Menu
blackryan

blackryan

space, United Kingdom
Joined : 7th Mar 2009 - 16 years ago
blackryan comments on tracks

blackryan has posted 356 comments on other peoples tracks.

Comments 101 - 125 of 356
blackryan
blackryan 23rd Sep 2010 13:00 - 15 years ago

on We re all people people by bobbybooth
Liked this JB. Reminds me of a more ambient Substance era New Order. Have a listen to their track Thieves Like US on Youtube. Either the original or the instrumental version. I think you'll see where I'm coming from. Was'nt overly keen on the change in direction half way through. Maybe that's just me?

edit - sorry ur not jb, ur bb!
bobbybooth
bobbybooth replied Unknown
Jesus - you are right. That intro is very reminiscent. i love new order so thats a great compliment. Thanks man!
blackryan
blackryan 23rd Sep 2010 09:51 - 15 years ago

on FREEDOM FIGHTERS by JONEVZ
RR, don't know the orig track but I thought this flowed well. I'm guessing that the source material is of good quality. I may have to get my hands on that myself. Good job.
blackryan
blackryan 17th Sep 2010 16:06 - 15 years ago

on Bangin by Enhouse
As the name suggested it certainly is bangin. I would say it's techno tho? Really nice to hear someone on hear going for the underground sounds. The only thing I would suggest is a bit more variation on the perc and drums. Good work.
blackryan
blackryan 17th Sep 2010 11:33 - 15 years ago

on She's Blue Tonight Chilled Remix (DV8) by celestial1157
I like the additional production on this remix. It's such a great tune. Like the perc.
blackryan
blackryan 17th Sep 2010 10:25 - 15 years ago

on War (The State of the Union) by Thethanx
Essentially it is a Dub track but I think some of the loops you have used make it some sort of dub/fusion hybrid. I think some of the early reviews hit the nail on the head. Needs some deep bass and needs a load of fx in various places. Fx loops and individual notes. Mix up the fx you use for variation. Experiment with panning. Overall the levels need a good tweak. Not too shabby though for your first dub. Good effort.
Thethanx
Thethanx replied Unknown
dub/fusion I can live with. Took your advice and added a bassline, used an itouch app called argon synth. also added some fx as well. Unfortunately, one of the limitations of beatmaker is how fx are handled, and panning as well. I Think beatmaker was more designed with a live production sort of mindset, and if you want to adjust panning on a loop or section for only a short section, It's only possible live. Same with applying fx, when I add an fx (and I only have 2 channels) it affects the loop in EVERY section, unless I make a copy of the loop and waste one of my precious 16 available pads on a clean version as well.
I'm curious about the levels as well. I'm quickly discovering getting good levels is one of my weaknesses, probably due to inexperience and shitty headphones... So even just some "turn the bass up a bit, and the drums down" type advice would go a long way. Thanks again!
blackryan
blackryan 16th Sep 2010 13:06 - 15 years ago

on So Blue by Nightingale
Yeah I really like this. Very minimal approach. That droney noise makes me want to lie down and close my eyes. Nice job.
Nightingale
Nightingale replied Unknown
Thank you. Very much.
blackryan
blackryan 14th Sep 2010 11:09 - 15 years ago

on rub a dub dub (mostly finished) by Warptone
Not too bad. Has potential. Levels need a major tweak. Bass needs to come forard and that main synthy type sound needs to sit back. A bit more dubification would be good too. Drop the beat in sections and the bass in other sections.
Warptone
Warptone replied Unknown
thx man,really helpfull advice
blackryan
blackryan 10th Sep 2010 10:16 - 15 years ago

on Degalvyi by Bioscape
Lovin this J. Very floaty just the way I like it. This is the best thing I've listened today.Liked the subtle panning and all the sound used.
Bioscape
Bioscape replied Unknown
thank you for listening and the nice complements
blackryan
blackryan 10th Sep 2010 10:10 - 15 years ago

on Plankton by jfw
Great piece of work Jamie. Floatastic!
jfw
jfw replied Unknown
Many thanks for the listen - appreciated!

Jamie.
blackryan
blackryan 10th Sep 2010 10:08 - 15 years ago

on Snakes by swanse
Lovin this. Weird noises blended together over the top of that beat. A real experimental feel which I like. Certainly different!
blackryan
blackryan 7th Sep 2010 11:20 - 15 years ago

on Evening Breeze by SimonVHimmel
To me it sounds like slowed down trance rather than deep house. Although the production sound is clean the track is very one dimensional. I think your track would be more interesting if there was more variation and/or some more unusual sounds and/or fx. Don't be afraid to experiment rather than play safe.
blackryan
blackryan 7th Sep 2010 10:10 - 15 years ago

on Parallel worlds by smallpaul
I think you've done really well here SP. A very mellow type of house. The instrumentation works really well. I could imagine it being built up with a full on Diva singing over the top of it. Good job!
blackryan
blackryan 5th Sep 2010 17:59 - 15 years ago

on beddington belly by jahknow
Yeah I'm havin some of that one! I love dubbed house and techno and this one works a treat. Don't need to tell you what's good about this track as u already know.
jahknow
jahknow replied Unknown
Thanks Ryan. Glad you liked it.
blackryan
blackryan 5th Sep 2010 09:20 - 15 years ago

on Resonance ( Second Try) by ELLEPROJECT900
I love the atmosphere created here. I think u need to make some adjustments to the levels. That percy sound needs to sit back a bit in the mix. More dubstep than dub. I think some additional dubby effects on individual notes would work well as the track progresses. Don't know if you had a chane to check out the dub logbook in the forums.Some great pointers in there and worth checking out.
ELLEPROJECT900
ELLEPROJECT900 replied Unknown
Thanks a lot, great comments. I will check dub logbook.
blackryan
blackryan 27th Aug 2010 11:04 - 15 years ago

on Alexei Scutari - Seasonal affective disorder by Scutal
30 downloads and 1 review - that's not right??? Great track. Maybe more chill house than ambient. Flows well and has a really nice vibe.
Scutal
Scutal replied Unknown
Thanks!:)
blackryan
blackryan 26th Aug 2010 10:24 - 15 years ago

on Fetter by MattHyde
Hey listened twice just to be able to leave a decent review. Firstly let me say I think parts of the track are really beautiful. When the synth with the heavy delays comes in conjunction with the vox is great and the whole mood of the track really compliments the sentiment in the vox. Couple of little things I would look at is the scratching type effect which is out of time. It might be meant to be like that I don't know but to me it was a bit off putting. When a lot of the sounds drop off there is a beat that continues but it sounds like a click and again could be accidental? If so, strip it out. If you do tinker with it let me know. I'd like to hear it. Oh, and it's a download from me. Good job my man.
blackryan
blackryan 25th Aug 2010 16:33 - 15 years ago

on Human Motivation by RickMal
Liked this groove once that pella was out of the way at the start. The bass is great and hold everything together and the little glitchy vox snippits are cool.
RickMal
RickMal replied Unknown
thanx for that blackryan,,i agree bout the pella man,but that was the foundation of this beat so i had to keep it in,,mal
blackryan
blackryan 25th Aug 2010 13:54 - 15 years ago

on Roots by ULTRAPHONICS
I agree with Frank. It has a summery feel. Not too far away from being a really good track. If you still have the parts I'd be happy to give it a dub remix. Lemme know.
ULTRAPHONICS
ULTRAPHONICS replied Unknown
Thanks for the review, I've sent you a message with a few details.
Cheers

-SK-
blackryan
blackryan 24th Aug 2010 19:10 - 15 years ago

on DarkDubMatter by Dubmusiclover
Yeah! Nice perc. Nice dropouts and delays and bass! All good. Melodica sitting on top is sweet. Good job.
blackryan
blackryan 24th Aug 2010 10:58 - 15 years ago

on Rumba de Flauta Magica (Pedro Martins Remix) by PedroMartins
Liked the beat straight off. Not the sort of house I would play but i think it's quite good and has a commercial appeal that would make it popular.
blackryan
blackryan 24th Aug 2010 10:25 - 15 years ago

on Time Line by Gsusfrk
I seem to recall saying the same thing about another one of your tracks - hard as nails. I don't listen to much dnb these days but I can appreciate that ur tracks are less formulaic than some of the stuff on here and u put a lot of thought into the piece.
Gsusfrk
Gsusfrk replied Unknown
Thank you Ryan, that means a lot because I really do try to strive to make my songs unique and different from those of other people that make, as you said, formulaic songs.
Thanks again, and I'll hit one of your songs up,
Steve
blackryan
blackryan 23rd Aug 2010 08:55 - 15 years ago

on ZION DUB by JONEVZ
I notice u seem to get a lot of lurkers listening to ur tracks as opposed to more established members. I can only think that is why the reviews are low. Good job. Has a bit of a Thievery Corp feeling.
JONEVZ
JONEVZ replied Unknown
Hello mate u back from ur hols.
yeah al my effort goes to reverbnation.com/theriviera rockers as i feel this site don't realy apprAciate my DUB.BUT I'M 173 IN THE REGGAE CHARTS FOR THE UK ON THERE AND MY FAN BASE IS GROWING BY 4/5 PEOPLE A DAY AND MOST FROM JAMACIA AND USA. I PUT UR TUNE UP ON MY SITE FOR U. RR
blackryan
blackryan 20th Aug 2010 11:53 - 15 years ago

on Gville Sound by White Trash by RasJB
Ok lets start with a positive. I really like the bass. It has a nice happy summery vibe. I think you hit the nail on the head with some of the other points. Overall there is a dullness. The sound qaulity is lacking some clarity and oomph. I think the bare bones are there to make a nice track. I accept that the vocal was freestyled but if you're gonna do it again you have an opportunity to improve that area. Maybe work with a singer instead?
RasJB
RasJB replied Unknown
I absolutely agree with everything you said. The guy rapping has never been much of a singer (he's more of just a musician) and I think that would really set it off if we had one. Other than that it was pretty much made for fun and I had a blast doing it. I really appreciate your review and hopefully I will get better from here ;)
blackryan
blackryan 14th Aug 2010 11:11 - 15 years ago

on LET IT PLAY (DUBWIZE SELECTOR by JONEVZ
I'm listening on a really kak set up at my parents house. I'll try and listen when I get home. Liked the flute and horn parts. Everytime I listen to ur tracks I'm impressed with the sounds you've gathered and I think man I'd love to remix that one.
JONEVZ
JONEVZ replied Unknown
Thanks for your review,Glad you like it ..if you want to remix it go to it man. respect RR
blackryan
blackryan 12th Aug 2010 13:09 - 15 years ago

on MAJESTIC LION(RUDEBOY MIX) by JONEVZ
Not too far away from being a really good track. I think it needs a bit more variation in places to keep it interesting and I think it needs a bit of widening or depth? I don't know if you know what I mean but it seems to be lacking a little oopmh. I think it could be ripe for some blackryan dubment!
JONEVZ
JONEVZ replied Unknown
IF U CAN LIFT IT THEN U HAVE MY SAY. I KNOW WHAT U MEAN.. I AM LIMITED IN THE GEAR I USE. BUT I DON'T DO TO BAD ..RR
Comments 101 - 125 of 356