Whoa! This thing is killer man! Super nice work with those drums/fills that makes all the difference in making it sound real and professional in my opinion. The guitar work is really good and the mix is very clean! You guys should keep collaborating and be a"virtual band"! :) Thanks for sharing this!
I'll start by saying that Country isn't my first choice of genres to listen to, but I can certainly appreciate the musicianship on this track. It's a nice song for sure. My only suggestion might be that the lead vocals seem just a little too low in volume compared to everything else, and perhaps a touch too wet, a little too much reverb perhaps? And maybe the backup vocals can stand to come down a touch in volume as well? Not sure. Just a thought. Thanks for sharing this!
Loving the sound of your bass guitar here! I'm also digging your intro/build up too. For my ears though I wonder if you were able to change up the velocity of hi hat stokes? To me they all sound too similar and it feels a little too machine like, unless that was an intentional choice. I also feel like the vocals maybe don't quite fit with your track, they feel almost like an afterthought. That's just my opinion of course. :) I really like your track though and think maybe a few tweaks here and there would make it even better. Thanks for sharing!
hey todd! thank you so much for the great feedback, man. i’m pretty primitive, you know, and sometimes that’s a favorable attribute and then sometimes it just ain’t. with the hats i was aiming for an eno-type ‘rhythm bed’ to underpin what i wanted to be overtones. my reach far exceeds my grasp. ah, but i am in love with the pellas, it’s my setting that does the disservice.
OH SNAP! That quaint little cafe in Paris turns out to be the site of the most diabolical plot hatched against society of all time!!! Call in TEAM AMERICA....F YEAH! :) All joking aside, this is really good. Great build up and ramping up constantly. This seems like it's going to be a "typical" suspense scene cue, but THEN the electric guitars hit and a double bass drum! :) Great work thanks for sharing. I hope they catch those bad guys! ;)
Thanks dude! I've never been good at building a song without some sort of tempo structure, which is probably why I can't do the ambient cinematic stuff too well. Probably will attempt it sometime soon. Thanks for the review!
I think Arloph09 is essentially saying something similar to what I suggested, which is get more low frequency instruments involved in your track. Most likely a bass instrument, somewhere in the 30-50 Hz range (low end). Also the "boom/thump" from your kick drum would most likely sit in the low end too, somewhere around 50-100Hz or so.
Hey there. I like your intro although I think you can probably mix it up a little instead of repeating the exact same piano notes over and over. I feel like your piano overall is too loud in the mix and the vocals need to be louder in the mix. Overall I think you're missing some low end, maybe some more bass or 808's tastefully placed. Maybe a little more "boom" out of your kick too? Just some ideas, I'm kind of a newb so maybe don't listen to me. :) I think you could work this track a little more and it will shine even brighter. Thanks for sharing.
I love pretty much anything that takes a unique or at least not a straight forward approach to percussion. I love what you've done with the rhythm here! Bass sounds nice too. Have you considered putting some vocals over it, or other sound samples? I really dig this a lot. I feel like you may be able to push this even further if you wanted to. Thanks for sharing!
Thank you for this constructive criticism, I appreciate it very much. For the moment I only produce instrumental but I plan to add voices to it in my next prod.
This is really cool. I like the way the two vocals go back and forth and blend. Catchy track. Maybe wish it was a little bit longer perhaps, and my only other comment which is just a suggestion, maybe the vocals can be a touch louder in the mix, or bring the instruments down a touch when the vocals are present. Just an idea. Thanks for sharing this!
Damn this thing moves! Nice driving track, certainly has a "party" vibe to it. Good arrangement and song structure too. Thanks for sharing this upbeat track!
This is really well done man! It builds really nicely and the movement seems to always being going forward. The lullaby part could have come off as "cheesy" but you handled that beautifully in my opinion. Everything feels on point. My only suggestion would be to try a slightly bigger finale note. In other words this feels a little like it ends with a period instead of an exclamation point. I think if your very last note were a big "boom" maybe with a little cymbal action it would feel more like a completion of something if that makes sense. I'm sure you had your reasons for ending the way you did but just thought I would throw out the idea in case you didn't already try something like that already. GREAT work, thanks for sharing.
This has a nice beat going and I'm digging it. It does seem repetitive though. Can you add an intro/break/another part etc. to it? Sounds like it may want some vocals over it too. :) I think this is a great start to something. Thanks for sharing.
Great use of sounds/builds/stereo mix and yeah pretty much everything. I really liked it, felt like a rich environment. Do you make any money from these types of things? Just curious. Thanks so much for sharing.
Hey thanks for the nice comments. In short, all of the "noise" I make is mostly for videos I produce, as most of them end up on youtube I decided to start releasing the music through "distrokid" to try and generate a little ad rev through their royalty collection on youtube.
On looperman I don't earn anything, I started posting unreleased and now the last few are released, with the hope that maybe they end up out there in a cool video or something. I hope that answered your question ;)
This was fun to listen to, great job! The robot sounds JUST like this app I used to have on my iPad called "Bebot". If you never heard of it check it out, I think it's still free. I've been meaning to use that app for a track and this has inspired me to. Thanks for sharing!
Hello friend, thank you for your review and for the interesting information. To make this song I used a fantastic low cost cell phone synth called Heat Synthesizer.
Best wishes
I did the exact same thing a little while ago. I took an old track I made about a year ago and remixed it just to hear the difference and it was a positive experience. Sounds like you had the same outcome, that's awesome. Any chance you can post a link in a comment to the original mix for comparison? Thanks for sharing!
Nice job! Good mix, and great stereo sounds happening from left to right! My personal feeling is that your first drop works better than your second one. To me the second one feels "unsatisfying". Your build up to 2:09 sounds like it's going to drop and then when it doesn't it feels kind of flat to me. Could just be me but feel like 2:09 to 2:13 could be taken out or reworked. I also think you might be able to add a little "sumthin' sumthin'" to your middle section too, not sure what though. Don't get me wrong this is an excellent track, just trying to offer some suggestions. Thanks for sharing!
Thanks for the listen, I took a bit of a risk with the buildups trying to be a bit different. I rarely make this genre so I'll definitely take your words into consideration.
I like this beat a lot! I like the use of the "ding" and the other samples you've put together here. The volume seems to be an issue though, it seems fairly faint to me. Is that by choice? Just curious. Great work and thanks for sharing this!
This is super sweet!!! I think with ambient tracks like this its hard to get someone to really listen to the whole thing. I think we've become so click antsy and want things to happen quickly. This forces you to slow down. I closed my eyes and it was a nice little calming vacation for my brain, so thank you! I only suggestion from a conceptual stand point might be to play around with how your arrangement changes when the rain stops. In other words, maybe going heavier on the dramatic "sad" parts while the rain is in the background, and then when the rain stops it opens up just and becomes a little more upbeat "happy"...not much but enough to notice. It may conjure up more feeling from the listening and put them in that space more. Just a thought. Great job with this! Thanks for sharing it!
Awesome layering, arrangement, use of sounds. I like when tracks use a dense layer of sound sources BUT not making the song feel cluttered. You have achieved that. By the end of the song you really had me going, but then it ended. :) Have to listen again. Great work on this! Thanks for sharing.
I know what you're saying, but something feels "unsatisfying" about it to me. Here's another idea/thought. What if you leave it the way you have it but add just one extra beat then cut them off? So, it sounds like you are ending on the "4". But maybe try cutting them on the 1 of the next measure instead? In other words one extra kick drum on the 1 as well as one extra note from your synth then let them cut out and come back where you have them still. Make sense?
Overall I really like what you have here. The intro has a super nice build to it. I didn't lose interest which sometimes happens with intros. Ok, so this is just my opinion nothing more, but I felt like that "arpy/wah wah wah" sound that cuts out briefly at 1:02, I find myself MISSING it. Have you tried the same arrangement but instead just cut the drums out briefly instead? Might be worth a try. Same thing at 1:33. The vocals are cool but for my taste perhaps just a touch too much reverb/delay? Overall though I think you did an excellent job with this! Thanks for sharing. Hope I was somewhat helpful even if you decide you don't agree with what I said. :)
thanks for the feedback! I see what you mean at 1:02/1:33, i guess the idea was to give the first beat maximal impact but i could try keeping the synth linne. Also yeah the voice is super reverby probably should tune it down a bit.
This has SUCH a nice feel to it! I like the chill lope but it still grooves. I love the lyrics, how they were recorded, backups, and how they all sit in the mix. What I really like is how "real" the lyrics are. In other words it's not all "hard guy/tough stuff" which to me mostly comes across as phony anyway. So awesome job on this man! Is this the final mastered version? It maybe feels like it can stand to open up a little? Thanks so much for sharing this gem!
Hey Todd, thank you for your feedback, I'm glad you liked it.
It's funny about the mix, the part with the male vocals were done about a year ago. Completely done and sent out to an engineer to mix.
Due to the virus, the female part had to be recorded...get this...on an iPhone in like a day.
Then I got those vocals and had to get it to sit properly on the already exported original song (so I couldn't mess with the levels of the male vocals and the instrumental).
With about a week before it was due, I had to put on my hard hat and this was the version I ended up with lol. I think it came out decent but you're right, it would be dope to get her in a real studio to re-record and we can remaster the song some time in the future.
on Control by Neomorpheus
on JULY 4TH by terryjmhitsong
on portals of light by xstokes
on Rise of a Villain by Centrist
Thanks dude! I've never been good at building a song without some sort of tempo structure, which is probably why I can't do the ambient cinematic stuff too well. Probably will attempt it sometime soon. Thanks for the review!
on Distance feat MansasWorld by Uwillneverknow
on Distance feat MansasWorld by Uwillneverknow
on hot bass riddim by Caly97Music
on SENMI by varyaris45gmail
on Just The Way By AAP Ft Leo Valentine WeWaji Remix by WeWaji
on Promises feat Patricia Edwards by Micky
Peace
on Striking With These Daggers by StrikingDaggers
on Infinity by Centrist
on desert wind by 19wickbrim
on GetOuttaMyHead Remix AAP featuring Leo Valentine by djphildrummin
on Sense - Lucky Number Eleven by Sense11
On looperman I don't earn anything, I started posting unreleased and now the last few are released, with the hope that maybe they end up out there in a cool video or something. I hope that answered your question ;)
on JaniMilfsson SWAY by djphildrummin
on The revenge of Bokrug by Stereonomicon
Best wishes
on Taco Tuesday With The Martians by ClickbaitCabaret
https://www.looperman.com/tracks/detail/201345
on Equinox - Rise by 0Equinox0
on Freddie dredd like beat by Odrumbeatz
on The smell of rain by Zivonmusic
on Feel Free by theSINGLOT
cheers
on Fractal Geometry by giuliomusic
on Fractal Geometry by giuliomusic
on Last Summer Remix by TheFemiFactor
It's funny about the mix, the part with the male vocals were done about a year ago. Completely done and sent out to an engineer to mix.
Due to the virus, the female part had to be recorded...get this...on an iPhone in like a day.
Then I got those vocals and had to get it to sit properly on the already exported original song (so I couldn't mess with the levels of the male vocals and the instrumental).
With about a week before it was due, I had to put on my hard hat and this was the version I ended up with lol. I think it came out decent but you're right, it would be dope to get her in a real studio to re-record and we can remaster the song some time in the future.