Tumbleweed

Tumbleweed

Regina, Canada
Joined : 26th Nov 2010 - 15 years ago
Last Online : 2nd Oct 2026 - 4 days ago
Tumbleweed comments on tracks

Tumbleweed has posted 1544 comments on other peoples tracks.

Comments 626 - 650 of 1,544
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 24th Nov 2014 19:33 - 11 years ago

on Tearing MySelf by samern
Welcome to The Loop samern...I am sure you will find good musical friends here....I am always interested in hearing the compositional thinking, arrangements and special elements that musicians from different parts of our world bring with them...you do it well...I do not listen to a lot of metal rock but I do really like groups like Nightwish (Norway) that bring the melodic approach to it...Goth rock...I enjoyed this one...you have obviously put a lot of thought into making it not just metal...but melodic metal..good job....Ed
samern
samern replied 24th Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
Thanks friend. Your words mean too much for me
I hope to have your notices always..
with appreciation
Samer N
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 23rd Nov 2014 17:12 - 11 years ago

on Day Four ft Effluence by Eighteen
nice intro build...good clear production Eighteen..well done...Ed
Eighteen
Eighteen replied 23rd Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
Thanks man, I appreciate.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 22nd Nov 2014 22:33 - 11 years ago

on Pink Boots by silverman
hell yeah...thought The Doors were going to start playing along with that intro bass line..meaty stuff with extra protein...your mama dont dance & your daddy dont rock n roll kind of feel but this one drives along with better power that gets the parts moving...there are a crazy bunch of people doing this...wish I was there...party on...love it silverman.....I`ll be back for more....Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 22nd Nov 2014 03:11 - 11 years ago

on HARLEQUIN by Planetjazzbass
Well Dave....you dont post as often as many of us (me in particular) would like...but when you do..man you just raise the bar...I`m not really sure what to even say about this one...for me, its an example of what might be accomplished when a group of fine musician /composers/ producers get together and build the music with thought and patience...(I`ll have another chat with myself about my lazy habits..but it hasnt worked before)...let me just say I enjoyed this one immensely...and I raise my glass in respect to all of you..(its just beer but I like it)...great stuff mate....Ed
Planetjazzbass
Planetjazzbass replied 22nd Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
Hey Ed...aahh mate your way too kind!..I'm definitely going to be lifting my musical output and want to explore more orchestrated pieces soon with extended acoustic backgrounds...it's heartening to hear a fine musician like yourself enjoying this piece,I was a little concerned it was too haphazard and all over the shop,maybe it is! haha...again thank you for taking the time to listen,I'll be heading down to your page for some Canadian 'windage' (I'm not absolutely certain what this actually means but someone said it in Full Metal Jacket in reference to whiskey and I thought it was cool! lol)..cheers mate Dave :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 22nd Nov 2014 02:24 - 11 years ago

on Signs--Feat--Danke by soundhound
danke seems to have a way of keeping things fairly simple yet grabbing your attention...and I think you have kept that approach going here TG...When I think of the songs that have stuck in my hear for years a big majority of them also have that same quality...you do it well my friend...I never stop by your place without being impressed and well entertained...great stuff..and delivered to my speakers just the way it should be.........Ed
soundhound
soundhound replied 22nd Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
Thanks...ED
I just tried to stay as close, as I could to him wanting to play that thing
or feel that he didn't play but belonged there from an artistic view of
the chord pattern...That's how I do it anyway...Easy Big formulas sound
better as well, simple to maintain the harmonics of the tune...with sustain...
The bounce guitar is just dancing with the hithat...
ED....It's nothing but some music, when you run into something that is fun
to do....Then it becomes a treat and a pleasure...

Thanks again for stopping in, both Danke and I are glad you enjoyed this...

Peace...TG.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 21st Nov 2014 01:17 - 11 years ago

on Off To Pandora By EazyBeatz by EazyBeatz
Trying to create a mind picture with just the music...compositional thinking...is great fun & something I love to try to do myself EB..I sometimes think that music can communicate more than words...and you do it well.....this is one cool trip...carried that vibe you describe really well...nice mix of genres (which we shouldn`t pay attention to when we are creating stuff...we can figure it out later)...nice upbeat vibe...so maybe there is hope for us on Pandora....see you there.....Ed
EazyBeatz
EazyBeatz replied 22nd Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
Thank you Tumbleweed very much on that very well though out comment. N yes thank you for noticing the truest sense of my style. Helping the listener to " Visually Hear" with little words n sound effects is something I'm trying to master. I'm only peaking into the beginning of this style but I promise I will be the best! I really want to bring something almost like Opera and modernize it. In other words, very intense story with little or no words. Except my style enhances sound effects as well so that the listener can almost feel a " First Person Feeling" (almost like if you are in the song) I know this might sound all weird, but this is what I do to keep my uniqueness . Well sorry for the long talk and thanks once again Ed. Take Care -EazyBeatz :)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 19th Nov 2014 20:49 - 11 years ago

on See Through by MisterBloodworth
I echo Orlando`s comments Ookami...very proficiently played and very enjoyable listening...I think piano is a wonderful instrument and to my taste it stands perfectly on its own as well as in the company of other instruments...I dont have a good piano vst myself (and I do not play keys well enough to invest much in one)..I often use the piano sounds in my old Alesis QS6 synth (sample based) that I have had since the late 90s...very nicely done...keep them coming...Ed
MisterBloodworth
MisterBloodworth replied 15th Dec 2014 - 11 years ago
Thank you for your comment. I really do enjoy seeing words such as yours. Take care.

~Ookami
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 19th Nov 2014 19:57 - 11 years ago

on Do you hear the sounds - featuring Farisha by clindsay
Hi clindsay....I really like the way you have left the vocal clear and uncluttered here plus mixed in the additional vox parts....even better is the fact that leaving out the drum stuff allowed the vocals & choir to create their own rhythm...very cool indeed....great job my friend really enjoyed what you have done here and the sensitive way you developed the composition...take a well deserved bow....Ed
clindsay
clindsay replied 19th Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
Thanks Ed - I'm glad you liked this - I think it works but it is definitely different from my other tracks. Farissa made it easy and it kind of wrote itself.
-clindsay
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 19th Nov 2014 17:05 - 11 years ago

on Into the Scene by kdlucas
yes...very cool chill with a nice R&B kind of vibe that reflects some of your influences kd....enjoyed this one...your music deserves much more attention & many more listens my friend....you do it well......Ed (that little warbly vocal bit around 1:28 do sound a tad perculiar..is that the way it was sung?)
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 19th Nov 2014 16:59 - 11 years ago

on untitled suite by promenade2239
Hey Alex....definite fav here...love the cool yet funky vibe and the way you fused the instrumentation & beat together...I like the first 2 sections best I think but the whole thing is good listening in my book....more of a Latin vibe to the second section I think...while the 3rd part reflects more of a jazz vibe....It is a very unusual compositional approach to include the distinctively different styles in one mix...but it certainly makes for a most interesting listen...
promenade2239
promenade2239 replied 19th Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
thanks a lot Ed. really glad you liked this compilation. I agree - it's quite unusual and doesn't necessarily make sense as a whole stylistical suite of pieces. At least that way I could upload more tracks I made recently...
I am happy you enjoyed different vibes of these 4 tracks - I appreciate your listening and nice comments. Thanks again, Alex
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 19th Nov 2014 02:44 - 11 years ago

on Green Shuffle Aka SCCM by Orlando51
Hi Orlando...well, I finally trying to do a little catch up this evening...so just had to stop by with my thanks...Once again you demonstrate the power of collaborative ideas...and when my own efforts fail me you have that special talent to take things another step forward....It is always a pleasure and I always enjoy the result as well as the process...and as always your talent and creativity shine....Ed
Orlando51
Orlando51 replied 19th Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
Thank God, Ed...I was afraid you have already frozen somewhere
in that cold weather in Canada...haha...all good then.:)
I think we had really good collaborative vibrations this time, so I have to say my sincere thanks back, cause this would never happen without your generosity on one side, and your musical excellence on the other...yes, as you say it's always a pleasure, so I'm looking forward for the next one.:)

Stay tuned______Orlando
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 19th Nov 2014 02:21 - 11 years ago

on Our Way - Featuring Kara Hesse by Musicante
you sure have one talented group of musicians in this one M...and it shows in the result..This is the kind of jazz that has a wide appeal for musicians of all genres....fantastic work and a big well done on the production too.....Ed
Musicante
Musicante replied 22nd Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
Thank you so much, Ed. We appreciate your kind words given to our little international group. Look for more of this line up along with other fine musicians.

Ciao,
M.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 15th Nov 2014 04:32 - 11 years ago

on All I See Is You by JodyJames
very nicely done Jody....hope you find a good R&B style vocalist (if thats what you are looking for)...Ed
JodyJames
JodyJames replied 15th Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
Thank you Ed.......I think I have someone for this =)

I appreciate the feedback

enjoy your weekend

Jody
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 13th Nov 2014 02:31 - 11 years ago

on I wish I could fly promenade remix III by promenade2239
you really have a nice mix going on this one Alex..especially like the piano.....I`ll have to check out crucethus`s mix again just for fun...but this is very cool.....Ed
promenade2239
promenade2239 replied 14th Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
thanks a lot Ed.
The short, isolated piano notes from the beginning are sampled from the crucethus's song. I played also some smooth chords and repeated piano one note motif in the second section using 4Font Piano plugin adding simple but really nice bassline at the same time. This track was definitely inspired by beautiful pads from the original and I used them a lot when making this version of the remix.

Glad you liked my production - I appreciate your comments. Alex
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 11th Nov 2014 21:55 - 11 years ago

on Opioid by StaticNomad
you know I love guitar Static...but the bass work in this one really grabbed my attention..I picked up bass in the 60s (influenced mainly by Chas of The Animals) & played a few years with my Brothers band when I wasn`t making a noise with my own group...always loved that walking around melodic bass style & you have loads of it going on here...the length does indeed make it a bit epic but you seem to use good glue to make it flow through the changes well..that little drop that starts around 5:10 is a fav bit...so is the whole funky vibe of the track...must say I enjoyed the music big time..and that is of course always a metter of taste....I wont comment on the mix detail as I try to do so when I might be able to offer a suggestion on how someone could do what they are trying better/more effectively...not sure when I could do that here...its your music Static...and even though I seldom listen to real lengthy mixes...you do it well.......Ed
StaticNomad
StaticNomad replied 17th Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
Hi. Sorry for slow reply.

Lots of audio and synth parts in this were made way back around 2002. One of many projects sitting on successive hard drives waiting to be completed as I go through software updates, new gear and techniques and the eventual return to the desire to begin working on them again.

The best bass playing that you're talking about is all from all those years ago. Some fun funk there, for sure.

I actually started out as a bass player in my teenage years but became much more of a guitarist after about 5 years and that's my main skill these days. I don't play bass often though I also often go a week or two without recording (perhaps even picking up) any of my guitars.

5:10 I thought that section might be one of the weaker ones here. It's definitely quite a change from what's preceded it.

Here's a much more recent funk track containing quite a bit of bass guitar.

http://www.looperman.com/tracks/detail/160058/comment-reply/506654

And I'm trying to complete a new epic that is probably my greatest ever funk track. Lots of bass guitar in that one too. It's called Bright Side Of The Sun and is coming soonish to The Loop.

P.S. Anyone's free to make suggestions about my stuff. So much going on that I totally appreciate all the other ways that it could have been done. Or could still be done! I do occasionally go back and change things based on/inspired by people's suggestions or criticism.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 11th Nov 2014 21:15 - 11 years ago

on Maybe Now by clindsay
that pella is working really well the way you have it in here clindsay...this is a mover and then some...the higher synth pads make it uplifting kind of bouncy stuff & them stabs are great..the outro drums caught me a bit off guard...if you keep doing this I`m going to have to start listening to a lot more of the genre than I sometimes do...great job....Ed
clindsay
clindsay replied 11th Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
Ed - thanks so much - you could be a professional reviewer. I tried several outros and this was kind of the default considering that this is supposed to be a dance track and lead into the next track. Thanks for the detailed response!
-clindsay
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 11th Nov 2014 21:07 - 11 years ago

on New Original - Feedback Needed WIP by Axion
not really enough to give some informed feedback Axion...but I think you are off to a good start...not my genre so my feedback would likely not be really useful...if you wanted some feedback on mastering...I would definitely recommend you put all the detailed work you can into the mix itself first..EQ, Comp on the individual tracks that need it etc...volume automation to keep the interest etc...mix it down to a new stereo track when its as good as you can get it...and consider Mastering as a separate process...I have beem using T-RackS since version 1..new version has some presets that might be useful (as a starting point only)...but I would suggest you master in a new project that allows you to apply the few main mastering plug-ins you will need..mastering is experience based and does requiire you invest in knowledge/education in the fundamentasl at least....keep it going....Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 8th Nov 2014 02:56 - 11 years ago

on revenir by domr30
This is definitely one of your best domr30...it has a very professional sound and is beautifully mixed/produced....much better that many of the songs I hear on my radio....bravo mon ami....much enjoyed......Ed
domr30
domr30 replied 8th Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
merci tumbleweed pour ce commentaire qui me touche un passage radio ce serais bien merci encore une fois domr
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 8th Nov 2014 02:24 - 11 years ago

on Tournament by Byleth
lots of tension....action.....a bit ominous..dangerous......if thats what you were going for I think you nailed it right on ant4505.....could be the soundtrack for a gladiator movie...it certainly is different...and that is a good thing....a big well done to you.....Ed
Byleth
Byleth replied 8th Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
In a gladiator match I think there are some tension,action and certainly dagerous so its that I wanted to create in a music. I think I did it well. Also a big thanks you ED for this comment
Tumbleweed
well ProgRockDan.....Patricia deserves the finest of accompaniament...and you do it well...this one has a splash of motown and bit of ye good olde R&B when it was real R&B...a sprinkle of gospel...a touch of blues...maybe its its own genre but its great listening over my way this evening...good job...enjoyed it......Ed
ProgRockDan1
ProgRockDan1 replied 7th Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
ED, thank you for visiting. I was working at staying true to her original vocals. I thought they had a splash of motown, a bit of R&B, gospel, and her own unique touch. I'm glad you appreciate what I did with it.
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 7th Nov 2014 01:49 - 11 years ago

on I Wish I Could Fly by crucethus
If I could fly...something like this would be the accompaniment...gliding smoothly...then swooping up in the current...the special attractions of the landscape that grab the attention for a few moments....its a great trip Steve....wonderful mind pictures painted by one hell of a fine artist.....Ed (PS:your versatility is showing again)
crucethus
crucethus replied 7th Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
Thank you Ed, I had a moment of artistic indulgence and I started to realize that my work around here may not be mainstream, but is a appreciated as a "Musicians musician". For that I am humbled and extremely grateful. Versatility is just my wanting to explore every nook and cranny of music. That curiosity keeps me going.
Slainte my friend.
Steve
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 6th Nov 2014 16:29 - 11 years ago

on Barrancas by TheSavage
I have always felt that the cinematic and ambient genres offered the greatest creative scope to musicians/composers..the challenge of creating the soundscape, implied melodies & vibe that conveys mind pictures...I would just as soon listen to this kind of music without the video as the mind just seems to automatically script the scene & feeling..those choir like pads give it a kind of majestic/mysterious vibe...I dont often listen to almost 12 min tracks unless they are backing a video/movie...but this one kept me listening until the end (cool outro section)...well done TheSavage.......Ed
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 6th Nov 2014 16:13 - 11 years ago

on Leverett - Glue by Leverett
deep and smoooooth Leverette...you made it an interesting listen with the breaks/drops & changeups..guess I`m pretty old school as I usually as I often unplug from electronic mixes that hold & repeat the same chord prog all the way through...but I enjoyed this one....well done to you..nicely produced too.....keep on....Ed
Leverett
Leverett replied 4th Dec 2014 - 11 years ago
Thanks a lot
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 5th Nov 2014 03:20 - 11 years ago

on Someone Waits by bbedford48
Fantastic bit of musical creativity here...a beautiful journey as it turns out...that sort of parts company with its original self around the 2 min mark...music with feeling that conveys some interesting/peaceful mind pictures...standing ovation from an old guy up in Canada.....Bravo.......Ed
bbedford48
bbedford48 replied 5th Nov 2014 - 11 years ago
Thanks Ed.
I wondered if this piece went to too many places! Gave me a big boost that someone of your great ability liked this
Bob
Tumbleweed
Tumbleweed 3rd Nov 2014 02:04 - 11 years ago

on One With The Stars EazyBeatz Edit by EazyBeatz
any time you plug in with Pete you are definitely off to a running start EB....the processed drums are really prominent but go great with the whole vibe of the track...you take it to a new place ...and aint that the beauty of collabs...when you can multiply the talent and combine ideas with fellow talents....very nicely done...enjoyed this one big time......Ed
Comments 626 - 650 of 1,544