Tumbleweed

Regina, Canada

Joined : 26th Nov 2010 - 15 years ago

Last Online : 2nd Oct 2026 - 5 days ago

Loops Out

Tumbleweed comments on tracks

Tumbleweed has posted 1544 comments on other peoples tracks.

Comments 1151 - 1175 of 1,544

Tumbleweed 4th Mar 2013 02:13 - 13 years ago

on Mambazo Africa by Proxy

I think the North African drumming first caught my attention when I discovered Loreena McKinnett`s music...Years ago we went to see "The Blue Nile" at the Imax here and I could just have closed my eyes (in spite of the great visuals) and listened to the music....This is a great track Proxy...quite minimal but with everything it needs to take the trip....much enjoyed......Ed

Tumbleweed 27th Feb 2013 03:10 - 13 years ago

on Drift Wood by BlackKasper

when I need some education in Techno I`ll be back over this way BlackKasper...I haven`t done a real techno mix but I quit paying attention to genres when looking for good beats a long time ago so I have more than a few from my techno folder in other types of tunes...This one says you got a good fix on not just the genre but the whole compositional thinking....nicely done...Ed

Tumbleweed 26th Feb 2013 20:31 - 13 years ago

on Aghalee-Tumbleweed-janis71 by janis71

janis71....thank you so much for doing this one...it was a very ordinary little piece of music until you raised it to the heavens...and I am very proud of you...and to have been a part of your musical journey....now its my fav all time Celtic song....(Loreena would be jealous)......Big Thanks....think I will post a little note in the forums.....Ed

janis71 replied 4th Mar 2013 - 13 years ago

Thank you Ed for the joy I had collaborating with you on this musical jewel ! It brought so much oxygen and peace in my chore ...
I found beautiful pics of Aghalee here :
http://www.flickriver.com/places/United+Kingdom/Northern+Ireland/Aghalee/search/
among which some with "swans swimming so boney" ... as Loreena sang !
I'm very touched, honoured and proud of this song we made . Thanks from the depth of my heart, my dear friend .
Big hugs,
Janis ;)

Tumbleweed 26th Feb 2013 16:27 - 13 years ago

on Kimbo by gator

sweet sounding guitar & played with feeling gator....could have kepp listening for a long time...keep on...looking forward to the final...really well done here....Ed

Tumbleweed 26th Feb 2013 01:19 - 13 years ago

on White Wedding - COVER - feat Mark Ratcliffe by JoyfulWAVE

Hey....way to go guys...grea5t job on this one...andf Mark does have the vocal chops to do this kind of stuff...just used the original in a video sound track a while back....could have used this one instead....well done...Ed

JoyfulWAVE replied 3rd Jun 2013 - 13 years ago

thx for your comment :) ...yes...mark did a great job on this one...

Tumbleweed 23rd Feb 2013 20:39 - 13 years ago

on The Minimal Baker - Chill Vibes by broekhoven

yes...have to agree with you...even though it is repetative...there is just something catchy about that little (dropped key) guitar bit...enjoyed the listen...Ed

Tumbleweed 21st Feb 2013 20:36 - 13 years ago

on Bohemian Grove stone owl mix by brillbilly

big long wind up....then off we go...even got some the my ol frozen parts going brillbilly..and lifted me out of a dreary feeling spot...good on ya....thanks man...great stuff...I am going to appoint myself president for life of something one of these days....Ed

brillbilly replied 22nd Feb 2013 - 13 years ago

Thank you Ed

Im just glad i dont believe in owls,lol

thanks for your kind words.!

peace and warmer weather i wish for you!

Tumbleweed 21st Feb 2013 20:24 - 13 years ago

on admiration of the nature by deciBel

Nature is a great inspiration for music everywhere on our little planet...It is often mine too benham.....this one with the flute and piano is very calming...something we could all use at times....well done...Ed

deciBel replied 23rd Feb 2013 - 13 years ago

Regards Ed & I'm glad to see you too love nature like me , I believe in nature more than any theory like god or killer allah Ed .& I've felt the beauty of life in nature .
great appreciations for your paying attention & taking time & listen to & commenting on it man .
Best wishes for you.

Tumbleweed 19th Feb 2013 19:05 - 13 years ago

on Nella Fantasia-My little version of it by janis71

Janis71...those good comments you hear are not flattery...they are fact...You have amazing vocal character and talent...This is just superb and I have insufficient words to express how impressed I am and how enjoyable this song was........Ed

janis71 replied 19th Feb 2013 - 13 years ago

I was just mailing you, Ed, and sending you a little draft ... Wow, that's telepathy !!!
Aw ... you can't imagine how much your words move me, Ed ... !
Coming from such a gifted musician as you and a so nice person, they touch me a lot ...
I did my best with the tempo, t'was quite hard to stick to it but I sang it with my heart and all this song was telling me .
Thank you very very much my friend for leaning on the Frenchie amateur I am .
Bises ;)

Tumbleweed 18th Feb 2013 17:41 - 13 years ago

on Burning Bridges by TheBedlamKids

You have a whole lot of talent going on here BedlamKids and it sure shows in the results..some thoughtful composing...really works where the heavy rhythm guitar drops out & the vocals over the cleaner chord prog sail for a bit...Its just an all round excellent bit of musical art guys...everything in here shines (great drums) and Pete is (as usual) just exceptional...Beautiful production work by Mahloo13 just gives it that extra special polish....congrats...super job....Ed

TheBedlamKids replied 18th Feb 2013 - 13 years ago

We're so thrilled you've liked it Tumbleweed!!! Thanks for stopping by and commenting on the track that means a lot to us.

Cya around mate,

TBK.

Tumbleweed 16th Feb 2013 02:44 - 13 years ago

on torture in Islamic Republic prison by deciBel

Hi behnamzandi...about your guitar question...the music conveys very personal feeling for you...so you are the best one to decide about that...perhaps a few short ambient guitar lines would bring some different feeling into the music...but..that is best decided by you....I am not trying to avoid the question...I`m just not sure....Try it and see how it comes out.....Ed

deciBel replied 16th Feb 2013 - 13 years ago

Dear Ed, thanx for your paying attention , & I've done some try on it by my electric Guitar , & would be happy if I may
send them for you by email & know your Idea about such guitar lines . ( of course depend on your time & premittion )
regards
__BehnaM

Tumbleweed 13th Feb 2013 20:40 - 13 years ago

on torture in Islamic Republic prison by deciBel

definitely conveys the darkness behnamzandi...music is often able to do that much better than words...well done....there is much evil in the world disguised as religion...Ed

deciBel replied 15th Feb 2013 - 13 years ago

Regards in first ,dear Ed , I'm glad to read from you as I've been told before too .
& I just can uphold your words about religion & also methodists & also about the strenght & power of music ,
+ & appreciate you for taking the time to listening to my music trials & commenting .
+
Ed I was thinking about some Elctric Guitar melody (a short but proper solo )to accompaniment the words of the my
instuments( notation), but I had no Idea ,
Do you think this track needs any Guitar solo & I should still try on it to have a better pronunciation about the torture trauma ? or not,& you think that this track was completed & enough ?
,

Tumbleweed 13th Feb 2013 18:55 - 13 years ago

on Im Okay version3 by bmarty24

Hey.....great job guys...the sax really add a bit of a different vibe and you did a super job on it bmarty24...really enjoyed this one....keep on.....Ed

bmarty24 replied 13th Feb 2013 - 13 years ago

Thank you very much Ed. This was a fun one to play to. Soren did an excellent job with this one!

Marty

Tumbleweed 12th Feb 2013 02:18 - 13 years ago

on until by thyroid

thyroid.....I`ve liked all of your tracks that I have listened to and this one is no exception...thoiughtful composing and you develop some really nice progressions in your music...really nicely done...enjoyed the listen again...Ed

thyroid replied 13th Feb 2013 - 13 years ago

Ed, thanks for listening and stopping by, glad you are enjoyed
this track. appreciated my friend

Tumbleweed 12th Feb 2013 02:00 - 13 years ago

on spankin the plank by gator

and a dm good blues feel too gator...great job...gets top marls from this ol guy & much enjoyed...keep on doing it & I`ll kleep on tuning in....ED

Tumbleweed 12th Feb 2013 01:56 - 13 years ago

on Unoffical Looperman Blues Revival Project by Thethanx

probably wouldn`t have found this one except for the forum post update by 3rd NippleMusic...just had to log in to say a well done & urge you to keep on doing it...we could use more of the bluesy goodness.....keep on & I will keep listening...Ed

Tumbleweed 9th Feb 2013 22:51 - 13 years ago

on hello space by doudei

it evolves along very nicely doudei...I know what you mean about snare sounds...I probably spend more time trying to find the right one that most anything else when I`m making a noise...enjoyed this one as it is though...nice laid back tune & good listening....well done...Ed

doudei replied 25th Mar 2013 - 13 years ago

thanks a lot for your nice comment Ed and sorry, i missed it!
glad you enjoyed though :)

Tumbleweed 8th Feb 2013 03:44 - 13 years ago

on Good Old Days by austinmusic

Man this is just top notch austinmusic....was listening to a few tracks and just had to log in to leave you a well done on this one....superb job all round...lyrics..vocal delivery & harmonies...accompaniment....production....You got it all right here ...One of the best I`ve heard in a very long time....standing ovation from this ol guy who had listened to a lot of music......Ed

austinmusic replied 8th Feb 2013 - 13 years ago

Thank you so much! That really means a lot!

Tumbleweed 5th Feb 2013 23:41 - 13 years ago

on Close my eyes so I can see by avasuzanne

beautifully done 3v3sound...very heartfelt indeed and I must say I like it just as it is, with the piano accompaniment...thanks for the DL, may see if I can add some noises that wouldn`t screw it up....Ed

avasuzanne replied 6th Feb 2013 - 13 years ago

thank you so much; would love to hear your version :)

Tumbleweed 5th Feb 2013 02:13 - 13 years ago

on Reflections On A Theme by ShortBusMusic by musiclover38

We can`t go wrong when our friend Bear is at the keys musiclover38...I really have to commend you for the way you wrapped this one up so perfectly and just let the instruments carry us along for a great ride...really nice work on that short but oh so sweet guitar solo...many of us tend to clutter the music with all kinds of things that don`t really add to what is so real about it...Kudos to you on the thoughtfuilness and musical skill that went into this one....it shows & I hear it.....Ed

musiclover38 replied 5th Feb 2013 - 13 years ago

Hi Ed, and once again Thank you for your kind words. Makes me wan't to try harder evert time :-)

Tumbleweed 4th Feb 2013 21:18 - 13 years ago

on Just another mindfunk by doudei

catchy funk there doudei...and I seem to still be ok. (thats just a personal opinion) after listening...good one...much enjoyed...Ed

doudei replied 6th Feb 2013 - 13 years ago

hehe glad to hear that :D
cheers for the kind comment!

Tumbleweed 4th Feb 2013 21:09 - 13 years ago

on No No by Master04

really hits the groove when that bass kicks in....nice job on the key changes...good one Master04....Ed

Master04 replied 5th Feb 2013 - 13 years ago

Thx !

Tumbleweed 3rd Feb 2013 21:15 - 13 years ago

on Padded Ambition by bmarty24

Oh man....this is feeling music...dispensed as only a pair of talents like you and Bear could...so I`m sitting here this Sunday afternoon feeling like I just discovered a precious gem....man this is just so dm good....fantastic piece of musical art bmarty24 & bear....You`ve got me motivated to don my music hat again & put the thinking part into gear...thanks for the download...I`m going to be listening to this one a lot more....Ed

bmarty24 replied 3rd Feb 2013 - 13 years ago

Well thank you Ed... I don't know what to say. If you are inspired and motivated to play after listening to this piece then I guess it moved you? Greatest compliment a musician could ever want.As far as being a talent like Bear... kinda of doubt it on my end, but thank you again!

Marty

Tumbleweed 3rd Feb 2013 20:54 - 13 years ago

on Guitar and afro flute trial - crystal by deciBel

behnamzandi....this is the kind of music that for me paints pictures in the mind....it needs no words for the instruments carry the feeling and the message....very thoughtful composing by you and very clean sound...I like the way it builds up and evolves along...with changes that hold attention and change the feeling and the pictures...I agree fully with our friend Bear`s comments....This is your best one...it is music that has no boundaries...it sounds good anywhere on our little planet....very well done...really enjoyed this one...You are accomplishing your goals......Ed

deciBel replied 3rd Feb 2013 - 13 years ago

really great thnx Ed,
I feel fulling of energy when reading such coments from one of my favorit musician & guitarist U are ,I just can say You know your idea is one of my most important coments (as dear Bear ),I think this track presents one of my favorite styles in my music trials .& thanx Ed because of your attention .
really I'm learning everyday here in looperman
& I wish to improove my music perception every day .
great regards man , & thnx for learning me with your attention.

Tumbleweed 2nd Feb 2013 02:59 - 13 years ago

on Rockin Blues by Randall822

about time we had an upload in the blues genre....and this is a dandy Randall822...good listening over my way....well done....Ed

Randall822 replied 3rd Feb 2013 - 13 years ago

Hi there Ed,

Thanks for your listening to and commenting on my latest Blues instrumental. Mostly I do Country and Rock, but now and then I get an idea for a song and the Loops I found helped me put it all together.
I'll check out your page and see what you have up.

Thanks again.
Randy

Comments 1151 - 1175 of 1,544