Ok you got me at gothic 3;) Your style reminds me so much of Edwyn Collins. See all the great that comes from experimenting? I'm going to have to watch some John Carpenter movies when I get home tonight. Been listening to a ton of gothic metal instead of watching movies lately.
I only know one song by Edwyn Collins and that's "Never met A Girl like You", so he must be influencing my style through some kind of musical voodoo. Remind me to put a circle of salt around my mic stand.
And you should definitely watch some John Carpenter tonight. In my opinion, The Thing is the best horror movie ever! Have fun :)
I'm not a Madonna or MJ fan but huge respect for such influencial artists! I love hearing different artist's take on famous songs, well done TA :D Ever hear Billie Jean on cbg? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=raD72-8PYrk
"Please don't think that I am dismissing you right of the bat. It's something i will think about."
Not at all, TA. I totally get it. I've got quite a stockpile of tracks that are as "finished" as I was able to get them, but that might or might not benefit from adding something more. I suspect that when, as is your case, you have lyrics for a song, it is more likely that you will have said everything you want to say in the song, and adding more could just detract from it. Most of the tracks I do never get bounced out of Logic. Those that do get bounced I put into a playlist in my iTunes library (not published on iTunes) and I go back and listen to some of them periodically just to see if I'm inspired to tackle them again. So, far, revisiting old tracks is a rarity for me. So, yes, I completely understand your point. I'm just glad you didn't take offence at my comment. Was worried you might misinterpret it as a criticism, rather than a vote of confidence. :)
Very nice song. You do really good vocals. Not sure if you actually sound like Jim Morrison, but your voice has a very nice quality and it shows on this track.
There are some things I'd revisit in the arrangement, but I have to say that the modulation to F# minor at 1:23 really took me by surprise and and it was great! I also like the way you built up the track as it progressed, adding more and more to enrich the sound.
My final parting comment on this track is that this is very, very good, but it left me wanting more of a good thing. I think you should seriously consider extending the song and working up additional section(s) with a different chord sequence (i.e., a chorus, perhaps a bridge).
I'm not sure what the sequence should be (I would never have thought of the modulation to F#-) but to maintain interest, it should not repeat the pattern of shifting down and up a major second interval, which is the main sequence found in both the sections of the song now.
EDM can often get by with little variation in chord sequences throughout the entire track. In fact, that's often a key feature of EDM tracks and I guess that's part of what makes them effective for dance music. But, this track of yours is definitely not run-of-the-mill EDM.
Of course, I'm not one to talk. In my tracks, I rarely get past just doing verses. :)
Anyway, this track has so much potential I just had to encourage you to develop it further.
Hi Eric. First of all, thank you for your detailed response. It's always encouraging to know that someone has engaged with the music enough to elicit a constructive response. Secondly, I too have thought about the potential that the song could have in a longer format. However, I don't know if I can do the rest of the song justice by extending it. Sometimes you make a song and you get to a point where you've said everything you have to say. Anything I add might actually reduce the songs impact as a whole.
Please don't think that I am dismissing you right of the bat. It's something i will think about. maybe i will revisit it later with fresher ears and get some inspiration. Maybe I'll just keep it as it is. Who knows what the fickle muses hold for us? Thanks again man.
So, TA, I haven't listened to all of your tracks, but so far this may be my favourite. Not that I don't like your vocals. I really like them a lot. But I think this track actually could handle vocals as well. Might need to scale back a bit on the dynamics, but I "heard" vocal melody lines in my head as I listened to it. Very nice indeed!
This has a very raw, live and organic sound and feel. I love acoustic guitar songs, good decision to team up with your friend. I was really enjoying it but when the drums kicked it gave the song such an uplifting feeling to a rather sullen song. Strangely your vocals reminded me of Jim Morrison of the Doors and the song in some ways reminds me of some of their songs so well done on mixing the vox and the how they transition into the more upbeat part.
Thanks man. Not sure I see the Jim Morrison vocal comparison. But I can see how the first half has that raw improvisational sound. Thank again for listening and for your kind words.
Dig that acoustic intro a lot...( a bit of a Southern blues vibe to start with)....the vocal fits to a T....I wanted to stand up and cheer at that little neat key change around 1:22...subtle but most effective...unsure how to describe this one but I gotta say I am absolutely impressed my friend...its got a kind of a folky vibe and is one of those little songs that just seems to wrap itself around your mind and carry you along...something we would all wish to accomplish.....Bravo....big fav from across the water....Ed
Not gonna lie, I was listening to the beginning and I wasn't expecting to hear vocals. But when they came on, they surprised me. In a good way. Just like the piano transition. That really is a beautiful addition to this piece. It took me thru a range of emotions in such a short time span. Which I like. Keep up the good work. Sounds good on my monitors. I can tell you're in an open room recording, or you have a heavy room reverb. Peace & Blessings.
Damn fine job in this intro. Timing issues sound like two guitarists playing together without a metronome.
Vocals are haunting and very storyteller like. Reverse elements are pretty well placed and rather effective. This is like a sad moment sung by a soul in limbo.
All I can add is that you should continue this with some new additions. Give us another minute or two. Good stuff. Not polished, but I think some things are better patinated.
on Endless Nostalgia by toastedavalanche
And you should definitely watch some John Carpenter tonight. In my opinion, The Thing is the best horror movie ever! Have fun :)
on Frozen - Madonna Cover by toastedavalanche
Steve
Oh and I love Madonna and MJ ;)
on Frozen - Madonna Cover by toastedavalanche
Cru
on Frozen - Madonna Cover by toastedavalanche
TA
on Frozen - Madonna Cover by toastedavalanche
Hats off, Danke
on Frozen - Madonna Cover by toastedavalanche
Good job man !!
on Seasons by toastedavalanche
Not at all, TA. I totally get it. I've got quite a stockpile of tracks that are as "finished" as I was able to get them, but that might or might not benefit from adding something more. I suspect that when, as is your case, you have lyrics for a song, it is more likely that you will have said everything you want to say in the song, and adding more could just detract from it. Most of the tracks I do never get bounced out of Logic. Those that do get bounced I put into a playlist in my iTunes library (not published on iTunes) and I go back and listen to some of them periodically just to see if I'm inspired to tackle them again. So, far, revisiting old tracks is a rarity for me. So, yes, I completely understand your point. I'm just glad you didn't take offence at my comment. Was worried you might misinterpret it as a criticism, rather than a vote of confidence. :)
on Seasons by toastedavalanche
TA
on Seasons by toastedavalanche
TA
on Seasons by toastedavalanche
There are some things I'd revisit in the arrangement, but I have to say that the modulation to F# minor at 1:23 really took me by surprise and and it was great! I also like the way you built up the track as it progressed, adding more and more to enrich the sound.
My final parting comment on this track is that this is very, very good, but it left me wanting more of a good thing. I think you should seriously consider extending the song and working up additional section(s) with a different chord sequence (i.e., a chorus, perhaps a bridge).
I'm not sure what the sequence should be (I would never have thought of the modulation to F#-) but to maintain interest, it should not repeat the pattern of shifting down and up a major second interval, which is the main sequence found in both the sections of the song now.
EDM can often get by with little variation in chord sequences throughout the entire track. In fact, that's often a key feature of EDM tracks and I guess that's part of what makes them effective for dance music. But, this track of yours is definitely not run-of-the-mill EDM.
Of course, I'm not one to talk. In my tracks, I rarely get past just doing verses. :)
Anyway, this track has so much potential I just had to encourage you to develop it further.
Please don't think that I am dismissing you right of the bat. It's something i will think about. maybe i will revisit it later with fresher ears and get some inspiration. Maybe I'll just keep it as it is. Who knows what the fickle muses hold for us? Thanks again man.
TA
on Run Until Your Lungs Give Out by toastedavalanche
on Seasons by toastedavalanche
TA
on Seasons by toastedavalanche
Well done!
Wayne
TA
on Seasons by toastedavalanche
the mood you get in your songs are very close to me...little pessimism, downtempo, minor chords, melancholy and a good voice...
hats off and fav of course, Danke
:)
on Seasons by toastedavalanche
on Seasons by toastedavalanche
Peace
on Seasons by toastedavalanche
TA
on Seasons by toastedavalanche
And you are correct, that is a heavy room reverb. I wanted it to feel more like I was singing in a big room on my own.
Thanks again,
TA
on Run Until Your Lungs Give Out by toastedavalanche
Wow wow wow mate.
It is brilliant piece of music.
I love not on the intro but the whole of the track.
Really Well done mate.
Jamid
on Run Until Your Lungs Give Out by toastedavalanche
handshake, Danke
on Run Until Your Lungs Give Out by toastedavalanche
on Run Until Your Lungs Give Out by toastedavalanche
I could see the potential for this track to be used in a movie some sort.
Overall a nice cinematic piece well done toasted :).
on Run Until Your Lungs Give Out by toastedavalanche
-WeinerBob
on In Space by toastedavalanche
Vocals are haunting and very storyteller like. Reverse elements are pretty well placed and rather effective. This is like a sad moment sung by a soul in limbo.
All I can add is that you should continue this with some new additions. Give us another minute or two. Good stuff. Not polished, but I think some things are better patinated.
Evan
on The Waltz of Regret by toastedavalanche
Really nice ballad, i appreciate musicians whose work is full of sensitive.
respects
Bleep