Menu
throughthevalley

throughthevalley

mcallen, United States
Joined : 5th Sep 2010 - 15 years ago
Comments on throughthevalley tracks

Other users have posted 63 comments on tracks by throughthevalley

Comments 51 - 63 of 63
DeadPixel
DeadPixel 7th Dec 2010 01:03 - 14 years ago

on i shut my eyes by throughthevalley
Nice soundscapes you've created here, definitely hearing more of the sonic youth inflence here, reminds me a bit of animal collective too. I love the vocal fx, real unconventional, I dig it.

Kevin
throughthevalley
throughthevalley replied Unknown
thanx bro i appreciate it especially comparing me to bands i look up to.its good to know somebody actually gets my music.
Mrbillionx
Mrbillionx 5th Dec 2010 00:16 - 14 years ago

on pride before the fall by throughthevalley
Has a good feel to it just needs a bit of something to pep it up.
throughthevalley
throughthevalley replied Unknown
i agree im just kind of stuck.hopefully it will come.thx bro.
Hetman
Hetman 4th Dec 2010 13:18 - 14 years ago

on completion is sure by throughthevalley
I love the collaboration of this strange and menacing melodie and your kind of singing...
Gonna listen to this song drunken, I´m sure it will be an awesome feeling ;)
throughthevalley
throughthevalley replied Unknown
thank you my friend enjoy the ride!!
DeadPixel
DeadPixel 4th Dec 2010 01:11 - 14 years ago

on CAROLINE by throughthevalley
Dig the noise, sorta reminds me of sonic youth or unsane...the vocals seem bizzare (in a good way) like something you'd hear from Psychic TV or Coil.
throughthevalley
throughthevalley replied Unknown
thanks for the compliments man i do bust out my old sonic youth cds all the time.
Glocke
Glocke 3rd Dec 2010 18:10 - 14 years ago

on completion is sure by throughthevalley
The problem I see is, that there is no fundament in this song without a bass. and that's a pity because it kills much atmosphere.
throughthevalley
throughthevalley replied Unknown
i heard ur track and your an excellent player.i wouldnt mind collaborating and having you add the bass if your up to it.
Glocke
Glocke 3rd Dec 2010 17:17 - 14 years ago

on completion is sure by throughthevalley
Hey, you made a nice piece of music. ;) It's not for everybody, sounds a bit psychedelic and strange sometimes but all in all nice.
some points for the next time.

- the sound qualitiy is really good, keep on doing like this!
- take more time to practise the guitar parts, some times it's not in time.
- where is the bass guitar?

but again, all in all it's nice. :)
throughthevalley
throughthevalley replied Unknown
thank you my friend for taking the time to listen and review.my music is usually not for everybody.lol.have not laid down the bass for it and am still learning to play and always forget what i just finished playing.
Angelus1818
Angelus1818 19th Oct 2010 23:10 - 15 years ago

on thinking of you by throughthevalley
Hey,

Well, first off, in my personal opinion you had way to many effects going on here. There is a saying in the world of producing when you apply to many effects to an acoustic piece, it's called "polishing a turd"

Now please keep in my mind I do NOT think your song "is crap" in fact the chords are nice, and I can tell it was hard for you to sing, but you did it anyway, so props there.

Another thing that really took this down was the guitar. It was out of tune, or at least one of the higher strings was. I couldn't tell what chords you were playing, beacuse of all the effects, but perhaps something like a D, it sounded off. This is normally not a problem in the world of music, just when you show other musicians your stuff, you have to the "ear" for it.

Overall I must give you props, but in my book, this needs some serious work. I know you stated it's not done, so I look forward to seeing the finished product.

-Angelus

P.S. I'm sorry if I came off mean, I wasn't trying to be.
throughthevalley
throughthevalley replied Unknown
wow your right i didnt even tune the guitar that day you have a great ear my friend.yes maybe one day i will finish this song(when i get better hahaha)thanks for the review i appreciate the honesty.
MStokes
MStokes 23rd Sep 2010 16:54 - 15 years ago

on a tragic collapse by throughthevalley
digging the arrangement and playing - the vocal perf is great - understated, real, wrenching - respect, appreciation for this work song
throughthevalley
throughthevalley replied Unknown
much thanks for the review means alot once again thank you.
DeadPixel
DeadPixel 18th Sep 2010 03:12 - 15 years ago

on FANTHEFLAME by throughthevalley
someones a mike patton freak jeez...lol nice work, maybe a collaboration is in order?
throughthevalley
throughthevalley replied Unknown
that guy is a genius lol thanks....lets do it send me the details for sure
AstralRaven
AstralRaven 14th Sep 2010 12:05 - 15 years ago

on pride before the fall by throughthevalley
Sounds slightly bland if i'm honest, i liked you're vocals although they need some work too. I liked the part at 3;06 when the song cut out and then kicked back in again. Good effort!
Broadydudester
Broadydudester 13th Sep 2010 20:38 - 15 years ago

on FANTHEFLAME by throughthevalley
Well I wont lie some of the singing vocals are a little rough, off tune in a few parts. But I do like the screaming parts. Overall pretty good. Thanks for using my song :)
Kikajon
Kikajon 9th Sep 2010 17:40 - 15 years ago

on through the valley by throughthevalley
Niiiice. Love it.
gastler
gastler 9th Sep 2010 07:05 - 15 years ago

on through the valley by throughthevalley
I like it dude. I has a very dynamic and emotional range. Keep pumpin' out the tunes on that Zoom!
Comments 51 - 63 of 63