You do not disappoint here.

But, then again, you never do.

Beautiful work as always, sir. Once again, I find myself wishing I could tap into the peaceful part of myself and create something that isn't so...aggressive.

Until next time, my friend, as always...Take care.
Aaron.
Orlando51
Orlando51 replied 28th Aug 2021 - 4 years ago
Hey Aaron my friend...so nice to meet you again...it's been awhile. I'm not much around here in recent times for a number of reasons, but I still jump in from time to time.
Thank you so kindly for your positive feedback which as always means alot...but wait...my previous upload could be much closer to your musical preferences...and in case you would like to check it out, here it is: https://www.looperman.com/tracks/detail/227964#1223585

Cheers my friend...stay safe.

Leon
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 25th May 2021 16:42 - 4 years ago

on The Sickness onto Death by ClickbaitCabaret
I completely agree with sticking to your signature style. But I also think you need to allow room for improvement and evolution.

As far as this track goes, I like it. It's got a touch of Depeche Mode, Massive Attack and a little bit of Dead Can Dance. Which, until now, a combination that I never thought would have worked.

Good work. Keep it up.
Take care.
V.
ClickbaitCabaret
ClickbaitCabaret replied 25th May 2021 - 4 years ago
Actually all three of the bands you mention are influences on my work, particularly Massive Attack. That 90's era Bristol scene is my number one influence for sure. Thanks for stopping by & listening. I appreciate it.
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 1st Apr 2021 21:26 - 4 years ago

on Another 80s Wave by BadNode
Ok, I was there. In the 80s when all this was happening live. If you had put this in a mix with other tracks that were actually produced back then, without telling me, I most likely wouldn't have questioned it being there. The reverb on the kicks and snare, the "kick/snare/kick/kick/kick/snare" beat, the brassy synths, the bouncy bassline. It's got it all. I think as far as the mix goes, there may be just a little too much clarity in the top end. I seem to remember it being just a little muddier. But, man...not by much.
I think the "missing element" that every one seems to be searching for, (aside from Robert Smith style vocals)is guitars. I know it's 80s synth style, but considering we were just coming out of the "classic rock" guitar driven decade, they were still a prominent feature across the board. Even in the then infant genre of rap. There needs to be some reverb drenched, low gain guitars in the backing rhythm section.
I wonder if the other artist that Lek can't put his finger on is Gary Numan. It kind of reminds me of him. Maybe just a touch of super early "With Sympathy" era Ministry. Or even some Eurythmics. Damn, there were so many good ones!

Excellent work! Keep it up!

Take care.
V.
BadNode
BadNode replied 10th Apr 2021 - 4 years ago
Valve, thank you for your review and feedback! I think some reverbed LA studio sounding guitar might be a really fun thing to try out on this and I'll definitely be experimenting! In my head I heard a saxophone solo somewhere so that might be something I investigate next too! Such kind words, It really motivates me to keep at it! I love the sounds that came out of the 80's and 90's and they constantly inspire my music. I hadn't heard of Gary Numan I am ashamed to say or the Eurythmics but I thank you for introducing me as now I have some new tunes to listen to and learn from!
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 30th Mar 2021 19:45 - 4 years ago

on Overload by ripzore9191
That's a good question.

By "Variation in the drums" I mean switch up the beat a little bit. Different patterns. Right now you have the same beat going through most of the track. It's a good beat, but with some different ones, it could really enhance the dynamics. Make it a lot more energetic, and less repetitive. An example would be to sync up with the dub-wobbles. Or kick it up to double time. Check out my track "Don't Be Afraid" for more examples. Not that I'm any master, but there are several switch ups in the drums. Some are very subtle, and some are very obvious. Granted, there is a difference between Dubstep and DnB, but the theory remains the same.

Either way, keep up the good work.

Take care.
V.
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 28th Mar 2021 00:54 - 4 years ago

on Overload by ripzore9191
Not bad. I think a little more variation in the drums could push this a little harder. Maybe pair them up with the synths a little more. As it is, it's still good and drives nicely, though.
That's my opinion. Take it for what it's worth.

Take care.
V.
ripzore9191
ripzore9191 replied 28th Mar 2021 - 4 years ago
I love feedback but when you say variation in drums do you mean different drum patterns or do you mean sounds?. Thank you!
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 27th Mar 2021 00:06 - 4 years ago

on Pleasure by mudhoen
Damn, man. This is good. I like the way you have a lot of elements working together, and it still sounds very minimal. I love that.
The mix sounds good. At least in my earbuds, they do. Nothing sounds out of place. It's a nice wide track with crystal clarity. The highs aren't sizzling, and the lows aren't clipping or muddy. Sounds good.
Personally, I would have given the track a little more length by running the full intro again at 2:24, right before the build up. But, replace the siren synth with the flute from the second drop. That's just me, though. I have a habit of running them long, so take it for what it's worth.

Either way. I dig it. Great work.

Take care.
V.
mudhoen
mudhoen replied 27th Mar 2021 - 4 years ago
Thanks a lot for giving you extended view on my track. really helps me get better! For teh arrangement of the track I think you are right to extend the start of the 2nd part a bit. A lot of EDM music nowadays is pushing for a drop. I thought otherwise the track became too repetitive. But hearing your opinion convinced me make it a little longer. Thanks again and take care!
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 24th Mar 2021 22:42 - 4 years ago

on JACK OF CLUBS by NDAPOCKET123
I'm not sure what makes it House or not. But overall, it sounds good to me. Honestly, it has a touch of Beastie Boys circa Paul's Boutique.
The only issue I hear is that Phone ring sounding synth that we first hear at the 0:02 mark. It's a little bit loud in the mix. Just a minor thing really.

Anyhow. Sounds good.
Take care,
V.
NDAPOCKET123
NDAPOCKET123 replied 28th Mar 2021 - 4 years ago
V.THANKS FOR LISTEN AND HONEST CRITIQUE.TRULY GRATEFUL FOR THAT. YEAH YOU RIGHT, THAT PHONE IS LOUD. LOL. PEACE.
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 24th Mar 2021 18:38 - 4 years ago

on WORKING4U by BeatMaker4real
Hey man. How's it goin?

This isn't my genre by any means. I don't know what makes hip-hop what it is. But, that aside, I really liked this for what it is. I'm sure it's meant to have a vocal track, but in my opinion, vocals get in the way. That's for EVERY genre. Except maybe Tuvan throat chant. You know...where it's nothing BUT vocals.
The only thing that seemed to be missing in my ears was a sub bass line to accent the percussion. Other than that, everything sounded great. The mix is nice and clean, everything sits right were it needs to be.
Good work. Keep it up.

Take care.
V.
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 24th Nov 2020 00:49 - 5 years ago

on Mr Burns and His Wife by jive4005
This is a pretty cool tune. I'm diggin' the vocal skills.

It totally sounds like a John Lee Hooker and B.B. King hybrid!

I would say it's more mid 40's Delta blues than it is 20's Jazz, though.

Either way, excellent work. Keep it up!

Take care.
V.
jive4005
jive4005 replied 24th Nov 2020 - 5 years ago
Thanks driver... actually the arrangement was a loop sample of mine... lyrics from way back
ValveDriver
ValveDriver 9th Nov 2020 19:49 - 5 years ago

on THE CHOKE- Gheto Waltz live in Helsinki by thechockehold
This is what would have happened if Vince Guaraldi and Dave Lombardo collaborated.

The contrast between jazzy keys and metal drums was very interesting for sure. But, as someone who's been listening to heavy metal since it's infancy in the early 80's, I'm totally digging the drums. Danke was spot on in recognizing the Lombardo-esque style there.

Kudos to you and your band.

Take care.
V.
Comments 201 - 225 of 520