Tumbleweed

Regina, Canada

Joined : 26th Nov 2010 - 15 years ago

Last Online : 28th Jun 2026 - 1 week ago

Loops Out

Tumbleweed comments on tracks

Tumbleweed has posted 1619 comments on other peoples tracks.

Comments 1301 - 1325 of 1,619

Tumbleweed 9th Oct 2012 20:20 - 13 years ago

on Make the KKonnection by DanielGtrman

well..thats some mighty fine doodling you got going on here Daniel...really like the piano & the subtle bit of acoustic...nice fat subby bas in there too....really well done....much enjoyed....Ed

DanielGtrman replied 12th Oct 2012 - 13 years ago

Thanks Ed for the listen and review. glad u liked my track

Tumbleweed 9th Oct 2012 20:14 - 13 years ago

on Phobia by PlasticPeyote

fantastic chilled groove PlasticPeyote...great piano sound..really nice laid-back listening this afternoon.....Ed

PlasticPeyote replied 10th Oct 2012 - 13 years ago

thank you.I'm glad you like it.

Tumbleweed 6th Oct 2012 22:09 - 13 years ago

on FEEL FREE PLASTIC SURGERY with BRAD SUCKS by PieroPeluche

nice smooth rock thats good for the ol rock soul....great job on the accompaniment PieroPeluche....Ed

PieroPeluche replied 9th Oct 2012 - 13 years ago

Thanks Ed. I'm dusting my guitar.

Tumbleweed 6th Oct 2012 21:59 - 13 years ago

on the returning by thyroid

you do a great job in this genre thyroid....I think I may have a couple of your orchestral loops in my folder....really nice composition onnthis one....Ed

Tumbleweed 6th Oct 2012 21:43 - 13 years ago

on Twilight Horizons by mystirP

that big reverby piano sure does the dreamy part Mr.P and the drums definitely fulfil the jumpy role...quite an unusual mix of sounds but I thinkthe biggest contrast likely comes from the drum mix....different is good...well done.....Ed

mystirP replied 16th Oct 2012 - 13 years ago

Usually my phone will alert me when I get stuff like this. It didn't this time or I didn't hear it. Sorry for the late response. Thank you and I am very glad you liked it. My mom says it's my best one yet. I kinda like to think maybe yeah, but I like Forever Friends the most due to some of the way I used my techniques in the breaks and bridges.

Mr. P

Tumbleweed 6th Oct 2012 00:44 - 13 years ago

on Walk in the Rain by Rockinchair11

Hi Rockinchair11...you are off to a good start...my take on it would be to loose the drum track and/or replace it with something a bit minimal or lighter...the synth & pad parts have a nice kind of Celtic vibe and sound good by themselves...maybe build up towards a kind of light beat & bass type groove that lets the mix go for a walk in the rain...keep on.....Ed

Rockinchair11 replied 6th Oct 2012 - 13 years ago

Thanks I have little or no music ability and the feedback meansa lot Thanks for the listem Cheers Rockinchair

Tumbleweed 4th Oct 2012 22:21 - 13 years ago

on If You Could See What I see by visualword

Now this is different...and in the best of ways..I`m not up on genres myself so you can call it whatever & I`d still like it...imaginative mix /instrumentation going on...thought I might have heard a touch of Latin in there too...well done visualword...enjoyed this one...Ed

visualword replied 21st May 2013 - 13 years ago

Sorry for the unbelievably late reply. I haven't had too many opportunities to get back to looperman.

If you like my material, please check out my page at www.visualword.bandcamp.com, I have 19 albums available for free download.

My passion is to share my music. Money is nice but that's not my goal. Please share with all your friends.

Tumbleweed 4th Oct 2012 19:41 - 13 years ago

on Can You Feel It - 2012 - Remastered by teamrufeless

on another note....forgot to mention...I like your vocal here just fine..nice smooth vocal character fits nicely with the music & on the money...if you think you want something different there you could check with our friend Ratty (Mark Ratcliffe) who has that nice touch of soulful character to his voice...Ed

Tumbleweed 4th Oct 2012 19:39 - 13 years ago

on Can You Feel It - 2012 - Remastered by teamrufeless

Oh man....I love this one Lee...its a tonic man...I was reaching for the download button after the first few lines...I was waiting for a key change or some kind of chorus/hook to kick in but it just kept rolling along real smooooooooooth all the way with enough directions in the mix to keep tl ol ears perked...I just gotta move this one over to my music pc and do a little play-along for the fun of it....thanks for positing this one....I`m still smiling....Ed

teamrufeless replied 5th Oct 2012 - 13 years ago

Oh wow thanks Ed that really means a lot bet it sounds fab with some of your riffs over the top, I will get in touch with Ratty soon, i am completely obsessed with October Moon I have the first verse and chourus already,Thanks again Lee

Tumbleweed 29th Sep 2012 03:56 - 13 years ago

on TANGLED DREAM ft DJShemZee by SERGEJ77

Ah yes...I`m familiar with Shemzee`s music..and like yoyrsel he is one talented guy who does a lot of atyles yet always has his own signature...particularly his vocal stylings....This is just another great example of how collaboration by a couple of talented musicians multiplies the result...great stuff guys...Ed

SERGEJ77 replied 29th Sep 2012 - 13 years ago

Thank you Ed, next time will cal you to join us...
RDS
SERGEJ

Tumbleweed 26th Sep 2012 17:26 - 13 years ago

on Interview with a Stranger by Phyruis

I have been getting a bit of an education on some of the electronica genres around the Loop PBJ.(I still got a long way to go I think)...and one of the things I am really noticing is some the great synth sounds and nice speaker-shaking production....another good one here....Now I know where to come when I ned to further my learning....nicely done....Ed

Tumbleweed 26th Sep 2012 17:21 - 13 years ago

on Foffanna ft RomyHarmony silent moon by Foffanna

this kind of trance could get me listening to the genre a lot more Foffanna...some really rich sounds & a really nice job getting the vocal so clean & clear up front....well done.....Ed

Tumbleweed 25th Sep 2012 00:24 - 13 years ago

on ONE SMALL STEP - BILBOZO by Bilbozo

That is some of the finest, most soulful guitar I have listened to in a long time Bilbozo...tone to the bone...and you sure have all the compositional elements in perfect order...and spot on production...this is a bout as good as it gets in my humble opinion...fantastic.....Ed

Tumbleweed 24th Sep 2012 04:05 - 13 years ago

on Contemplating by Proxy

You have a special talent for this kind of music Proxy, and kudos to you for the different instrumentation....really enjoyed it...well done....Ed

Proxy replied 24th Sep 2012 - 13 years ago

Thank you for your words. I like your music also. I appreciate that you regularly comment on my music.

gr proxy

Tumbleweed 24th Sep 2012 04:02 - 13 years ago

on Sacrifice by Twanna1

great piece of cinematic work Twanna1...you had some talented musicians on board, but it takes big compositional talent to put one like this together...great track...much enjoyed...Ed

Twanna1 replied 24th Sep 2012 - 13 years ago

Thank you so much Ed for your kind review. It is greatly appreciated.

Much love and appreciation back at cha:)

Have a wonderful and blessed week.

Twanna

Tumbleweed 24th Sep 2012 03:51 - 13 years ago

on greenspoon - i think of you by thegreenspoon

your track absorbed a little of the night greenspoon...I just became a bit familiar with dubstep since I have been listening around LM and while it has a beat that my ears are not yet fully accustomed to, it also has some fantastic synth sounds...like the ones you have used here...the track really carries the whole vibe of thoughts in tyhe mind late at night....well done...enjoyed this one....Ed

thegreenspoon replied 27th Sep 2012 - 13 years ago

thank you very munch for your effort. Im really lucky to hear thant somebody is liking my track :)

Tumbleweed 23rd Sep 2012 04:07 - 13 years ago

on on the road by carlosnble

you`ve got some catchy tracks going on over here carlosnble..really like this one too...great sounds and a groove that just pulls you along..I spent a lot of years listening to mixes with a bit more traditional musical structure..so pardon me if I repeat myself (must be getting old) but it would really benefit from a bit more variation (either in key, beat, or accompaniment etc) somewhere along the line..hope you take my comments as constructively intended...its just that I hear more potential...really nicely done...enjoyed the listen...Ed

Tumbleweed 23rd Sep 2012 03:59 - 13 years ago

on new rnb idea by carlosnble

I hope you find the vocalist you want on this one carlosnble...its a dm good sounding piece of music...could benefit from a bit of a break just to vary thingts a bit more...definitely has potential.....keep on...feel free to mail me when you get it done (no favs button here any more)...would like to hear the results...Ed

Tumbleweed 22nd Sep 2012 21:40 - 13 years ago

on Sunset Silhouette by ChrisNeal

nothing seems to conjure up emotions and mind pictures quite like cinematic music..and it gives you license yo go most anywhere you want musically...great job on this one Chris...much enjoyed.....Ed

ChrisNeal replied 24th Sep 2012 - 13 years ago

Thanks for the listen Ed! :)

Tumbleweed 22nd Sep 2012 21:31 - 13 years ago

on Remember by Proxy

the cello is just such an emotional sounding instrument..and paired with the piano and played with the skill evidenced here it creats a fabulous bit of musical art....superb Proxy...great track....Ed

Proxy replied 23rd Sep 2012 - 13 years ago

Thank you for your comment, although I didn't play it. I've made it in Fl studio.

gr proxy

Tumbleweed 18th Sep 2012 20:31 - 13 years ago

on Pages of my past featuring Farisha Haque by RichieWinn

Man Richie...every one I listen to I thing..this must be your best one yet,...and then you keep topping yourself...I can only echo the many compliments you have received..this is just a superb bit of musical artistry...you do indeed set a standard that many of us would wist to strive towards...all the best on your move mate.....Ed

RichieWinn replied 19th Sep 2012 - 13 years ago

Hi Ed

Always good to hear from you. Thanks for the support on this and your comments are so rewarding. Whenever I put a new track together it is always a voyage of discovery and I'm never too sure where it will lead me. I've said it before - my function is to get the very best platform I can for the vocal and trying to keep on top of my game a challenge I will never tire of.

Dismantling the studio today, packers in next Monday, fly to UK Sept 28th. It's been a great two years. Looking forward to another adventure in England!

Best regards

Richie

Tumbleweed 14th Sep 2012 03:32 - 13 years ago

on The shadow box by lofthouse

the word epic came to mind when I first hit play...then it kicked in to the main verses...the emotion of the music and vocal really comes through in this one...really well done lofthouse...Ed

lofthouse replied 14th Sep 2012 - 13 years ago

Wow!Epic.Sounds so good-like something from a movie!
I put my heart and soul into this one and your comment made me feel so good!
I;m so glad you like the vocal,as that is really what I do, and appreciate that you mentioned it!
Your comment is appreciated.Thanks for listening and giving me the faith that someone is out there,listening and caring!
Love always.
g.xxxxx

Tumbleweed 11th Sep 2012 22:18 - 13 years ago

on Delicate Journey by Spidey77

Its just good listening music in any category you put it in Spidey77..The processed beats moved the more ambient keys and pads along really nicely...enjoyed the listen very much...well done....Ed

Tumbleweed 9th Sep 2012 05:20 - 13 years ago

on People Help The People by shibbyco

It not only sounds decent...it sounds dm good shibbyco...excellent job on the vocal..comes across very expressive & on the money....well done...Ed

shibbyco replied 9th Sep 2012 - 13 years ago

Thanks man! I was concerned that the vocals might have sounded to cheesy or fake or forced, but yay!

Tumbleweed 7th Sep 2012 02:52 - 13 years ago

on Kaj - Something New by KnoppKnopp

very chill KnoppKnopp...nice easy listening & reallu like that big subby bass...well done...Ed

Comments 1301 - 1325 of 1,619